Essays /

Federal System Of Government Essay

Essay preview

Ahmed Said |
Federal system of Malaysia |
|
Master’s Of Public Administration & Management |
Ahmed Said Musse |
12/17/2012 |

|

Table of Contents
Introduction 2
Federalism 2
Malaysian Government Structure 5
Federal Government 5
Conference of Rulers 5
Monarchy 6
Federal Legislative 7
Federal Executive 8
Judiciary 9
State Legislatures 9
State Executive Council 10
Separation of Powers 10
Advantages and Disadvantages of Federalism 11
Conclusion. 12
Bibliography 14

Introduction
Today, there are many different forms of governments exercised in the world. The governments can be classified by economy, what goods and services are provided by the government. Capitalism, socialism and communism are the common in this perspective. In addition, they can be classified according to their political view, how government is run, by dictatorship, aristocracy, theocracy, parliamentary, federal, republic, anarchy and monarchy. According to who picks the government, it can be classified revolutionary, democracy, oligarchy, plutocracy and totalitarian. Malaysia is one of the countries that employ federal, democratic and monarchy system of government but its unique form. Further, Malaysia has thirteen federal states; nine of them are ruled by monarchies while the rest are ruled by governors. In addition, the thirteen states form a federal government led by a prime minister and each of the states has its self autonomous. According to (Aun, 1999) Malaysia is a federation of thirteen states and two federal territories. It has a federal constitution and thirteen state constitutions. The federal constitution is the supreme law of the land. In this discourse, it will be discussed the type of federation and its characteristics adopted by the Malaysian government. Before the discussion of the federal government in Malaysia, it has to be understood deeply the types of governments, constitutions and federalism. Federalism

A federation, or federal states, is a political body described by a combination of partially self-governing states or provinces united by a central (federal) government. In a federation, there is a self-governing status of the element states and there is also separation of powers between them and the central government that is explicitly demonstrated in the constitution and may not be amended by a unilateral decision of the latter. Hence the legislature of the whole country has a limited power, while the legislatures of the states or provinces have also limited power. Neither is subordinate to the other; both are co-ordinate (Wheare, 1966).

The federalism is a type of government or constitutional structure that powers and resources are divided into different hierarchies of administration. Federal level, state level and local level are most common entities that form a federal system of government expressed by the constitution or a separate federal law.

(Modern Constitutions Author) In a federal constitution, the powers of the government are divided between a government of the whole country and the governments of parts of the country in such a way that each government is legally independent. The government for whole country has its own area of powers and it exercises them without any control from the governments of the constituent parts of the country and the constituent governments exercise their power without any control of the central government.

Federal law is the body of law created by the federal government of a country. A federal government is formed when a group of political units, such as states or provinces join together in a federation, surrendering their individual sovereignty and many powers to the central government while retaining or reserving other limited powers. As a result, two or more levels of government exist within an established geographic territory. The body of law of the common central government is the federal law (Wikipedia).

There are many governments that adopted federal system of government such as America, Canada, Australia, Malaysia and etc. But each of them has its own way of federalism which has articulated by its constitution or federal law. Taking Canada for example, its constitution establishes an independent government for the whole country, but it permits that government to exercise certain limited powers of control over the governments of ten provinces. Although there are certain powers vested in the provinces to exercise exclusively, yet it is provided that the executive government of Canada may veto or dismiss the bills or acts passed by the provinces (Wheare, 1966).

In Australia, although the constitution articles stric...

Read more

Keywords

-2 /1086717/centralised_federalism_in_malaysia /admin/docs/malaysia.pdf /en/main/msiangov/govgovernance/pages/govgovernance.aspx /malaysian_court_system.html /malaysianmonarchy/?q=en/conferencerole /parline/reports/ /q/what_are_the_advantages_and_disadvantages_of_federalism_for_democratic_government /wiki/federal_law 09 1 10 11 12 12/17/2012 127 14 15 153 1966 1993 1999 2 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2012 21 222 29 3 32 38 40 41 42 44 4409 45 5 6 7 8 9 abus academia accompani accord achiev act action addison addit adher administ administr adopt adult advantag advic advis advisor affair affect age agenc agong agreement ahm al alli allow also altern although amend america american among anarchi and/or answer appeal appli appoint area argu aristocraci arm armi articl articul aspir assembl assign assimil attack attend aun australia australian author automat autonom avoid bar barrier base basi basic becom besar besid bhd bibliographi bicamer bill bodi branch britain british broad brought burham c cabinet canada capac capit case categor central centralis certain chairman chamber chang character characterist check chief chosen civil classifi claus close closer co co-ordin coalit code codifi collect combin come command committe common commonwealth communism commut compar competit compon compris conclus conduct confer confid confinder.richmond.edu confinder.richmond.edu/admin/docs/malaysia.pdf conflict consent consid consider consist constitu constitut constrain consult content contradictori control conven corpor corrupt could council countri court creat crimin currenc custom daili darul date day dec decentr decis declar deepli defenc degre deliber democraci democrat demonstr depend describ develop devolut dewan di di-pertuan dictat dictatori dictatorship differ difficult digniti direct disadvantag discours discret discretionari discuss dismiss dissolut dissolv district divid divis doctrin domin dual dual-sovereign duplic duti econom economi educ ehsan either elect element embodi employ emption en.wikipedia.org en.wikipedia.org/wiki/federal_law encarta encompass encourag ensur entir entiti enumer especi establish et etc ethnic ethno everi exampl except exclus execut exercis exist experienc explicit express fact faith fall feder fee fifti final financi finder fine first first-past-the-post five five-year follow forc form formul forti forty-four four fourteen free front function furthermor fusion general generat geograph gerakan good govern governor grant great group guarante guard hand head hear held henc hereditari hierarchi high highest honour hous howev huat i.e ibrahim ideolog illustr immun implement includ independ indirect individu ineffici inequ influenc inform infus inherit innov input institut integr intern interparliamentari interpret interven introduct ipu.org islam isol jan jeong join judgment judici judiciari jurisdict k karisma ketua king kuala land langman lap last latter law lead least led legal legisl legislatur less level levi like limit liter littl local london lower lumpur m made majesti major make malacca malay malay-ethno-nationalist malaya malaysia malaysian malaysian.gov.my malaysianbar.org malaysianmonarchy.org manag mandat mandatori mani manner march master matter maximum may mca mean meant measur member menteri method mic microsoft might minist minster mn model modern monarch monarchi month multi multi-ethn multi-parti muslim muss must mygovern n.d name nation nation-st nationalist near need negara negeri neither never newyork nine normal null offici oligarchi one one-parti oper opinion order ordin origin other over-govern over-lap overse overwhelm oxford pardon parliament parliamentari part parti partial pass past paul penang peopl permit person perspect pertuan pick place plan plenari plutocraci pm polic polici polit posit possess post power ppp practic practis pre pre-empt predomin preemin presid press prevent prime principl privileg problem proceed program protect provid provinc public purpos rakyat rather recommend refer regard region regist relat relev religion relinquish remain remit remov repres repriev republ requir reserv resourc respect respit respons rest result retain retriev revenu revis revisionari revolutionari right rivalri rotat rule ruler run sabah said sarawak scientist scope sdn second select selengor self self-govern senat senior sentenc separ septemb servic seventi sever shall short similar singl single-memb sit six small social socio socio-econom sourc sovereign sovereignti speak special st stand standard state status stipul strict structur subordin suffrag suggest sultan summon superior supervisori suprem surrend suspend syariah system systemat tabl take tax ten term territori theocraci therefor third thirteen three three-year throughout thus tight timbalan time today togeth totalitarian tri trial tune twenti twenty-six two two-third type tyrann u.s umno undangan understood unhealthi unicamer uniform unilater union uniqu unit unitari univers upon upper use usual vari various vest veto view violat void vote voter w way weaker weakest wealthi wesley whear wherea whole whose wiki.answers.com wiki.answers.com/q/what_are_the_advantages_and_disadvantages_of_federalism_for_democratic_government wikipedia within without work world www.academia.edu www.academia.edu/1086717/centralised_federalism_in_malaysia www.ipu.org www.ipu.org/parline/reports/ www.malaysia.gov.my www.malaysia.gov.my/en/main/msiangov/govgovernance/pages/govgovernance.aspx www.malaysianbar.org.my www.malaysianbar.org.my/malaysian_court_system.html www.malaysianmonarchy.org.my www.malaysianmonarchy.org.my/malaysianmonarchy/?q=en/conferencerole yang ydpa year yet yong