Essays /

Why Did The Labour Government Introduce Essay

Essay preview

Jamal Malik
Mr. Tuck
April 21, y

Why Did the Labour Government Introduce a Set of Constitutional Reforms After 1997? How well were they planned?

The Labour party grew increasingly concerned with constitutional reform when it occurred to them that the Conservative party had taken the baton of sovereignty between 1951-64 and 1969-97, and they were not returning it to the Labour party as often as Labour would have liked. As such, by the time the Labour party had returned to power with a landslide majority in 1997 under the leadership of Tony Blair, constitutional reforms centred around the modernisation and the democratisation of the constitution and the restoration of rights, had become part of their agenda. However, the main criticism against them is the unforeseen consequences they invoked, in addition the them having been incoherent, incomplete and unstable. The need to modernise aspects of the constitution was apparent to the Labour party for two reasons. Primarily, the House of Lords is anachronistic in nature, with too many hereditary peers; representing a long outdated system of hierarchy rather than modern meritocracy. Hence, stage 1 of Labour’s 1999 House of Lords Act removed all but 92 hereditary peers and left the chamber made up largely of appointed life peers. Although this legitimises and marginally democratises the second chamber due to life peers being nominated by the executive, it is inconclusive as a result of stage two reform aimed at rendering the second chamber more representative and democratic not having been completed. Additionally, this reform does not decentralise power in any way; perhaps even having the opposite effect. The Labour party also attempted to bring the UK constitution in line with other modern democracies with the adoption of the codified Human Rights Act in 1998. Despite it having been a significant s...

Read more


-64 -97 1 12 1951 1969 1979 1990 1997 1998 1999 2 2000 2002 2004 2010 2014 21 22 27 6 65 92 abil abl abu access account achiev act action actual addit administr adopt agenda agre aim al al-qaeda allow almost alon also although anachronist anoth appar appeal appear appoint april around aspect assembl attempt august base baton becam becom began behind believ belmarsh better bill blair block bring cameron case caus centr centralis certain chamber chang clear codifi coher committe common complet concern conclus conflict consequ conserv consider constitu constitut continu contrast coupl court creat crimin critic current david death decentralis declar deem democraci democrat democratis demonstr deport despit detent devolut devolv direct disclos discrimin due easili effect effort elect elector endors enough entrench erod european even event eventu exampl except exclud execut exposur extend extens extent fact factor far figur final first flaw foreseen freedom full fulli furthermor gain general give given go goal govern greater grew ground halfway halv hand held henc hereditari hierarchi homosexu hous howev human illeg immigr incoher incompat incomplet inconclus increas indefens independ influenti inform insignific instabl instanc institut instrument interest introduc introduct invok issu jamal judiciari labour lack landslid larg lead leadership left legal legitimis less lesser let liaison liber lie life like limit line local locat london long lord lost low made main major make malik mani margin member meritocraci mess minist minor modern modernis mr much multipl nation natur need neither nine nomin notabl notion occas occur often open opposit outdat overal parliament parliamentari part parti past patchi patchwork peer peopl perhap plan polit popular portion pose post potenti power precious presenc present primarili prime prior prison problemat produc proport prove public qaeda qatada question quo radic rather reach reason receiv recognis recognit reduc referendum reform releas remov render repeal replac repres represent restor result return right rose rule scotland scottish scrutini second see seen senior septemb set sever shift show shown signific sinc slight somewhat sovereignti spawn stabl stage state status still subject succeed success suffici support suspect system taken tenanc tenant terrorist therefor threat time toni tradit transfer trial tuck two uk ukip under-repres understand unforese unforeseen unrestrict unstabl upset use virtual vote wale want way weaken well western wherea wish without would y year