Essays /

Philosophers Contributing To Modern Government Essay

Essay preview

John Locke (1632-1704)
John Locke was a British philosopher, Oxford academic and medical researcher, whose association with Anthony Ashley Cooper (later the First Earl of Shaftesbury) led him to become successively a government official charged with collecting information about trade and colonies, economic writer, opposition political activist, and finally a revolutionary whose cause ultimately triumphed in the Glorious Revolution of 1688. Much of Locke's work is characterized by opposition to authoritarianism. This opposition is both on the level of the individual person and on the level of institutions such as government and church. For the individual, Locke wants each of us to use reason to search after truth rather than simply accept the opinion of authorities or be subject to superstition. He wants us to proportion assent to propositions to the evidence for them. On the level of institutions it becomes important to distinguish the legitimate from the illegitimate functions of institutions and to make the corresponding distinction for the uses of force by these institutions. The positive side of Locke's anti-authoritarianism is that he believes that using reason to try to grasp the truth, and determining the legitimate functions of institutions will optimize human flourishing for the individual and society both in respect to its material and spiritual welfare. This in turn, amounts to following natural law and the fulfillment of the divine purpose for humanity. Locke's monumental An Essay Concerning Human Understanding concerns itself with determining the limits of human understanding in respect to God, the self, natural kinds and artifacts, as well as a variety of different kinds of ideas. It thus tells us in some detail what one can legitimately claim to know and what one cannot. Locke also wrote a variety of important political, religious and educational works including the Two Treatises of Government, the Letters Concerning Toleration, The Reasonableness of Christianity and Some Thoughts Concerning Education.

The Two Treatises Of Government
The First Treatise of Government is a polemical work aimed at refuting the patriarchal version of the Divine Right of Kings doctrine. The Second Treatise of Government provides Locke's positive theory of government - he explicitly says that he must do this ‘lest men fall into the dangerous belief that all government in the world is merely the product of force and violence.’ Locke's account involves several devices which were common in seventeenth and eighteenth century political philosophy — natural rights theory and the social contract. Natural rights are those rights which we are supposed to have as human beings before ever government comes into being. We might suppose, that like other animals, we have a natural right to struggle for our survival. Locke will argue that we have a right to the means to survive. When Locke comes to explain how government comes into being, he uses the idea that people agree that their condition in the state of nature is unsatisfactory, and so agree to transfer some of their rights to a central government, while retaining others. This is the theory of the social contract. There are many versions of natural rights theory and the social contract in seventeenth and eighteenth century European political philosophy, some conservative and some radical. Locke's version belongs on the radical side of the spectrum. These radical natural right theories influenced the ideologies of the American and French revolutions. Locke defines political power to be a right of making laws with penalties of death, and consequently all less penalties, for the regulating and preserving of property, and of employing the force of the community, in the execution of such laws, and in the defence of the common-wealth from foreign injury; and all this only for the public good According to Locke, God created man and we are, in effect, God's property. The chief end set us by our creator as a species and as individuals is survival. It follows immediately that ”he has no liberty to destroy himself, or so much as any creature in his possession, yet when some nobler use than its bare possession calls for it.“ (II. ii. 5) So, murder and suicide violate the divine purpose. If one takes survival as the end, then we may ask what are the means necessary to that end. On Locke's account, these turn out to be life, liberty, health and property. Since the end is set by God, on Locke's view we have a right to the means to that end. So we have rights to life, liberty, health and property. These are natural rights, that is they are rights that we have in a state of nature before the introduction of civil government, and all people have these rights equally. I don't want anyone to violate my rights to these things. Equally, considering other people, who are my natural equals, I should conclude that I should not violate their rights to life, liberty, health and property. This is the law of nature. It is the Golden Rule, interpreted in terms of natural rights. Locke does not intend his account of the state of nature as a sort of utopia. Rather it serves as an analytical device that explains why it becomes necessary to introduce civil government and what the legitimate function of civil government is. Thus, as Locke conceives it, there are problems with life in the state of nature. The law of nature, like civil laws can be violated. There are no police, prosecutors or judges in the state of nature as these are all representatives of a government with full political power. The victims, then, must enforce the law of nature in the state of nature. But when the victims are judging the seriousness of the crime, they are more likely to judge it of greater severity than might an impartial judge. As a result, there will be regular miscarriages of justice. This is perhaps the most important problem with the state of nature. The institution of civil government comes about because of the difficulties in the state of nature. Rather clearly, on Locke's view, these difficulties increase with the increase in population, the decrease in available resources, and the advent of economic inequality which results from the introduction of money. These conditions lead to an increase in the number of violations of the natural law. Thus, the inconvenience of having to redress such grievances on one's own behalf become much more acute, since there are significantly more of them. These lead to the introduction of civil government. For Locke, legitimate civil government is instituted by the explicit consent of those governed. Those who make this agreement transfer to the civil government their right of executing the law of nature and judging their own case. These are the powers which they give to the central government, and this is what makes the justice system of civil governments a legitimate function of such governments. Locke is now in a position to explain the function of a legitimate civil government and distinguish it from illegitimate civil government. The aim of such a le...

Read more


-1679 -1704 -1809 -90 -95 1 10 11.4 11.6 1588 1632 1688 1689 1712 1723 1737 1755 1760 1762 1768 1771 1772 1774 1776 1778 1787 1790s 1791 1792 1793 1794 1802 1809 18th 2 2.1 28 29 3 3.1 3000 4 5 500 8 89 abandon abl abroad absenc absent abus academ accept accord account accur achiev acknowledg act action activ activist acut adam address advanc advantag advent affair affect afford afraid age agre agreement aim alarm alcohol alembert alien alleg allow almost alon alreadi also altern although america american among amount analog analyt anim annual anoth anthoni anti anti-authoritarian antithet anybodi anyon anyth appeal appear appli apprentic approach appropri april apt arbitrarili argu argument aristocrat aristotl armi arrang articl articul artifact artifici ashley ask aspect assent assess associ assum attack attempt august author authoritarian avail averag avoid await bad baker balanc ban bare baron base basi basic be beast becam becom began begin behalf behav belief believ belong benefit benevol benign benjamin best best-sel bibl bitter bodi book born boston bound break brethren brewer bridg bring britain british brought burden buri burk busi butcher buy call came camp campaign candl cannot capit career caricatur carri case cash caus center central centuri certain cf challeng champion chanc channel charact character charg chariti charl charles-loui check chief childless christian church circumst citizen civil claim classic clear close club coal collect coloni combin come commend commit commod common common-wealth commonwealth communiti compact compar compat compens compet competit complementari complic compos comprehens conced conceiv concept concern conclud conclus condemn condit conduct confid confisc conflict confus congress conscienc consecr consent consequ conserv consid consider consist constant constitut constrain construct consum content continent continu contract contrast contribut controversi convent convinc cooper copyright core corner correspond corrupt corset cost could council cours creat creation creator creatur crime crisi crusad custom d danger david day de deal death debat debt decemb decid declar decreas defeat defenc defend defens defin degre deism deist delic demand democrat deni depend depriv deriv describ deserv despot destroy detail determin develop devic devis devot diderot die differ differenti difficult difficulti diffid dinner direct dirti disagr discern discharg discours discrep disput distinct distinguish divid divin doctrin dollar drastic duti earl earn easier east econom economi economist educ effect effici eighteenth either elect els embark emigr emil empir employ empow encourag encyclopedia end endeavor enemi enforc engag england enhanc enlighten enorm enough ensur enter entiti environ envoy equal erron essay essenti establish esteem etern europ european even eventu ever everi everyon everyth evid evil exact exampl except excess excis exciseman execut exercis exist expect expend expens experi explain explan explicit export extraordinari extrem extremist fact faction fail failur faint faint-heart faith fall fan far far-forth farc farm father fear featur feder fell fellow fight final financi find first fix flourish foist follow forc foreign form former forth fortun foster foundat four fourth framer franc franklin fraud free free-market french frequent friend fulfil full function fund gain gave general generat generos generous genuin get girondin give given glori glorious go god golden good gospel govern grammar grant grasp great greater greatest grievanc gross ground group guid hand hangman hangmen happen happi hard hard-press harm head health heart heed help hereditari high higher histori hobb hold home home-consum hope horror hous howev human hundr hysteria idea ideal ideolog ie ii iii illegitim imageri immedi immers immin immor immut impact imparti imperi import impos imposs imprison improv incarcer includ incom inconveni increas inde independ individu industri inequ influenc influenti inform injuri inquiri insecur insight insofar inspir instanc instead institut instruct intellectu intend intent intercess interest interpret intrins introduc introduct invari invent invest invis involv iron issu jacobin jacqu jame januari jean jean-jacqu jefferson job john joint joseph journal journalist judg judgment judici judiciari june justic justifi keep kent kill kind king know labor lack laid last late later latter launch law lay lead leader learn leav led left legal legisl legislatur legitim less lesson lest letter level leviathan lew liber liberti life like likewis limit lincolnshir littl live local lock london long longer look loui love loyalist luxembourg m made magazin magistr main maintain major make maker man manag mani manifesto mankind manner mar mark market marri marriag mass materi maxim maximis may mean measur mechan medic meet member men mercantil mere met might militari mill million million-dollar mind mine minist miscarriag mislead misunderstand moder modern monarch monarchi money monopoli monro montesquieu month monument moral more-or-less motion much murder must myth mythic n nation natur naturalist necess necessari need neglect neither never new newton next nobler norfolk noth notion novemb number numer obedi obey object oblig obtain obvious occas occasion occup occur octob odd odious offic offici often old one open oper opinion oppos opposit optim order organ origin ostrac other otherwis ought outcast outlaw outlin outsid overrid overwhelm oxford p pain pamphlet pari parliament part parti particular passion patent patriarch pave pay peac pen penalti pennsylvania peopl perfect perform perhap permit person philadelphia philosoph philosophi pin play pleasur point polem polic polici polit poor popul popular pose posit possess possibl post poverti power practic preach precari precursor preserv press pretend prevent prey price primari principl prison privileg problem proclam produc product profit program promot propagandist properti proport proportion proposit prosecut prosecutor prospect protect prove provid provok public publish punish purpos pursu put quaker question quit radic rais rang rate rather ration re read realist realiz realli reason rebellion receiv recogn recompens reconcili redress reform refut regard regicid regul regular reject releas reli religi religion remedi rememb render repeat repres republ republican reput requir research resembl resist resourc respect respons rest restless restrict result resum retain return reveal revel review revolut revolutionari reward ricardo ride right rise road rochell role rousseau rule safeti said sake satisfi saw say scarc scholar school scienc sea search second secondat secur see seek seem seen self self-interest self-lov self-preserv selfish sell sens sentiment separ septemb seri serious serv set settl seventeenth seventi sever shaftesburi shall shklar shock shop shopkeep short shortcom show side sight signific similar simpl simpli sinc singl situat six sl small smith smokeless social societi soever sole someon someth sometim son soon sort sought sound sovereign sovereignti speak speci specif spectrum speech spent spiritu stake stark state still stint stori strongest struggl stuart studi subject success suggest suicid superior superstit suppli support suppos suprem surplus surviv suspect sussex sympathi system systemat tackl tactless take tavern tax teach teacher tell ten term terribl terror testament theori therefor thetford thing think third thoma though thought threat three threefold throughout thus time togeth toler topic tough town tract trade transfer transit treatis tri triumph trust truth turn two type tyrann ultim unabl unaccount unavail unconquer undermin understand unifi uniform unit univers unknow unlik unsaf unsatisfactori upon urg us use user utopia vain valu varieti various vehement version veto victim view violat violenc violent virtu virtual virtuous voic voluntarili vote wage want war wast way wealth wealthi weapon wear welcom welfar well well-b well-receiv whatev whether whole whose wide wield wife will within without won word work world worst worth worthwhil would write writer wrong wrote xiii.3-9 xiv.4 xiv.5 xvi year yet york