Essays /

Government Failure Essay

Essay preview

This essay is an attempt to critically examine the statement that “irrespective of how we define the public sector or how we measure its size, it is important to realize that governments, like markets, can also fail”. Furthermore, this essay will try to outline the causes of government failure. In order to achieve this, an investigation into why there has been a shift of concern from market failure to government failure will be undertaken and relevant definitions will be cited. Finally, the possible causes of government failure will be outlined. A conclusion will then be drawn from the discourse.

To begin with, the public sector refers to the range of economic activities where resources are controlled and decisions over their use are taken by agencies responsible to the government through its political institutions. In other words, it is the economic sector controlled by the State and not directly subject to the normal market forces of private consumption and supply though these may influence decisions taken through the political machinery of the State. In Zambia, like in most countries, the public sector consists of the central government and the local authorities. Since the extensive privatization that began in 1991 and went on through the 90s, the nationalized industries are no longer a major part of the public sector. At the same time, there has developed a number of non-elected bodies appointed by the central government. The size of the public sector, therefore, is dependent on the number of institutions which are mandated by the State. These include government ministries, commissions and authorities, and parastatal organizations. Market forces on the other hand are underlying influences on the operation of the economy. They boil down to supply and demand---the basic factors determining price. According to the theory, or law, of supply and demand, the market prices of commodities and services are determined by the relationship of supply to demand. Theoretically, when supply exceeds demand, sellers must lower prices to stimulate sales; conversely, when demand exceeds supply, buyers bid prices up as they compete to buy goods. The terms supply and demand do not mean the amount of goods and services actually sold and bought; in any sale the amount sold is equal to the amount bought, and such supply and demand, therefore, are always equal. In economic theory, supply is the amount available for sale or the amount that sellers are willing to sell at a specified price, and demand, sometimes called effective demand, is the amount purchasers are willing to buy at a specified price (Samuelson and Nordhaus, 1998).

The theory of supply and demand takes into consideration the influence on prices of such factors as an increase or decrease in the cost of production, but regards that influence as an indirect one, because it affects prices only by causing a change in supply, demand, or both. Other factors indirectly affecting prices include changes in consumption habits (for example, a shift from natural silk to artificial silk fabrics) and the restrictive practices of monopolies, trusts, and cartels. In the view of many economists, the multiplicity of such indirect factors is so great that the terms supply and demand are inclusive categories of economic forces affecting prices, rather than precise, primary causal factors (open citation). Market forces vary from market to market and derive their power from the individuals who make up a market and on whose lives they have enormous influence. They are determined by such factors as wealth, consumer taste, regulation, and taxation. Stringent safety requirements may push up the cost, and therefore the price, of a potentially desirable product beyond that which a sufficient number of consumers can afford or are willing to pay.

The price-determining mechanism of supply and demand is operative only in economic systems in which competition is largely unrestricted. Increasing recourse, in recent times, to governmental regulation of the economy has tended to restrict the scope of the operation of the supply-and-demand mechanism---the market.

In a pure free market economy, market forces are unrestrained. However, in all countries, governments to a greater or lesser degree restrict the operation of the free market and therefore distort or even negate the effect of market forces through economic policy. For example, in the former Communist countries the system of central planning left no room for market forces to operate. In other parts of the world governments have often, for different reasons, sought to override market forces through such actions as the granting of subsidies to firms or services that (it is assumed) could not survive in a free market, or the imposition of tariffs or quotas on imports. This has led to market failures.

According to Antoff and Hahn (2009) a market failure can arise if there are externalities, such as pollution; or if there are inefficiencies associated with market structure, such as cartels, monopolies, and oligopolies.

A monopoly is the control of market supply: a situation in which one company controls an industry or is the only provider of a product or service while an oligopoly is an economic condition in which there are so few suppliers of a product that one supplier's actions can have a significant impact on prices and on its competitors. A cartel is an alliance of business companies formed to control production, competition, and prices (Microsoft Encarta Dictionary, 2009).

Basically speaking, markets fail when there is disequilibrium in supply and demand factors. Firstly, markets fail because of the unequal allocati...

Read more


/economics/laureates/1972/arrow-autobio.html). 1 10th 16th 1951 1971 1980s 1990s 1991 1995 1997 1998 1999 2 2000 2001 2004 2006 2008 2009 2011 2nd 3 313 4 4th 5 6 80 90s 9th a.p abil abl abus accid accord achiev across act action activ actual add addit address adjust administ administr advantag aei aei-brook affair affect afford africa agenc agent aggreg agricultur ahead alcohol allianc alloc allow almost along also alway america among amongst amount analysi analyz and/or anecdot anoth antoff appear appli applic appoint approach appropri argu argument aris arm armi arrow artifici aspect assess associ assum assumpt asymmetri attempt attract author avail avoid bakija banda banda-l bank base basi basic becom beer began begin behavior believ benefit best better beverag beyond bibliographi bid bill bloc bodi boil boost bought break bring broader brook brought budgetari build built busi butcher buy buyer by-pass c cabl call cap capit capitalist captur carri cartel case categori caus causal center central certain chang chaotic cheat cheltenham chicago choic choos christoph cigarett circumv citat cite citizen civil clean clear cliff cohes collaps collect command commiss commod common communism communist communiti compani compar compet competit competitor compris concern conclus condit conduct confin conflict congest connect consequ consid consider consist consum consumpt context contribut control convers corpor correct corrupt cost cost-benefit could countri cours cover creat creator crimin crise critic czech d d.c damag de de-merit deal debat decid decis decision-mak decreas deem deep deep-root deepen deeper defin definit defraud degrad degre delhi demand demand-sid democraci democrat depart depend deriv describ desir despit despot determin develop deviat diamond dicken dictatori dictionari differ difficult difficulti direct discours discuss disequilibrium disincent disinterest dispens distort distribut done donor downstream drawn drive drug drunken due dump dynam e e.g earli easi eastern ebenstein econom economi economist ed edit educ edward effect effici eight either elect electr elgar embark embrac empow encarta encourag end endors energi enforc engag englewood enjoy enorm ensur entiti environ environment equal equiti error espous essay essenc establish estim etc etcetera eu europ european evas even eventu everi everyth evid examin exampl exceed exchang exclus exert exist expans expect expens explain extens extent extern extort extra extra-budgetari extrem eye fabric face facil factor factori fail failur fair fall farm farmer fascism fast favor fear final financi find fine firm first fiscal fisp fix focus fogelman food forc foreign form former formul forward fra free freeli full function fund fundament furthermor general generat get give global go goal gone good govern government grant great greater greider grey group grow growth guarante guid habit hahn hampshir hand harm haven heart helpless heritag hide high higher hill hospit hour howev huge hungari hurt ibidem idea ideolog ignor ill illeg illinoi imagin imf imf/world impact imperfect implement implic import imposit imposs in-built inadequ inappropri incent inclin includ inclus incom increas incur indirect individu industri ineffect ineffici inequ inequit influenc inform infrastructur innov input instanc instead institut integr intent interest intern interrelationship interven intervent introduc introductori investig involv irrespect ism issu item j job join joint k key kill kind known kuttner l labor laboratori lack larg last late law lead least lectur led left legal legisl less lesser let level liber like limit line link literatur littl live lobbi local logic london long long-run long-term longer look loom loophol loss lot low lower ltd m machineri macmillan made magstadt maiz major make man manag mandat mani manic manner mark market martin masiy mass massachusett mathemat may mcgraw mcgraw-hil mean means-test measur mechan media meet mercenari mere merit microsoft might minim minimum ministri misalloc misguid misplac mit mix mmd monetari monopoli moor motiv move movement much mulenga multiparti multipl must myopia nation natur need negat neighbor neither network never new noll non non-elect non-exclus non-optim nordhaus normal note noth number object observ occur offici often oligopoli olson one open oper opposit optim order organ origin other outcom outlin over-product overal overproduct overrid owe own p p.80 p.m packag paid palgrav panitch paper parastat part particular pass pay pearson peopl percent period person pipe place plan planner play point poland polici policy-mak polit politician pollut poor poorest popul popular posit possess possibl potenti power practic precis predict predispos prefer prentic present press pressur prevent price price-determin primari primarili principl privat problem process produc product profit program prohibit project prompt proper propon protect prove provid public publish purchas pure pursuit push put qualiti quick quo quota r raid rais rang rapid rare rate rather ration reaction readi real real-wag realiz reason recent recours reduc reduct refer reform regard regardless regul regulatori relat relationship relev reli relief reloc rememb renew rent rent-seek replac report republ requir research reserv resourc respons restrict result revenu revers revolut rider right rise risk river road role room root rule run rupiah russia s.c safe safeti said sale samuelson sanit sap satchet say scale scarc scenario scheme school schuster scienc scope second sector see seek seen seldom select self self-interest sell seller sensit serious servant servic set shadow share shift short short-sight show side sight signal signific silk silverman sime simon simpli sinc singl situat size slemrod slower smith smuggl social socialist societi sold solut sometim sought south southern soviet speak special specifi spectrum speed spend st stabil standard stanford start state state-oper state-run statement status stimul stop storag strategi stringent strong structur studi style subject subsid subsidi substanti success suffer suffici suggest summar suppli supplier supply-and-demand support suppos surviv swamp synonym system take taken tariff tast tax taxat taxpay techniqu telephon tend tendenc term territori terror terrorist test textbook theorem theoret theori therefor thing third thirlwal though thus time todaro today topic toward trade traffic tragedi transfer transport tri trivial trust tujilijili turn turnout type u.k uce unabl unanticip under underground undermin undertaken unemploy unequ unexpect ungovern unintend union univers unrestrain unrestrict unwarr upon urban use usual valu valuabl van vari various versus vest victor view violat virtu virtual voluntarili vote w wage want war washington wast water way wealth wealth-creat weapon welfar well went western westview wherebi whether whole wholli whose will winston within without word work worker world wors worsen worth would yanowitch year zambia zambian