Essays /

Famines Poverty Government Policy Food Supply Essay

Essay preview

Topic: Famines, poverty, government policy, food supply in colonial India

From 1760 till 1943 India was hit by terrible famines on a regular basis. More than 85 million Indians died in these famines which were in reality genocides done by the British Raj. Contrast this to the fact that there have been no famine related deaths since independence. British famine policy in India was influenced by the arguments of Adam Smith, as seen by the non-interference of the government with the grain market even in times of famines. Keeping the famine relief as cheap as possible, with minimum cost to the colonial exchequer, was another important factor in determining famine policy.

A major characteristic of British rule in India, and the net result of British economic policies, was the prevalence of extreme poverty among its people. While historians disagree on the question whether India was getting poorer or not under British rule, there is no disagreement on the fact that throughout the period of British rule most Indians always lived on the verge of starvation. As time passed, they found it more and more difficult to find employment or make a living. Different people have different ideas of what poverty means. In his famous study of poverty in York, Seebohm Rowntree (1901) defined families as being in ‘primary poverty’ if their ‘total earnings are insufficient to obtain the minimum necessities for the maintenance of merely physical efficiency’. It is not surprising that biological consideration related to the requirements of survival or work efficiency have been often used in defining the poverty. Starvation, clearly, is the most telling aspect of poverty. W. Aurther Dowe states that there are four different meanings of poverty, they are: 1. Normal or natural poverty follows laziness or incompetence. It is in individual’s concept. 2. Poverty is inflicted on some by crime or misconduct of others as theft, personal injury, property damage, slander or racial discrimination. 3. Poverty as a result of illness, old age or accident

4. Poverty is caused by injustice, oppression, slavery, land conquest, taxation and political corruption. Amartya Sen is an advocate of concept of absolute poverty. Absolute poverty refers to subsistence below minimum socially acceptable living conditions usually established based on nutritional requirements and other essential goods. Absolute poverty is also referred to primary poverty. Absolute poverty is a state where one cannot raise the income required to meet the expenditure for purchasing specific bundle of basic requirements. According to him poverty is a matter of deprivation. Poverty and inequality relate closely to each other, but they are distinct concepts and neither subsumes the other.

What is a famine?

Figure 1 Photograph of Famine Victims 1899-1902. Source: Wikipedia A famine is defined as “A famine is a widespread scarcity of food that may apply to any faunal species. This phenomenon is usually accompanied and preceded by regional malnutrition, starvation, epidemic, and increased mortality.” Famines imply starvation, but not vice versa. And starvation implies poverty, but not vice versa. It is possible for poverty to exist, and be regarded as acute, even when no serious starvation occurs. Starvation, on the other hand, does imply poverty, since the absolute dispossession that characterizes starvation is more than sufficient to be diagnosed as poverty. Even though this binary relationship between famine and starvation seems reasonable, this passage seems hardly enough to clarify the notion. Amartya Sen in his book goes on to list certain common characteristics of famines related to declines in food consumption (i.e. the “time contrast”) and disparities in food consumption between different groups (i.e. the “group contrast”). This is very helpful indeed, but can only serve as taxonomy because these characteristics need not be true for all famines. A food supply crisis?

The most common approach to famines is to propose explanations in terms of food availability decline (FAD). This FAD approach has been extensively used to analyse and explain the Bengal famine. The Famine Inquiry Commission’s view that the primary cause of the famine was “a serious shortage in the total supply of rice available for consumption in Bengal” provides the standard explanation of the famine. Droughts are usually the root cause of famines. In turn droughts where there is a scarcity of life giving water for the crops are usually the direct causes of crop failure in India. The failure of the crops in turn leads to a scarcity of food in the affected area. Droughts are themselves usually caused by the failure of monsoons. The failure of monsoons in turn is due to a periodic natural phenomenon known as ENSO (El Nino Southern Oscillation).ENSO occurs every five to seven years and causes extreme weather such as floods, droughts and other weather disturbances in many regions of the world. So, is the process of famine in India as simple as sequential steps below? Putting it simply, ENSO is like a natural seesaw which causes the failure of monsoons over India while causing unnatural rainfall over the coast of South America. ENSO causes monsoon failure → Drought →Crops fail→ Famine →Millions dead? Are famines then a natural follow on from the droughts caused by ENSO? Not...

Read more


-17 -1772 -1783 -1784 -1792 -1803 -1804 -1807 -1813 -1814 -1834 -1838 -1861 -1868 -1870 -1874 -1879 -1885 -1889 -1892 -1897 -1901 -1902 -1908 -1921 -1943 -1944 -34 -38 -6 -74 -78 -79 /wiki/famine 1 1.2 1.5 1.62 1.8 10 10.3 100 104 11 115 12 13 14 15 150 1500 16 1627 1750 1757 1760 1768 1769 1770 1782 1783 1791 1802 1803 1805 1812 1813 1817 1818 1823 1833 1837 1850 1854 1860 1865 1866 1868 1869 1871 1872 1873 1876 1877 1880 1884 1888 1891 1892 1896 1897 1899 19 1901 1902 1907 1911 1925 1930s 1941 1942 1943 1944 1991 2 2.1 2.7 29 3 3.2 30 3000 32 33 375 4 40 43 450 5 6 6.1 60 7 7.5 8 8.4 80 85 9 a.k.connell absolut abund accept access accid accompani accord acr acreag across act actual acut ad adam addit adequ advanc advoc affect afloat age agoni agra agrarian agricultur air air-tight almost alreadi also alway amartya america american amid among amount analys andhra andkashmir anoth anyth appeal appli approach arbitrari area argument artisan asian aspect assess asset associ attitud aurther author avail averag avoid away backward ban bara base basi basic battl becam beggar begin bengal bengalfamin berar better bhanushali bigger bihar binari biolog black bodi bombay book borrow breakup bristol britain british brutal buchenwald buffer bullock bundl burden burma buy byth c calam calcul call calori calorif came camp canal cannot capabl capita capitalist captiv carri case cash caus ce cent centuri certain chalisafamin chamber charact character characterist charl chattisgarh cheap cheer chennaiand children china cholera circumst clarifi clark clear close clutch coast coastlin coincid colin collabor collect coloni commerc commiss common compani compil complet conced concentr concept conclus condit confisc connect connel conquer conquest consequ conserv consider consumpt continu contrast control corps correct corrupt cost cotton could council countri court cow craftsmen crime crise crisi crop crush culmin cultiv cultur damag date davi day dead death deathnot debt deccan declin deep deeper defect defin degre delhi demand demographi depend deplet depriv design desper destroy determin devast develop diagnos dictat die dietmar differ difficult digbi direct disagr disagre discourag discrimin diseas dismal dispar dispensari dispossess distinct distress distribut district disturb doji done dow drain drought due dung dutt earli earn earthen east econom economi effect effici either el elliott empir employ enact end english englishman enough enso ensur entir epidem equit escap essenti establish estim etc europ european even everi exampl excess exchequ excus exercis exist expect expenditur expens explain explan exploit export expos extens extent extortion extract extrem face fact factor fad fail failur famili famin famous far farm farmer faunal feel fertil fig fig.2 figur final financi find finish first five flexibl flimsi flood fluctuat flung follow food forc foreign form forti found four free full funer futur gazett general genocid geographi get ghosh give given go goe good govern governor gradual grain gram graph great grew grim gross group grow growth gujarat guntur habitu half hand hard harvest haryana help hesit high histor histori historian hit hold holocaust horribl horror hour human humanitarian hundr hunger hunter husband i.e ibid idea ill illus illustr immemori immens imperi implement impli import imposs impoverish includ incom incompet increas inde indebt independ india indian indic indigo individu industri inequ inevit inflict influenc influx inher injuri injustic inmat inquiri instant institut insuffici interest interfer intervent introduct ira irrespect jar jharkhand journal jump justic k k.c k.c.ghosh karnataka keep kept khatedari kill killer klein know known labor lack lakh land landlord last late lazi lead leav led left lender less lessen level levi life like likelyestim line linger list live lord loss lost low lowest lytton made madhya madra madrasfamin maharashtra maharatna main maintain mainten major make malnutrit man man-mad manag manchest mani manipul maratha market massiv matter maximumestim may meal mean medic meet member merchant mere mike mile million millionapprox minimum minimumestim miscellan misconduct miser modern money money-lend moneylend monsoon mortal mortalitybut mortgag mother much mughal murar murder nadu name nation natur nazi near necess need neither net never next niggardli nine nineteenth nino non non-interfer nonresid normal north northern note noth notic notion number numer nutrit oandhra observ obtain obvious occur odeath of1782 of1876 of1943 ofdeath offamin offic offici ofkarnatakauttarpradesh ofrajasthan often ofthefamin old one opium oppress option orissa oscil other outbreak outcom overal owner ownership paid pamphlet paper paradox part particular pass passag past patel pauper pay peak peasant peopl per perform period perish perman person phenomenon photograph physic pit place plantat plassey plot point polici polit pond poor poorer popul possibl post poverti power pradesh pre pre-british pre-coloni preced precis present presid presidencyof prevail preval prevent previous price primari princ prison process produc product profit progress proper properti propos prosper protect provid provinc public punjab purchas push put quantiti queen question quit quot r r.c racial railway rainfal rais raj rajasthan rajputana rajputanafamin rate ration ravag raw reach read readili real realist realiti reason recogn record reduc refer regard regim region regular relat relationship releas relief remain remark remnant repeat requir reserv resourc respons rest result revenu revolut rice rich rip rise rite river road root rothermund rowntre rule ruler rupe rush ryot s.g sahukar sanit sank save say scanti scarciti scenario scene school scienc score second secur see seebohm seed seem seen seesaw select self sell semi semi-starv sen sequenti seren seri serious serv servant seven sever share shortag show side similar simpl simpli sinc sindh singl situat six sixti skeletonis skull slander slaveri small smith soar social soil sold sole sourc source.the south southern span speci specif spite spread stagnat standard starv starvat state stay step still stock stocks.the stop storag store stori strip structur studi subcontin subject subordin subsist subsum suffer suffici suppli support suprem sure surplus surpris surviv suspend susten swept system taken tamil tank tax taxabl taxat taxonomi tell templ ten term terribl theft therefor thing third thirti though thousand threaten three throughout thrown thus tide tight till time timespan today tonn took top topic torment total totaldeath toward trade tradit traitor tremend trend true tumbl turn twentieth two typic tyrant unabl unchang uncl underdevelop unimpair unless unnatur unsustain upper use usual util uttar uttarakhand valu vast verg versa vice viceroy victim victoria victorian vidarbha view virtual vol w walk want war ware water water-suppli way wealth weather well went west western wheat whether whole wide widespread wife wikipedia william within without withstand wive work worker world wors worst would year yield york young zamindar