Essays /

Eminent Domain When Can The Government Essay

Essay preview

Melanie Carter
Political Science 2212
State & Local Government W01 Spring 2013

Eminent Domain
When Can the Government Take the Property of a Citizen Without His Consent?

One of the more controversial Government actions is its ability to exercise the power of eminent domain to take control of property that belongs to an individual or private entity against their will. “Eminent domain, broadly understood, is the power of the state to seize private property without the owner's consent” (WordNet).

This paper will examine the elements of eminent domain and what protections are in place for citizens that may be effected by it, identify types of transactions that are typically involved and accepted in eminent domain cases and discuss what the citizens should expect to receive as compensation even though they have lost the property due to some of the broad definitions of the elements. Any time the government is taking the property of an individual, without his consent, it is a controversial matter. Many politicians and citizens agree that it was necessary to establish a method of acquiring property for the needs of the common good of the community even when there is a lone hold out property owner. It has been held that the power of eminent domain can only be exercised after meeting the protection standards established under the Fifth Amendment of The United States Constitution. We have been conditioned through the media that the Fifth Amendment protects us against self-incrimination “I plead the fifth”. Self-Incrimination is an important aspect but most people don’t realize that the Fifth Amendment has a “taking clause” designed to protect the property owners.

“No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or in the Militia, when in actual service in time of War or public danger; nor shall any person be subject for the same offence to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb; nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use without just compensation (United States Constitution Fifth Amendment). The Amendment initially only applied at a federal level until passage of the Fourteenth Amendment in which due process and equal protection were made applicable to the states. Taken at face value, the Fifth Amendment taking clause can be broken down into four basic elements: Nor shall (1) private property be (2) taken for (3) public use without (4) just compensation

The first is private property, it is self-explanatory and the definition is fairly narrow today although its prior applications were more expansive for example one of the biggest issues with emancipation of slaves was the one time belief that they were seen as property and not as individuals and this status protected the property owner. It was this view that brought about the Emancipation Proclamation and passage of the Thirteenth Amendment. Private property is defined as: Private property N-land or belongings owned by a person or group and kept for their exclusive use ( The next element is the taking of the property. The property my be taken from the owner without their consent in order to make an improvemen...

Read more


-150 /blog/law/property/property-law-keyed-to-dukeminier/eminent-domain-and-the-problem-of-regulatory-takings/kelo-v-city-of-new-london/ /browse/private /cu/cssn/expansion/ /definition/just-compensation.html. /ebchecked/topic/206470/fifth-amendment/296512/takings /public /supct/html/historics/ussc_cr_0348_0026_zs.html 000 04 1 10th 150 16 1945 1954 2 2004 2005 2011 2013 22 2212 250 3 3.0 4 439 5 50 500 abil accept accomplish account acquir acquisit acr act action activ actual add address administr advantag afford aforement age agenc ago agre agreeabl agreement airport allow almost alreadi also although alway amend amount anoth answer appel appli applic appoint approach apr april arbitr area aris aspect assess atlanta attempt attorney author awar award away b baptist base basement basic becom began begin belief bell belong benefici benefit berman best bibliographi biggest black board bottom bridg bring broad broaden broken brought build built busi buy buyer canal capit carter case cash caus center chair challeng choos church circumst citi citizen class claus clean clear clearanc close colleg collin columbia come commerci common communiti compani compel compens complet conced condemn condit congress connecticut consent consid constitut construct continu control controversi corpor could cours court cover cq creat crime crimin current d d.c danger deal dealt decid decis defin definit depriv design despit determin develop dictionari dilut directori discuss displac disput distress district domain downtown due earlier econom ed edit educ effect either element elimin emancip emin employe encroach end english entiti entitl equal essenti establish even events/institutions examin exampl except excess exclus exercis expand expans expect explanatori eye f face facil fact factori fair falcon fall famili favor feder fee feel felt fifth file final financi find first flood fmv for-profit forc ford forefront form formal found four fourteenth fox franchis friendship fulfil futur g gamili georgia get go good govern grand greater greedi greenblatt group half harbor hardship hawk heavili held highway hill histor hold holdout home homeown hope hospit hous ideal identifi impact import improv includ increas incrimin independ indict individu infam infrastructur initi interest involv issu jail jeopardi job joint judici juri just k kelo kennesaw kept kind land landown law lawsuit leas legal less level liberti life limb line littl live lloyd local london lone long longer look lord lose loser lost lot m made make mani manufactur march mariani market matter may measur media meet melani met method might militia mind minier miriam monetari money morehous motor mount much n n-land n.d n.p narrow naval necessari need negoti never new news next note number numer offenc offend offer often oldest one oper order otherwis outcri outsid overturn own owner p paid paper parcel park parker parti passag pay payment pecunuarili peopl perhap person pick pick-up place plan plant play plead point polit politician popular portion posit possess power preced present prevail prevent primarili prior prison privat procedur process proclam proctor profit project properti propos protect protest public purchas purpos put railroad re re-develop reach readi realiz reason receipt receiv redevelop refus regard relat relev reloc remain remaind requir reservoir result retriev revenu review revit right road roadway role root rule safeti said satisfact say sceg scenario school scienc see seen seiz self self-explanatori self-incrimin sell sentiment seri servic set settl shall shed short shown signific simpl simpli sinc sit site slang slave slum smenkowski smith sold sort speak spelman sport spring stadium staff stand standard start state status street stress studi subject substandard suprem surrend take taken tax term termin text theater therefor thing third thirteenth though tie time today toward tower transact transfer tri truste twice two type typic unabridg understood unit unjust unless unpopular upheav uphold upset urban us use usual util v vacant valu ventur vernon view w01 wait walk want war washington water waterfront way web websit webster well winner wit within without wordnet work world worthi would wrap year