Essays /

Writing Essay

Essay preview

Questions 22 –29

In 1996, a leading academic journal of cultural studies, Social Text , published an article by a physicist named Alan Sokal. The article attacked the sciences for their ‘authoritarianism and elitism’ and argued, amongst other things, that physical concepts (ssuch as gravity) were essentially ‘social constructs ’. Subsequently, Sokal revealed in a rival journal that the article had been a hoax. In the following two passages Sokal and the editors of Social Text justify their actions.

Passage 1: Alan Sokal
Why did I do it? While my method was satirical, my motivation is utterly serious. What concerns me is the proliferation, not just of nonsense and sloppy thinking per se, but of a particular kind of nonsense and sloppy thinking: one that denies the existence of objective realities, or (when challenged) admits their existence but downplays their practical relevance. At its best, a journal like Social Text raises important questions that no scientist should ignore – questions, for example,about how corporate and government funding influence scientific work. Unfortunately, epistemic relativism does little to further the discussion of these matters. Social Text’s acceptance of my article exemplifies the intellectual arrogance of Theory – meaning postmodernist literary theory – carried to its logical extreme.No wonder they didn ’t bother to consult a physicist. If all is discourse and ‘text’, then knowledge of the real world is superfluous; even physics becomes just another branch of Cultural Studies. If, moreover, all is rhetoric and ‘language games ’, then internal logical consistency is superfluous too: a patina of theoretical sophistication serves equally well. Incomprehensibility becomes a virtue; allusions, metaphors and puns substitute for evidence and logic. My own article is, if anything, an extremely modest example of this well-established genre.

Passage 2: The editors of Social Text
Obviously,we now regret having published Sokal ’s article, and apologize to our readers, and to those in the science studies or cultural studies communities who might feel their work has been disparaged as a result of this affair. From the first, we considered Sokal’s unsolicited article to be a little hokey. It is not every day we receive a dense philosophical tract from a professional physicist. Not knowing the author or his work, we engaged in some speculation about his intentions, and concluded that this article was the earnest attempt of a professional scientist to seek some kind of affirmation from postmodern philosophy for developments i...

Read more


-2 1 12 1996 2 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 5 9.8 absolut academ acceler accept accord acer act action ad admit adventur affair affect affirm agre air alan allus along also alway amongst amount analysi anatomi angl anoth anyth apolog apologet appear appli approach approxim argu argument armada arrog articl asid ask assert assur astronaut atom attack attempt attribut author authoritarian avoid awkward b baccalaur background ball base becom behaviour best better billard biolog bother branch break brush bullet c calcul cannon captur car carder care carri case caus centr challeng chang characterist chemic chemistri claim collis combin come comfort comment common communiti complex compon comprehend concept concern conclud conclus condescend conserv consid consist constant constitut construct consult contain contradictori control corpor correspond cost could critic cultur cup curriculum curtail d daunt day death decept decis defi deni dens densiti depend depth deriv describ desir detail determin develop didn differ direct disciplin discours discov discuss disparag displac distanc distort document done doubt downplay draw drawn drop drop-off earnest earth eas easi easier easili editor eg either elit elitist elsewher embarrass encourag engag entropi epistem epistemolog equal equat equival error essenti establish etern even everi evid exact exam exampl execut exemplifi exist extrem f faith feather feel field fire first first-year flash flashcard float follow footnot forc forget foster found frequent friction fulli function fund fundament game gamsat genr get given glanc gold good govern graph gravit graviti greek ground group guard hand happen hard harmon higher hindsight hoax hokey honour howev humanist humbl humour i.e ice idea ignor iii imag imit imparti implement import impuls in-depth includ incomprehens inertia inexplic inflat influenc inform innuendo inquiri insincer intellectu intent interest intern involv ir iron journal judg judgement justif justifi kilogram kind know knowledg known label land languag laps larg largest latin law lead learn leitner length less level light like line link list literari littl ll locat logarithm logic long look lot low low-frict lower m ma made make mani mark mass materi math matter may mean measur medic memori memoris metafilt metal metaphor metaphysics.what meter method might model modern modest molecul molecule/conditions momentum moon moreov motion motiv move ms much name narrow natur necessari needless neglig newton non non-scientif nonsens normal notat noth notion number object obvious offer often one open opposit organ outdat par paraphras part particular passag patina pattern pc per perhap persuas philosoph philosophi phrase physic physicist pic place plausibl play point polit possibl post postmodern postmodernist pound practic precious prefer prefix present presum principl problem profession program projectil prolifer prompt proport provision publish pull pun push qualiti quantiti quarter question rais random rang rare rather reaction reactiv read reader real realiti realli rearrang reason recal receiv recent reduc refer regard regret relativ relev reli remain rememb repetit repres reput requir reson resourc rest result return reveal revisit revolv rhetor ride rink rival role root satir scalar scholar scienc scientif scientist score se second section section1 section3 see seek seen sens seri serious serv set shoot short show side sign signific simpl sincer singl sink skill sloppi slow small social softwar sokal solid someon somewhat sophist sort sound space specul speed ssuch standard state still straight studi subject submit subsequ substitut suggest superflu sure suspici suspicion syllabus symptomat system taken task tast tea teacher tenth term terminolog text theoret theori thing think third thought time time-honour toy tract tradit tri triangl trick trigonometri troy truck two type understand unduli unfair unfavour unfortun uni unintent unit univers unlik unnecessarili unsolicit unusu upon upward use usual utter v valid vari variat ve vector veloc virtu volum vulner wall wallpap warrant water way weigh weight weightless well well-establish well-known went wonder word word-root work world worth would write year