Essays /

Canada Vs Brazil Essay

Essay preview

How to Make an American Job Before It's Too Late: Andy Grove By Andy Grove July 1, 2010 Bloomberg Opinion

Recently an acquaintance at the next table in a Palo Alto, California, restaurant introduced me to his companions: three young venture capitalists from China. They explained, with visible excitement, that they were touring promising companies in Silicon Valley. I’ve lived in the Valley a long time, and usually when I see how the region has become such a draw for global investments, I feel a little proud. Not this time. I left the restaurant unsettled. Something didn’t add up. Bay Area unemployment is even higher than the 9.7 percent national average. Clearly, the great Silicon Valley innovation machine hasn’t been creating many jobs of late -- unless you are counting Asia, where American technology companies have been adding jobs like mad for years. The underlying problem isn’t simply lower Asian costs. It’s our own misplaced faith in the power of startups to create U.S. jobs. Americans love the idea of the guys in the garage inventing something that changes the world. New York Times columnist Thomas L. Friedman recently encapsulated this view in a piece called “Start-Ups, Not Bailouts.” His argument: Let tired old companies that do commodity manufacturing die if they have to. If Washington really wants to create jobs, he wrote, it should back startups. Mythical Moment Friedman is wrong. Startups are a wonderful thing, but they cannot by themselves increase tech employment. Equally important is what comes after that mythical moment of creation in the garage, as technology goes from prototype to mass production. This is the phase where companies scale up. They work out design details, figure out how to make things affordably, build factories, and hire people by the thousands. Scaling is hard work but necessary to make innovation matter. The scaling process is no longer happening in the U.S. And as long as that’s the case, plowing capital into young companies that build their factories elsewhere will continue to yield a bad return in terms of American jobs. Scaling used to work well in Silicon Valley. Entrepreneurs came up with an invention. Investors gave them money to build their business. If the founders and their investors were lucky, the company grew and had an initial public offering, which brought in money that financed further growth.

Page 1 of 6

Intel Startup I am fortunate to have lived through one such example. In 1968, two well-known technologists and their investor friends anted up $3 million to start Intel Corp., making memory chips for the computer industry. From the beginning, we had to figure out how to make our chips in volume. We had to build factories; hire, train and retain employees; establish relationships with suppliers; and sort out a million other things before Intel could become a billion-dollar company. Three years later, it went public and grew to be one of the biggest technology companies in the world. By 1980, which was 10 years after our IPO, about 13,000 people worked for Intel in the U.S. Not far from Intel’s headquarters in Santa Clara, California, other companies developed. Tandem Computers Inc. went through a similar process, then Sun Microsystems Inc., Cisco Systems Inc., Netscape Communications Corp., and on and on. Some companies died along the way or were absorbed by others, but each survivor added to the complex technological ecosystem that came to be called...

Read more


-1 /news/2010-07-01/how-to-make-an-american-job-before-it-s-too-late-andygrove.html 000 1 1.5 10 100 13 166 1932 1956 1968 1970s 1975 1980 1980s 1987 1990s 2 2005 2010 25 250 2800 3 30 360 4 5 6 600 62 650 800 9.7 abandon abil abl absorb accumul achiev acquaint act action activ ad adapt add adjust advanc advis afford afraid ago alan along alreadi also altair altern alto america american ammunit andi anoth answer ant appl appli applic area aren argument around array asia asian ask assembl assign astound author automobil avail avenu averag awar away back bad bailout bank base basi basic batteri bay bayonet beat becam becom began begin behalf beij belief believ best bet better big biggest billion billion-dollar bit blade blinder bloc bloomberg brazil breakdown breed brilliant bring broke brought build built busi businessweek calcul california call came can canada cannot capac capit capitalist car care case catch cavalri cell centric chain chairman challeng chanc chang charg chase cheaper check chief china chines chip choic cisco clara clear close co coffer columnist combin come comment commit commod common communic communiti compani companion competitor complex comput computer-manufactur condemn consequ conserv consid consist consol consumerpag continu contractor contribut convict convinc coordin corp corros cost could couldn count countless countri creat creation crucial current custom daili damag day deal decad decid decis declin defin dell demand demonstr depend deposit descent design detail deterior develop devic didn die digit dilig director directorsfor disagre discov disk disk-driv divid doesn dollar domest done doubt dramat draw drive driven drop due eager earli earlier easi easier east econom economi economist ecosystem effect effici electr electron elev elsewher emerg employ employe enabl encapsul encount energi engin enjoy entrepreneur equal equip establish estim even ever everi everyappl evid evolut exampl excit execut execution exist expand expect experi explain explod export exposur express exquisit extra face factori failur faith fals familiar far featur feel fewer fight figur film final financ financi firm first first-hand five fix fled focus follow forc forgotten fortun found founder four foxconn free free-market freer friedman friend full fund fundament futur gadget gain gap garag gave general generat get giant global go goal goe golden got govern grant great greater grew grove grow grown growth guid guillotin gulp guy hadn hai hand happen happi hard hasn head headquart health health-car heard help herd hesit hewlettpackard high high-valu high-value-ad higher hinder hire histori hold home home-energi hon hous howev hp hungari idea illustr imac imper import improv inc incent increas indic individu individualist industri ineffici inflat inform infrastructur initi innov intel intellig interest introduc invent invest investor involv ion iphon ipo ipod isn issu japanes job job-centr job-machin jobless join juli keep key kind knew know knowhow knowledg known l labor laptop larg larger largest last late later lead leadership learn left less lesson let levi like lithium lithium-ion lithiumion littl live local locat lock london long longer loos lose lost love lower lucki m machin mad made maintain make maker man manag mani manufactur margin mark market mask mass matter may mean meantim meanwhil measur memori memory-chip met microprocessor microsoft microsystem might mileston million mind misplac misstep mistak mit modif moment money motherboard move much must mythic naiv nation necessari need netscap network new newspap next nokia nowaday number numer object oblivi observ obvious offer offic offshor often oil ok old one onetim open oper opinion organ other outsid overreach oversea oyj page paid palo panel part particip particular partner pass passag past pc peculiar pennsylvania pentium peopl per percent perform perhap peril person phase phone photo photo-act photovolta piec pioneer place plan plant play plenti plow plus point polici polit popul posit potenti power preced precis pressur previous princeton principl prioriti probabl problem process produc product profit project promis protectionist prototyp proud provid public pulley pursu pursuit put rapid rate ratio real realli reason rebuild recent region relationship reli remain rememb remind requir respons restaur result retain return revenu revers roar robert role room rose rough rug run rusti santa say scale school seagat see seem seen sell semiconductor senior separ seri set sever share sharehold shatter shenzhen ship show silicon similar simpl simpli sinc size societi solar soldier solv someth soni sort sound southern soviet spate spectacular spend spread sputter stabil stake stare start start-up startup state stay steel stick stockhold stop stori strateg strategi stratifi strong stuck studi success suggest suicid sum sun suppli supplier sure surpris survivor system tabl taiwan take taken talk tandem tank target task tax tech technolog technologist televis term theori thing think thoma thorough though thought thousand three time tini tire to1 today told tomorrow tour trade tradit tragic train transact transfer treat truck truism turn tv two u.s ultim under understand undervalu undoubt unemploy univers unless unlik unquest unsettl untold up upon us use usual valley valu vc vcs ve vehicl ventur versus veteran victori view visibl volum vs wade wage wait want war washington wasn way well well-known went weren whatev whether white whoever whose wife wild win wit without wonder work worker world worldwid would wrong wrote xbox year yet yield york young zero