Essays /

Can A Machiavellian Prince Be A Essay

Essay preview

Can Machiavelli’s Prince be a Good Christian?

… [Many] have pictured republics and principalities which in fact have never been known or seen, because how one lives is so far distant from how one ought to live, that he who neglects what is done for what ought to be done, sooner effects his ruin than his preservation… Hence it is necessary for a prince wishing to hold his own to know how to do wrong, and to make use of it or not according to necessity. (Machiavelli, 62)

Machiavelli’s suggestion to rulers to sacrifice virtue to win and maintain states has brought his political treatise, The Prince, both attention and contention for the past five centuries. While condemned for the ruthlessness and cruelty that it espouses, The Prince has been hailed as the first modern political treatise for the meticulous warfare and statecraft strategies it prescribes to the rulers. It is a sprawling discourse on how a king “needs”, not “ought”, to behave in order to maintain his kingdom; Machiavelli’s Prince is a strategist whose decisions are based on calculating reason rather than on any abiding faith in morality or virtue. His overarching argument is to value, in order to achieve and hold power, being feared over being loved, being cruel over being kind, being parsimonious over being generous, and so on.

While other texts in the wisdom tradition – Plato’s Republic and Aurelius’ Meditation, for example – emphasize the importance of a ruler being “good” and “just”, Machiavelli concerns himself solely with practicality, dismissing the philosophical tradition of holding rulers to moral perfection. Under the light of comparison then, it is easy to dismiss The Prince as an aberration in the history of classical philosophy; after all, it never came to be read by a ruler and Machiavelli himself saw little political success in his life after writing it (Machiavelli, p. 9).

Yet, interspersed through The Prince are phrases like “… without burdening the people (Machiavelli, p. 64)” which make the reader wonder at the engaging struggle between what he prescribes for the king – a relentless and amoral pursuit of reasoning and strategy – and what he hopes the king will achieve for his populace, which is overall stability and peace. At stake is a fundamental rift between what Machiavelli’s Prince does to win and maintain states, and why he does it. Machiavelli prizes a king’s use of far-reaching...

Read more


11 13 18202 19 2001 2013 23 28 35 39 43 44 5 62 64 65 83 9 aberr abid abject abl absenc absolut accord achiev acquir action acut addit address advic advis aid aim allow also ambigu ambit amongst amor ancient anoth anti anti-christian1 apolog apostl appear argument armi ask assign attent attitud aurelius author awar balanc base beget behav believ benevol best better bibl biblic blanket borgia bring brought burden calcul came caus cautious center central centuri cesar cheek christian christian1 cite citi claim classic clemenc clement coher come compar comparison compet complement complet concept concern conclus condemn confid conflict consid consum consumm content contrast control cosmos counsel counselor countri cruel cruelti damrosch danger deal death decis deepli defend deleg demonstr deplet deriv desir differ difficulti direct disclaim discont discours discuss disdain dismiss disord dispens distant distinct distribut distrust divin divinely-cent done duti easi easili effect effici electron elimin emphas encyclopedia enemi engag english enough entrust equal espous establish esv evalu even exampl excess exchang execut expect expound extend extens extern extrem eye face fact faction faith famous far far-reach favor fealti fear fellow fend first five follow forc form fortress friend full fundament furthermor futur gain gateway generos generous get go god good gospel greater grow hail happi harm hate hazleton heal help henc hide histori hold homag home hope howev human import inadvert includ inde india inher inspir instead integr intent interest interfer intern interspers jesus judici keep kill kind king kingdom know known larger leader learn lend lenient less let lie life light like littl live lord love loyal loyalti machaivelli machiavelli machiavellian maintain make mani marriott mass matthew may medit men mention merci messag meticul mind minim miracl misalign misinterpret misread mistrust modern moral motiv much must n n.d n.p necess necessari need needless neglect neighbor neighborhood never newli nobil nobl non non-interfer none note nov obey oblig offens old one opposit order other ought overal overarch overwhelm p p.63 p.70 pa paper parabl parad paragon parsimoni part parti particular past pay peac peopl percept perfect perish person persuas philosoph philosophi phrase pictur place plan2 plato play polit ponder poor popul populac popular portray power practic preach prefer prepar prescrib present preserv prevent princ princip privat privi prize process proclaim professor profound project promin protect protector prove provid psu psu-hazleton pursuit put question ramiro rare rather reach read reader readi reason rebellion refer reform relationship relentless religion reproach republ respons revolt rift right rise risk role ruin ruler run ruthless sacrific save saw say scheme scrupul see seed seem seen select selfish sens seri servic sever sign similar small societi soldier sole sometim sooner sovereignti sprawl stabil stake standard stanford stark state statecraft step still strategi strategist strength strict strike strong struggl subject subservi subsum success suggest support suppress sure suspici swift sword take talk task tenet term text theme thing threat threaten time toler toward tradit translat treat treatis treatment tri troubl trust turn two unchristian unhappi unto usabl use usurp vain valu various version victori view violenc virtu vision w.k war warfar way weapon web welcom whose win wisdom wish without wonder word world would write wrong yet