Essays /

124824683 Petrolera Zuata Case Analysis Essay

Essay preview

CASE ANALYSIS
PETROLERA ZUATA, PETROZUATA C.A

PETROLERA ZUATA (PETROZUATA) CASE ANALYSIS:
Q1.

HOW SHOULD PDVSA FINANCE THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ORINOCO BASIN? WHAT ARE THE COSTS AND BENEFITS OF USING PROJECT FINANCE INSTEAD OF TRADITIONAL DEBT FINANCE?

Soln.

PDVSA should go for project financing for the development of the Orinoco basin. PDVSA is not looking for financing of one deal, but at a chain of many deals which would be a public- private partnership between PDVSA and a foreign organization for development and up-scaling of the Orinoco Basin. Therefore, it is important that PDVSA maintains its cash and debt capabilities to address to future uncertainties. This would provide higher flexibility for PDVSA and at the same time better distribute the risk, providing a lower risk to the home company PDVSA. The costs attached with using project finance instead of traditional debt finance are: 1. High cost of political risk insurance would increase the interest rate associated with debt. As a result higher leverage through project finance would be costlier. 2. Chances of a negative carry due to inflow of large amount of funds via bond in the start, which would not have its usage then. As a result these bonds would fetch a lower investment gin and cause a higher interest drain leading to loss. The benefits associated with project financing instead of traditional debt finance are: 1. The probability of getting a higher investment grade for the project even when the country Venezuela had a rating of B.

2. Using project financing PDVSA can get into a joint venture which can be private and not public. Through this it can enjoy benefits currently being enjoyed by private equity firms. 3. PDVSA will preserve its debt capacity and hence have higher flexibility. 4. Through project financing it can approach larger private markets inviting more foreign investments.

Hence project financing for the venture is a better option.

Q2.

WHAT ARE PETROZUATA͛A THREE OR FOUR MOST IMPORTANT RISKS? HOW DOES THE DEAL STRUCTURE ADDRESS THESE RISKS? WHO WOULD BEAR THESE RISKS IF THE PROJECT WERE FINANCED INTERNALLY BY PDVSA INSTEAD?

Soln.

Petrozuata͛s most important operating risks were:
1. POLITICAL RISK: the political risk associated with the downfall of the Venezuelan government and the unpredictability of the Venezuelan government to abruptly change the tax rate or the royalty posed a big risk for the investors.

2. EXCHANGE RATE: the other major risk associated with the Petrozuata project is exchange rate fluctuation. As the Venezuelan economy is developing there is a high risk that that the currency Bolivar would appreciate against dollar. This would increase the expenses and tax

liability of the project relative to the sale income which would be in dollar, reducing the profitability of the project.
3. OIL PRICE VOLATILITY: the third major risk associated with the Petrozuata project...

Read more

Keywords

-19 -22 0 0.6 0.60 0.67 0.73 0.84 0.93 0.98 000 021 024 034 035 086 1 1.03 1.12 1.14 1.21 1.24 1.32 1.35 1.4 1.40 1.41 1.45 1.53 1.55 1.57 1.63 1.64 1.71 1.73 1.80 1.81 1.87 1.90 1.94 1.98 10 10.5 11.75 111 124824683 13.34 134 137 14.27 144a 169 18 18.57 18.6 187 19.07 19.46 1996 1997 1998 1999 1st 2 2.06 2.10 2.20 2.35 2.55 2.62 2.72 2.88 20 20.25 20.89 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 200mn 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 21 21.24 21.56 22 22.34 222 23.02 23.59 24.22 241 25.07 25.39 25.80 252 26 26.47 267 268 27.00 27.01 27.44 27.70 27.96 2728 28.22 280 299 2nd 3 3.01 3.11 3.17 3.24 3.30 300bps 32 333 348 37 372 3rd 4 401 411 448 449 450 484 4th 5 5.60 50 556 567 6 6.67 60 614 631 669 689 7 7.5 70 70.41 75 755 79 8.01 8.14 8.63 8.75 81 849 856 90 961 977 abrupt account achiev address adequ advantag affect agenc alreadi also amount analysi appreci approach around arrang ask asset associ assum assumpt attach attain averag b bank bare barrel base basin bear becom benefit besid best beta better big billion bolivar bond born borrow bound breakeven c c.a calcul cannot capabl capac capit carri case cash caus ceil chain chanc chang charg choos claus close come compani compar compromis conco constant construct cost costlier could countri coven cover coverag credit currenc current d day deal debt decid declin decreas default definit delay depend design develop direct dis dis-advantag disclosur distribut dollar downfal drain draw drill dscr due earli earn easili econom economi edc emerg end enjoy enough envis equiti estim even exchang execut exim expect expens fall͟ fetch field financ financi find firm flexibl fluctuat follow foreign four fund futur gain generat get gin give given go goe gone govern grade happen heat help henc high higher histori holder home howev huge ifc impact import improv inclus incom increas inflow initi instead insur integr interest intern invest investor invit irr issu joint ke keep kind larg larger lead lend less level leverag liabil like limit line liquid loan longer look lose loss low lower made maintain major make mani margin mark market match matur mean measur minim minimum model month much need negat net note numer oblig offer oil oilfield one oper opic opt option organ orinoco outflow part partnership pay payment pdvsa per percent petrolera petrozuata petrozuata͛ petrozuata͛a pictur pipelin point polit pose prefer premium preserv pri price prioriti privat probabl profit project project͛ provid public q1 q2 q3 q4 q6 q7 q8 question rang rate ratio reason recommend reduc refin regul relat remain reput requir requisit reserv restrict result return rf risk robust royalti rule sale scale scope see seen serious servic share sharehold shield short show similar sinc singl situat size smaller soln solut sponser sponsor stabil start startup status still structur sub sub-invest substanti suffer suffici sum tabl take tax therebi therefor third three time total tradit true turn u.s uncertainti underwritten unlik unpredict unsecur up-scal us usag use util v/e valu vari variabl various venezuela venezuelan ventur via volatil water waterfal way within without would x year yrs zuata