Essays /

Revolutions Occur When Governments Are Weak Essay

Essay preview

The strength or weakness of a government can be viewed in two ways. Firstly it may be interpreted as being literally the extent to which the government has control over the internal security of the state and in general its ability to resist challenges from opposition groups. Alternatively a government can be viewed as being weak based on its poor decision making and its failure to protect the national interest. In relation to the former definition there is little to support the view that revolutions occur when governments are weak. There can be little doubt that revolutions are more likely to succeed when governments are weak, however revolutions occur for a range of far more complex reasons rather than simply the opportunity arising. For example the present government Ireland would have very limited ability to resist a well organised revolution, however it does not occur because few if any of the requirements necessary for a revolution are present. In the case of the latter, poor decision making of a government has indeed contributed to the birth of past revolutions, however it is only one aspect of the numerous and complex causes of a revolution.

Revolutions are by nature shrouded in misconceptions and false conclusion. This is unsurprising due to the conditions of chaos under which they occur. This confusion is confounded by the fact that, as such events are highly politically charged, their causes and their inspiration are often manipulated in order to serve a certain political cause. For this reason the causes of revolutions are often reduced by the casual observer to two simplex causes, the oppression and hardship suffered by a population under a weak and corrupt government. Although the causes of Great Revolutions such as the French and the Russian are more complex than this, they are surprisingly uniformed, to the extent that Crane Brinton in his book, ?The Anatomy of a Revolution?, (along with numerous other historians) has formed a concise template by which the great the Great Revolutions occur.

The common misconception is that all revolutions arise from great oppression being imposed on the lower classes under a corrupt regime until the people can suffer it no longer and are forced into revolution with which th...

Read more

Keywords

-1986 1 1780 1789 1812 1904 1905 1914 1917 1965 1987 1991 1994 1995 1998 2 3 3rd 4 5 6 abat abil absolut achiev acknowledg admir adopt alexi alli allow along also altern although american amount anatomi antagonis apart approach approxim area argu arguabl aris aristotl armi asia aspect assembl atmospher attack attempt autocrat bad bankruptci base becam becom belief believ better bibliographi birth bloodi blown book border born bourgeoisi briefli brinton broke broken brought c call came cannot capitalist case casual caus central centuri certain challeng chang chao charg charl class clearer coincid collaps collus colonist come committe common commune compar complex concept concess concis conclus condit confid conflict confound confus consid consist constitut continu contradictori contribut control conven convinc cope corrupt could countri crane critic de decad decis defeat definit degaul delud demand democraci desert despit deterior determin didn disorganis display dissatisfi dissolv distinct distribut divin doctor domin doubt driven dub due duma earlier easili econom economi ed educ effect eighteenth either embarrass emerg empir end endevour endur enjoy enlighten enter equip equival erod erupt essay estat estates-gener european evapor even event eventu everi exampl except exil expos extent extern extrem face fact factor factori failur faith fals far februari feel financ financi firm first fitzpatrick five flagship follow forc foreign form former franc french full fundament general germani get goal govern grant great greater group growth hall hardship hatr high histori historian hold hope howev humili hundr i.e ideal ignor ii implement impos improv increas inde industrialis inevit inspir interest intern interpret introduct ireland j.n januari japan karl kill king known landlord larg latter lawyer lead leadership level liber life like limit liter littl live london longer loss loui love lower m m.c made maintain make manag mani manipul marx massacr may meal mean mercantil middl militari minim misconcept modern monarch monarchi month moral movement mutini nation nationwid natur necessari need needler new next nichola nobl nomin number numer observ obtain obvious occur occurr octob offens often old one opportun opposit oppress order organis over-confid overthrow oxford palac pari parliament particip pass past path peac peasant peopl petersburg phase philosophi piec piece-m pillag pipe placat place pledg plot point polici polit poor popul posit poss possibl power praeger precipit premiership prentic prerequisit present press prevail prevent price primari principl profession proletarian proletariat prompt properti protect protest prove public pull put quasi quit r radic rang rare rather realis realiti reason redistribut reduc reform refus regim reign relat relinquish remain repeat repel replac repres represent republ requir resist respons restor result retain reveal revolut rid right robespierr roskin ruin rule russia russian safeti saw say scandal scarciti second secondari secur see seem seiz seldom serv set seventi ship short shown shroud similar simpl simplex simpli situat social societi socio socio-econom son sort sourc spawn spur st start state state-soci step strain strength strongest structur succeed sudden suffer sunday support surpris system templat tend tension tenuous terror theori thing third thoroughgo three throne thus time tocquevil took toppl toward tradit trigger troop tsar turn twentieth two unavoid under unflinch uniform univers unpopular unpreced unrest unsurpris unwit unworthi urban use various verg victori view vintag war warrant way weak wealth well western westwood whilst whys widespread winter within work worker would xvi year yet york