Essays /

Webber Essay

Essay preview

What relations do you see between what Max Weber defined as the “Protestant Ethic” and what social psychologists describe as achievement motivation to counter act Puritanism. Use specific examples from your text. Make sure you include who(m) you are quoting. In "Asceticism and the Spirit of Capitalism," Max Weber explains how the Protestant work ethic can be double jeopardy. Weber also argues that religious groups like Calvinists played an influential role in the capitalistic spirit. He goes on to say that individuals believe self righteousness is powerful. Weber argues that everyone should be living an ascetic lifestyle and follow the calling of god. Weber uses Calvinistic principles to stress the importance of using self denial to practice a routine in order to avoid “temptation,” which means laziness and enjoyment of life once a person acquires wealth. However, Weber claims “enjoyment is a sign of idleness," and the writer strongly disagrees with Weber's view. People who are working hard and giving time to God daily should not be condemned from enjoying their own lifestyle.

However, Weber’s ideology, of the Protestant ethic describe that an individual should do the work unto God, or play a part in giving back to society as a “common good." Weber, use Puritanism, has a form of contradiction,“Wealth is thus bad ethically only in so far as it is a temptation to idleness and sinful enjoyment of life and its acquisition are bad only when it is with.....”(Weber,115). How can Weber believe that the more successful a person is at his job, the more god would like him?. Unfortunately, Weber's Theory is a bit confusing because wealth sometimes does allow people stray from their religious beliefs. According to Weber, having ownership within capitalism does enable excessive wealth. This approach relates negatively to a person's willingness to give back to society “Gods calling”. Weber quotes, “I fear whenever riches have increased, the essence of religion has decreased in the same proportion.... “How is it possible in the nature of things, for any revival of true religion to continue... “But riches increase, so will pride, anger and love of the world in all branches..” (Weber,123). Weber's explanation of this quote describe what was once "God's wealth” is now greed. Asceticism, now allow individuals to keep acquiring more wealth, which eventually will strip, them of their real religious beliefs of the  "common good".

David McClelland describe that achievement motivation is a persons desire and their ability to perform well in society according to their social environment. McC...

Read more


101 115 123 135 138 15 16 18 19th 23 394 395 92 93 96 abil abl accord achiev acquir acquisit act action activ adept affect age agre aim alleg allow alreadi also alter although alway american anger anoth approach approv argu around artisan ascet ascetic associ asund athenian attitud avoid awar away awe back bad bare base becam becom behavior belief believ benefici better bias birth bit blank bodi boi born bound bourgeoi bourgeoisi branch bring brooklyn build built busi call callous calvinist cannot capac capit capitalist carpent carri cash caus centuri chase child children china church civil claim class clear color come commit common communic communication-li communist communiti compani compar comparison compet competit complet concuss condemn confus connect constant continu contradict contrast contriv control convert cop cost counter countri cover creat crime crime-hi crimin critic crow cultur dad daili damag danc david day decent declar decreas defin demand deni denial describ desir despit develop development differ difficult disagre disappear discoveri discrimin distinguish doubl du duboi durkheim earli earlier earn effect ego electr enabl engel engl enjoy entir environ environment equal er especi essenc establish ethic even eventu everi everyon everywher evolut ex exampl excess exclud exist expand expect experi explain explan express extinct face fact famili far father fear feel fell feudal fight first follow forcibl form fraction free freedom freud function furthermor gang gender general georg get give go god goe good got great greed group grow gun halo hand handicraftsmen happen hard hat help hero high hiterto hold honor hour hous howev human identifi ideolog idl illeg import imposs includ incom increas independ india individu industri inequ influenti ing insecur instil interact interest intern jeopardi job join justic karl keep keeper kid labor laid larg law lawyer lazi lead learn left lie life lifestyl like live long longer look lose love low lower lower-middl m machin made maintain major make man manifesto manufactori manufactur mark market marx master matter max may mcclelland mead mean mechan men mental middl mind mirror modern money monitor moral mother motiv motley must nake narrow natur necessari need negat neighborhood nestl never new newli nexus normal noth object occup oftentim older one order organ other own owner ownership paid parent part particular pay payment peasant peopl perfect perform person persuad physic physician pillar pitiless place plant play point possess possibl power practic prejudic preparatori present pride priest principl problem produc proletariat proport protest prove provid psych psycholog psychologist punish puritan push quot racial react read reader real reason recent regain reign relat religi religion report restrain restrict result revernet reviv revolut reward rich right righteous rise role routin rule ruler run said save say scienc see seen self self-concuss self-interest sens separ serv settl sever shoe shoemak shop shopkeep shot shut sign similar simpli sin sinc sing skin slate small social societ societi sociologist socrat someon someth sometim somewhat son soon specif spirit spoke stage start state status stick still stray stress strip strong subconsci subject subtl success superior support sure surfac surround tailor taken teach tear temptat text theori therefor thing think though thought thoughts.however thus tie time today togeth torn toward trade train trigger true truli turn two type understand unfortun unit unless unlik unto upon us use util valu view villain wage want way wealth weapon web webber weber well whenev wherea whether whole willing within work worker world would writer wrong yet young