Running Head: SESSION 4, RTI SYMPOSIUM 2003 SUMMARY 1
Session 4, RTI Symposium 2003 Summary
Angela Inkster
January 20, 2012
Simon Fraser University

Running Head: SESSION 4, RTI SYMPOSIUM 2 In 2003 The National Research Center on Learning Disabilities held a symposium on the topic of Responsiveness to Intervention (RTI), a model of early identification and intervention for children with learning difficulties. In Session 4 of the symposium presenters and discussants address the topic of how “unresponsiveness to secondary intervention should be operationalized in an RTI approach to learning disabilities”. The first presenters, Vellutino, Scanlon, Small & Fanuele (2003), distinguish between reading disabled and non-reading disabled children though early intervention in Kindergarten and Grade 1. The second paper, by Torgesen (2003), deals with issues of operationalizing RTI with older children. The discussant, Compton (2003), summarizes and comments on the findings of the presenters in Session 4, and draws a comparison of RTI to giving a child “a nudge”. “The nudge” is a metaphor he uses throughout his paper to refer to the extra assistance that some children require to be successful in school. While the first two presenters address the operationalization of RTI at different ages, all three papers are in agreement on two issues: first, that RTI distinguishes the role of experience from biology, and second, that more work is needed on RTI and the current protocol for learning disabilities in schools. Both Vellutino et al. (2003) and Torgesen (2003) use RTI as a model to identify children with learning disabilities, however, Vellutino et al. (2003) look at early intervention while Torgesen (2003) addresses reading difficulties at grade three and beyond. The focus of the interventions vary because age differences of the children studied. Both Vellutino et al. (2003) and Torgesen (2003) look at phonemic awareness, however, Vellutino et al. (2003) uses sound and word level measures with Kindergarten and Grade 1, while Torgesen (2003) focuses on comprehension with older children. Vellutino et al. (2003) are strong believers in early Running Head: SESSION 4, RTI SYMPOSIUM 3 intervention. Their study shows that early and ongoing testing,...

-108 -146 -171 -638 .. 1 137 157 162 18 1960 1996 2 20 2003 2005 2008 2012 3 39 4 49 601 88 98 abc abil abl academ accord account achiev across actual address adequ administ advantag age age-specif agre agreement al allow also altern alway angela appar approach area assess assist at-risk attent awar b back background base basic began believ benefit berman berrman beyond biolog broader burlington c canada canadian canter categori caus center challeng chang chen child children citi classifi classroom clear cognit combin comment common comparison comprehens compton concentr conceptu concur consid consist constitut construct continu contrast conveni convey core correl creat current d d.l deal decemb decod deficit defin definit deliv deliveri denckla describ despit develop diagnos diagnosi differ difficult difficulti disabl discrep discuss disord dissatisfact distinct distinguish district draw due e earli ed edit educ effect either element elementari elsevi end esl et ever evid exact exampl expect experi experienti explain extra f f.r fals familiar fanuel final find first fit fletcher focus franci fraser fuch g give good grade graham great group grow head held help high hoskyn howev i.e idea ideal identif identifi illustr implic import improv inadequ includ indic inform initi inkster instruct intellig intens intervent investig iq iq-achiev isol issu j januari journal k kansa key kindergarten know kozey l label late ld lead learn learner less level like longer look low lower lyon m ma make mani may measur metaphor method middl mo mock model morga much nation natur need negat non non-read nudg number often older one ongo operation opinion p paper period perspect phonem phonolog place point poor possibl potenti practic pratt present press prevent previous primari prior problem profil promis protocol proven provid provinc psycholog psychologist psychometr question r rais rang read reader readili reason receiv recent redefin reduc refer regular relat reliabl remedi requir research research-bas research-proven resourc respons responsiveness-to responsiveness-to-instruct responsiveness-to-intervent result risk role rti run sampl saw scanalon scanlon school score second secondari sent ses session sever shaywitz show siegel simon simpl sinc sipay skill small smaller sound specif spectrum stage state stem still strength strong struggl student studi stueb subsequ succeed success suffici suggest summar summari symposium teacher tend term territori test therefor though three throughout thus tier tool topic torgensen torgesen tradit train tutor two univers unless unlik unrespons use valid vari vaughn vehicl vellutino verbal way weak well well-know whether without wong word work would write year young