Essays /

Canada S Foreign Policy Post 9 Essay

Essay preview

The Impact of 9-11 on Human Security in Canada’s Foreign

Draft: Please do not quote

Paper to be presented on
C10: Responses to the American
“War on Terrorism”: Political Parties and Democracy
Canadian Political Science Association,
Saskatoon, June 1, 2007

Dr. Stefan Gänzle
Visiting Assistant Professor (DAAD)
University of British Columbia
Institute for European Studies/Political Science
182 C. K. Choi, 1855 West Mall
Vancouver, BC V6T 1Z2
[email protected]

Abstract: This paper presents an analysis of Canadian foreign policy and its changes in the post-September 11th (9/11) world focusing of the emergence and sidelining of the ‘human security’ (HS) agenda. The paper argues that the securitization of the HS agenda has reduced its normative power substantially, and that domestic politics have reshaped the HS agenda into a US-led security dialogue in which the Canadian state has lost its impetus as a prime mover or the normative weight acquired in the 1990s by the advancement and attainment of key HS agenda items such as the Ottawa Convention and Treaty.

I. Introduction
Throughout the second half of the 1990s, the concept of ‘human security’ became closely associated with Canadian foreign policy. The then foreign minister Lloyd Axworthy was clearly seen as a norm entrepreneur within various international organizations popularizing a ‘new’ approach in international politics which emphasizes the importance of protecting individuals and communities from any form of political violence in contrast to national security (albeit mutually reinforcing) which, in turn, focuses on the defense of the state from external attack. 1 Although human security declined conceptually as soon as Lloyd Axworthy had left Ottawa in 2000, its agenda did not entirely lose momentum – as this paper will show. As a normative concept it has contributed to inform a number of Canadian foreign policy domains, soften domestic policies vis-à-vis (international) terrorism and still seems to be rather well-entrenched in the foreign affairs bureaucracy. In the aftermath of 9-11, Ken Roach suggested that Canadian foreign policy should insist that “terrorist threats be integrated into a broader human security agenda and separated from American geo-political interests.” 2 Thus, how much of human security survived in Canadian post 9-11 (foreign) policy, 3 or, alternatively, was human security nothing more than an ‘Axworthy doctrine’ destined to disappear once the prominent close to Nobel prize-winning foreign minister had left office?

Without downplaying the terrorism-related areas on which Canada has stood firm and opposed US action, I argue that, at the level of domestic politics, Canada took many post 9-11 actions in direct response to US concerns or in an effort to align Canadian efforts with those of the United States. In contrast, however, Canada pursued a more liberal, multilateral and comprehensive approach – ultimately spurred by human security – similar to other civilian powers such as Japan or Germany. 4 Thus, while it is right to assume that a “continental divide” emerged between Canada and the United States internationally (albeit somewhat remedied by the new Conservative government coming into power in March 2006), domestically pragmatic cooperation (in the shadow of US domination) between both partners prevailed.

This paper proceeds in a threefold way: first, it situates the concept against the backdrop of Canadian foreign policy demonstrating that human security, in principle, subscribes to the multilateral tradition of an “activist state” 5 or middle power. Second, it analyzes human security as well as its development as a theoretical and practical tool of Canadian foreign policy starting in the late 1990. Third, it provides an analytical assessment of Canada’s major anti-terrorist measures introduced in the aftermath of 9-11. In the context of this analysis, it evaluates the role human security played in Canada’s efforts to counter terrorist threats.

II. The pillars of Canadian foreign policy
Since the end of World War II, Canadian foreign policy unfolds in a (virtual) dynamic triangle defined by the interplay of three basic factors. The first one is set by the fact that Canada is a North American country sharing the largest land border of the world with the United States in the South and North West (Alaska), the “big elephant” to use an image by Pierre Trudeau. Since the late 1980s, there have been increasing efforts of regional (economic) integration on the North American continent. The Canada-US free trade agreement in force since 1989 was eventually superseded by the creation of the North American Free Trade Area (NAFTA) including Mexico in 1994. In March 2005, the


Security and Prosperity Partnership of North America (SPP) was launched as a trilateral effort to compliment economic cooperation with greater cooperation and information sharing in the field of security. Canadian foreign and defense policy is strongly influenced by the overall climate of the US-Canada relationship, as are virtually all sectors of Canadian society. 6 The infrastructures of both countries are greatly interlinked, such as for instance the energy power grids, making Canada – given its size and resources –the more vulnerable partner in the bilateral relationship. Moreover, any terrorist threat targeting US domestic infrastructure in terms of water supply, energy and transportation is also likely to translate into an immediate threat to Canada. It is estimated that more than one third of Canada’s GDP is generated through trade with the US, and roughly 80 per cent of Canada’s trade in goods and services is with the US. 7 For many manufacturers in Canada, the US market is more important than the domestic one. Jennifer Welsh elucidates, “[t]he value of trade in goods and services that crosses the 49th parallel every day is now CDN $ 1.9 billion. Each day, more than half a million people and 45,000 trucks cross our common border.” 8 Against this backdrop, it becomes crystal clear why issues related to border security such as the USproposed Western Hemisphere Travel Initiative (WHTI) are of paramount importance to Canada. 9 In the aftermath of the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001, the CanadianUS trade relationship was increasingly penetrated by security concerns articulated by Canada’s southern neighbor. 10 In contrast, south of the border, only 19 per cent of US exports are destined for Canada. Still, for 39 US states the Canadian market is the most important one for their exports. 11 From a US perspective, Canada is most significant as a reliable supplier of energy and raw materials.

Furthermore, the predominance of the US in the bilateral relationship became deeply entrenched in defense matters. Sharing a land border with the US, Canada’s territorial defense is more closely integrated with the US than with any other NATO member. Canada assumes commitments in various bilateral defense agreements established to secure the territorial integrity of the North American continent, such as NORAD and the Arctic Distant Early Warning defense system. The cooperative proximity between Canada and the US in matters of defense sees the Canadian Department of National Defense (DND) tend to lean much more towards NATO – and implicitly the United States –, whereas the Department of Foreign Affairs (DFAIT) tends to be more UN-leaning. While human security was certainly more influential with DFAIT, it also resounded in DND: “…while for diplomats and humanitarian or development workers human security has created a paradigm within which it is now possible to act with the support of international institutions and against the previously sanctioned rights of a state, this is of little practical consequence to the Canadian military…DND does human security already; it just does not speak human security.” 12 It is very difficult for Canadians to escape the shadow of power projected by their southern neighbor; at the same time, it is also clear that Canadians want to distance themselves in many respects from the policies of the US, in particular with regards to social policy, environmental issues and international law. Hence, the permanent quest for differentiation has been a catalyst if not the engine of ‘Canadian identity’. Although these contentious issues have been on the US-Canadian policy agenda for a while, the rift has grown since the George W. Bush administration came into power; a rift including a wide range of norms and policy issues – ranging from softwood lumber trade, the role of


international trade courts in NAFTA and the World Trade Organization (WTO) to questions concerning Canada’s internationally contested Northern sovereignty over the Arctic archipelago – has become discernible. A few public opinion polls have revealed that this rift also translates into an increasing “feeling of distinctiveness” between USAmericans and Canadians. Less Canadians today think of US as Canada’s “closest friend” (now 53 per cent, formerly 60 per cent). 13

The second factor is defined by the fact that Canada, in many regards of its sociopolitical life, is both a ‘European’ and multicultural country in terms of values and norms. 14 While it has always been an immigrant country, Canada has integrated a substantial inflow of immigrants from China, India and African states into its society over the past two decades. Moreover, the Canadian immigration experience is widely – within the country and outside – considered to be successful. 15 The existence of many different communities has been made possible by the presence of values such as societal openness, transparency and inclusiveness in Canadian political life. As a member of the Commonwealth, numerous historical affinities with Europe in general and the United Kingdom in particular still prevail. These affinities are also deeply entrenched in Canada’s constitutional, social and political life. Canada’s second founding nation, Québec maintains very close relations with Europe in general and France in particular. In many regards, the system of governance and the federal structures of Canada and the European Union share quite a few commonalities. Furthermore, both Europeans and Canadians hold similar views on a number of domestic (e.g. social policy) as well as international issues (e.g. Kyoto, ICC, UN). Still, the growing convergence in these policy areas has not translated to a deeper economic relationship. As trade has been stagnating over the past few years, both Canada and the EU now focus on improving the conditions for mutual investments and services.

The third factor is defined by Canada’s global vocation which has roots in a legacy of Commonwealth membership and the obligation to co-opt into Britain’s global role until the decline of the Empire. Today, however, it is mostly motivated by Canada’s...

Read more


-1092 -11 -126 -20 -216 -44 -48 -57 -665 -7 -8 -84 -9 /8 /content/view/24/59/ /news/releases/2005/03/20050323-3.html 000 074 1 1.9 10 100 1067 11 11th 12 124 13 1373 14 15 16 166 17 18 182 1855 19 1948 195 1956 1968 1980s 1988 1989 199 1990 1990s 1993 1994 1996 1997 1998 1999 1z2 2 20 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 201 204 21 21st 22 224 23 24 246 25 255 26 27 28 28.05.07 29 2nd 3 30 31 32 33 34 344 35 36 37 37th 38 39 4 40 41 42 43 44 45 45th 46 47 48 49 49th 5 53 6 60 62 63 651 7 72 8 80 85 9 9/11 a/561160 a13 abroad abstract academ academia accept access accommod accord account acheson achiev acid acknowledg acquir across act action activ activist actor adapt add.1 address adequ adjust administr admit adopt advanc affair affari affect affin afghanistan africa african aftermath age agenc agenda agre agreement aim air aircrew airport alaska albeit alfr align alleg alli allianc allow almost alreadi also altern although alway ambassador ambit america american among ampl analysi analyst analyt analyz andrew announc annual anoth anti anti-fre anti-glob anti-land anti-personnel anti-terror anti-terrorist antiamerican antipersonnel apec appear applic appoint approach appropri april arar archipelago arctic area arena arf argu argument arm armament arrang arriv articul asean ash asia asia-pacif ask aspect aspir assembl assess asset assist associ assum asylum asymmetr atlant attack attain attempt attent attitud attract audienc augst august austria author autumn avail avenu avert aviat avoid awar away axworthi b b6 back backdrop background bad balanc ban bandwagon bank base basic bc becam becom began begun behind belgium benefit berlin bermuda besid best better bi bi-nat bibek big bigger bilater bill billion birth black blanch blur board bodi bomb book border brazil bridg bring britain british broader broken budgetari build bureaucraci bureaucrat bush busi börzel c c10 call came campaign canada canada-us canadian canadian-american canadianus capabl capac caribbean cart case catalyst caus cbsa cdn cent center centr central centre-right centuri certain certif cf cfc chair challeng chang character charg charter check children china choi chosen chrétien cia cit cite citi citizen citizenri citizenship civil civilian claim claimant clarifi clash clear climat clinton close closest co co-oper co-opt co-ordin coalit code coin cold colin collabor collect collector collin columbia combat come command commission commit common commonwealth communic communiti compet complex compliment compon comprehens compris conceiv concept conceptu concern conclus condit conflict connect consequ conserv consid consider consist consolid constitut constrain consult contain contenti contest context contin continent continu contraband contrast contribut control convent converg convict coolli cooper coordin core cornerston corr.1 correct could council counter counter-terror counterpart counterterror countri court creat creation credibl crime crimin crisi critic cross cross-bord cross-cultur crucial crystal csc cse csis ctag ctcb cultur current custom cut cut-back cyber d.c daad date daughter david day dc deal dean debat debroy decad decemb declar declin deeper deepli defenc defens defin delay delhi delinqu deliv demand democraci democrat demonstr deni denmark depart depend deploy deputi describ descript design despit destin destruct detect deterr develop dewitt dfait dhs dialogu differ differenti difficult diplomaci diplomat diplomatic/development direct director disagre disappear disast discern disclosur discont discours disdain dismiss disrupt dissent distanc distant distinct distinguish diverg divers divert divid divis dixon dnd do-good doctrin document dollar domain domest domin downgrad downplay dr draft draw driver drug dunant dynam e e-publ e.g eagl earli earlier easier econom economi economist ed edgar effect effici effort elabor elect electron element eleph elimin elizabeth elsewher elucid embassi embrac emerg emphas emphasi empir emul enabl end endang endnot energi enforc engag engin enjoy enough ensur enter entir entiti entrench entrepreneur entri entrust environ environment equip equiti equival era escap especi essay establish estim etatist etc ethno ethno-cultur eu europ european evalu even eventu everi evian evid exampl exercis exert exist expand experi expert expertis export express extend extent extern facet facilit fact factor failur fair fall fals far fatf favor fbi februari feder feel field final financ financi fine fintrac firearm firm first fius five five-year-review flexibl flight flow focal focus follow fora forc forefront foreign foremost forerunn form format former formul forti forty-f forum forward foster found foundat four franc fraudul free freedom freez french friend front front-lin frozen fulfil function fund fundament furthermor futur g g8 g8-bodies gain gander garton gather gave gazett gdp general generat geneva geo geo-polit geograph georg germani get give given glaneagl gleanagl global globe goal god golden good gooder got govern government-issu governor grand grate great greater grid group grow grown guidanc gänzle haglund half handbook hann hansard haq hard harnisch harper harsh hatr haven head health healthier heavier hei heinbeck held help hemispher henc henceforth henri high highlight hijack histor histori hold home homeland hope host hostag hous howev hs hubert human humanitarian hundr hussein i.e iansa ibid icao icc idea ident identif identifi ii iii illeg imag immedi immigr immin imo impact imper impetus implement implic implicit import improv inabl incid includ inclus increas indecis india individu indulg inextric inflow influenc influenti inform infrastructur initi innov insecur insist inspect inspector instanc instead institut instrument integr intellectu intellig intent inter inter-st interdepend interest intergovernment interlink intern internationalist interplay intersect interven intervent interview intra intrins introduc introduct invad invent invest investig involv iraq ireland irpa isa issu item iv januari japan jean jennif jluy job john join joint joseph journal judgment juli julian june justic juvenil k kai keep ken kenkel key kilomet kingdom knopf konark kosovo kyoto labor labrador lack land landmin larg large-scal largest last late later latter launch launder law lead leader leadership lean least led left legaci legal legisl legitim leo less lester level liber licens life light like like-mind limit lindley lindley-french line link list literatur littl live lloyd local logic london long long-stand long-term longer longest look lose lost loui lower lumber m made mahub mail main maintain major make maker mall manag manchest mandat mani manifest manley manner manufactur manuscript map march margaret marin maritim market martin mass massiv mastermind materi matter maull may mccallum mcgill mcgill-queen mean measur medium meet member membership mexico middl might migrant migrat militari million mind mine minist minut mirror misrepresent mission mix mode model modern momentum money month montreal montreal/kingston moral moreov morn most motiv mount movement mover much multi multi-facet multicultur multilater multipl must mutual nafta nagi nation nato nato-l natur navig necess necessarili need needless neglect negoti neighbor network new newfoundland newslett newspap next ngo ngos nobel non non-stat non-viol nongovern norad norm normat north northern norway notabl noth notic notion notwithstand npb number numer nutshel nye oa object oblig observ occur octob offenc offens offer offic offici one ontario onward op open oper opinion oppos opt option order ordin organ origin osc other ottawa outlin outsid over-al overal overstretch own pacif pakistani pandem panitch paper parad paradigm parallel paramount parliament parliamentari parol part parti partial particular partner partnership pass passeng passport past path pattern paul pauli peac pearson penalti penetr peopl people-cent per perceiv period perman person personnel perspect pertin photo pierr pile pillar place plan plane platform play player pleas point polic polici policy-mak policymak polit politician politiqu poll popul popular portfolio pose posit possibl post post-cold post-kosovo post-septemb potenti power practic practition pragmat predat predomin preoccup prepar prepared presenc present presid press prevail prevent previous primari primarili prime princ principl prior prioriti prison privat prize prize-win pro pro-ban procedur proceed process professor program prohibit project promin promot proof propos prosecut prosper protect protocol provid provinc provis provok proxim psep psepc public public-priv publish pulpit punch punish purdi pursu push put quebec queen quest question quick quit quot québec r2p rain rais ralli rang rather ratif raw rcmp re re-ent reach read realm recent recogn recommend reconcil reconnect reconstitut recruit red reduc refer reflect refuge regard regim region regul regular reinforc relat relationship releas reliabl religi reluct remain remark remedi remov repercuss replac report repres represent republ reput requir reshap resolut resound resourc respect respond respons restart result retriev reveal review richter riddel riddell-dixon ridg rift right rigor rise risk riss roach robinson rogu role root rooy rough roundtabl royal rule run run-up saddam safe safeti said salw sanction sasha saskatoon say scale scene scienc scope sea seal search sebastian second secretari secretariat secretary-gener section sector secur securit see seek seem seen select self self-descript sell send sens sent separ septemb septembr serious serv servic session set sever [email protected] shadow share shift show shown side sidelin sign signal signific similar sinc singl situat six size small smart smooth smuggl so-cal social societ societi sociopolit soft soften softwood someth somewhat soon south southern sovereignti speak special specif speech spin spin-off sponsor spp spread spur stabl stage stagnat stanc stand standard start state statement stefan step stephen stern still stock stock-pil stood stop strand strategi strengthen stress strict string strive strong stronger structur studi studies/political subject subscrib subsequ substanti success suggest summer summit superior supersed supplement suppli supplier support suppress sure surpris surround surveil surviv suspend suspici sustain switzerland sympathi synchron system tabl take talk tanja target task team technic tend term territori terror terrorism-rel terrorist theme theoret think third thirteen thoma though thought thousand thread threat three threefold throughout thrust thus tie tighten time timothi today togeth tom took tool toronto toronto/buffalo toward trace track trade tradit traffick train transact transfer translat transnat transpar transport travel treati tri triangl trilater truck trudeau true trust turn tutelag twenti twenty-first two u.s ul ul-haq ultim umbrella un un-lean un-sponsor unar uncertainti understand understood undp unfold union uniqu unit univers unlaw unnot unpublish unstr unwil uphold upon urg us us-canada us-canadian us-l usamerican use uspropos util v v6t valu van vancouv varieti various vehicl venu via view vii violat violenc violent virtual vis vis-à-vi visa vision visit vital vocat voic vs vulner w wake walk want war warn washingon washington washington-bas water way wco weak weapon websit weight welch well well-articul well-entrench well-plac well-understood welsh west western wherea whether whisper white whose whti wide widespread will win within without won work worker world worldwid would wto ww www year yet york à