A Giant Cage

The internet was expected to help democratise China. Instead, it has enabled the authoritarian state to get a firmer grip, says Gady Epstein. But for how long?

THIRTEEN YEARS AGO Bill Clinton, then America’s president, said that trying to control the internet in China would be like trying to “nail Jell-O to the wall”. At the time he seemed to be stating the obvious. By its nature the web was widely dispersed, using so many channels that it could not possibly be blocked. Rather, it seemed to have the capacity to open up the world to its users even in shut-in places. Just as earlier communications technologies may have helped topple dictatorships in the past (for example, the telegraph in Russia’s Bolshevik revolutions in 1917 and short-wave radio in the break-up of the Soviet Union in 1991), the internet would surely erode China’s authoritarian state. Vastly increased access to information and the ability to communicate easily with like-minded people round the globe would endow its users with asymmetric power, diluting the might of the state and acting as a force for democracy. Those expectations have been confounded. Not only has Chinese authoritarian rule survived the internet, but the state has shown great skill in bending the technology to its own purposes, enabling it to exercise better control of its own society and setting an example for other repressive regimes. China’s party-state has deployed an army of cyber-police, hardware engineers, software developers, web monitors and paid online propagandists to watch, filter, censor and guide Chinese internet users. Chinese private internet companies, many of them clones of Western ones, have been allowed to flourish so long as they do not deviate from the party line. If this special report were about the internet in any Western country, it would have little to say about the role of the government; instead, it would focus on the companies thriving on the internet, speculate about which industries would be disrupted next and look at the way the web is changing individuals’ lives. Such things are of interest in China too, but this report concentrates on the part played by the government because that is the most extraordinary thing about the internet there. The Chinese government has spent a huge amount of effort on making sure that its internet is different, not just that freedom of expression is limited ...

11 14th 1917 1987 1991 2006 2009 2010 2012 20m 560m 70 abil abl abroad absurd abus academ access accid account achiev across act activ activist adapt affili africa agenc ago agre air align allow almost also altern alway america american among amount analys analysi anyth apparatus appoint area argu armi around asia ask asymmetr attack attempt attend attent author authoritarian award away baidu balanc bar becam becom behaviour beij belarus believ bend best best-appoint better beyond big biggest bill block blog blueprint bolshevik book border break break-up bring broad brother build built buy cadr cage call came capac care carri casual censor censorship centr central challeng chang channel chaotic check china chines chip civic civic-mind clinton clone close co co-writ collect combin come commerci commissar common communic communist compani complaint comput concentr conduct confin confound connect constant construct contain continu control corner corrupt could countri coup creat creator credibl crise critic criticis crowd crush cyber cyber-hack cyber-polic cynic daili deal debat declar deem defenc definit delet democraci democratis demonstr deploy desper detain develop deviat devic dictatorship differ dilut dinner direct dismay dispers disput disrupt dissent dissid distinct diverg divers domest dozen drawn e e-mail ear earli earlier eas easili east eastern edific educ effici effort either enabl end endow energi engin enjoy epstein equal erod ethiopia europ even eventu everi everyday exampl excess exercis expect expens exponenti express extraordinari facebook famili famous far farmer fastest februari fenc fenced-off ferret filter fire firewal firm firmer first flight flip flourish focus follow food forc foreign foremost freedom freeli fun gadi game gap gaug get giant given global globe go goal golden googl gorg got govern grab grade great grew grievanc grip grow growth gruesom grumbl guard guid hack hacker hardwar headlin heard heavili help hesit hold home huawei huge humour impact import impos incid includ increas indefinit individu industri inform infrastructur inher insight instead interest intern internet internet-connect internet-servic introduc invest iron isol jail januari jell jell-o job joke kazakhstan keep keyword kill know know-how known lampoon larg largest last lead leader led less level liber life light like like-mind limit line listen littl liu live local locat long longer look low low-grad low-level luxuri made magazin mail make mani manifesto manipul march market may mean media messi microblog microblogg might million mind minder mix mob mobil mock money monitor monstros most mouthpiec mr much much-jail music nail name nation natur network new newcom news next nobel nonetheless north north-western notic number numer o obvious offend offer offici one onlin onto open opinion organis other outnumb outrag outsid overal paid part parti party-st past paternalist peac penetr peopl perform photograph pic place play playground polic polit pollut poorer pop popul pornographi portal pose possibl post potent power presid previous prison privat prize probe problem proclaim produc project prolifer propaganda propagandist proud provid provinc public punish purport purpos put question quick radio rather rattl reach real reason recent recur regim region relat remain remark remot renren report repress requir resembl respond respons rest restrict result retain revolut ridicul riot role round routin rueful rule rumour run rural russia ruthless safeti said saw say scene scholar scof search seem self self-censor sell senior sensit sent sentenc septemb serious serv servic set shield shift shop short short-wav show shown shut shut-in signatur sina singl six skill small smile social social-media societi softwar someth sometim soon south south-east soviet speak special specul spent spike spread state state-run steal still stori strain strict subtl subvers suffer supplier support sure surg survey surviv swift switch system systemat tabl take technolog telecom telegraph televis temporarili tencent terror thing think thirteen though thought threat threaten thrive throw tight time titl tool toppl track tri trust turn tweet twitter twitter-lik two undesir undisturb union unknown unorganis unruli unwieldi urban use user valuabl vast via victori vietnam view vulner wall watch wave way wear weather web websit weibo well well-off west western whether whole wide withdrew within wobbl work world would write writer xiaobo xinjiang year yet youtub zambia zte