Essays /

Canadian Identity And The Loyalist Myth Essay

Essay preview

Since the process of decolonization, but especially in recent decades, the study of British imperialism has involved examining the development of identity, not only in metropolitan Britain, but in the colonies as well. In the case of English-Canadian history J.M.S. Careless described three schools of thought in 1954, each providing a different stance on imperial Britain’s ties with Canada. The Britannic school, which was predominant from the 19th century until the early 20th century historians claims the British Empire is a community unified by common British institutions and including subjects of a common British race. The Political Nationhood School is more critical of ties between Canada and imperial Britain, instead focusing on how Canada became its own autonomous nation. Finally, there is the Environmental School which argues that Canadian institutions and North Americans were shaped more by their “American” circumstances instead of just imperial British identity being the basis for Canadian identity . Careless himself “encouraged a trend away from viewing Canadian identities in their wider, imperial setting” . This method of studying Canadian identity on the national level has continued from the late 50’s through the 1980’s. Only in the past fifteen years has the study of Canadian identity been steered back towards an imperial setting instead of an insular national one.

However, the debate over the origins of Canadian identity, whether it is more “American”, (imperial) British, or something else continues. This is exemplified by the debate over the impact of Loyalists and Canadian Loyalism in the creation of a Canadian identity. Some of the works analyzed in this essay argue that Loyalists and Loyalism were important in defining Canadian politics, other works emphasized Loyalism’s impact on Canadian cultural identity, some argued that the imperial connection was vital to Loyalists, and some the (North) American connection, and one source largely downplays the Loyalist impact on Canadian identity altogether. It is Buckner’s ideas on Canadian identity that I found myself in agreement with. He emphasizes the common rights, institutions, and ethnicity (albeit a vague concept) between Britain and English Canadians and how that made Canada in many ways a British nation during its history as a colony. This is similar to some of the other works except that Buckner emphasizes the influence of the vague idea of shared British ethnicity, at times based on ancestry in the United Kingdom but also subjectively applied on a broader cultural definition of British values and culture. However, identifying themselves as a British nation, “did not prevent English-Canadians from developing an overlapping sense of North American or Canadian identity” .

Before examining the different relevant works it is vital to understand what the phrase “Canadian Loyalism” implies. This loyalist myth is best displayed in a passage from David Mills’s The Idea of Loyalty in Upper Canada, 1784-1850, which states: “Rather than submit to a successful rebellion they forsook the land of their forefathers—their homes,--their families—in many instances, their friends, and all they hitherto held dear upon earth; and plunged unhesitatingly into the depths of difficulties of a boundless forest, there to teach their children, amidst every species of privation those lessons of patriotism and faithfulness, they had so nobly illustrated in action.”

Canadian Loyalism is based on allegiance to the Crown and common ties with British institutions, politics, and the constitution. However, it is also argued that involves being linked to a common British (white, Protestant, preferably but not necessarily Anglo-Saxon) race. It was not until the 1980’s that Canadian Loyalism, whether its reality or later rhetoric, came to be seen in most English-Canadian scholarship as actually being a positive part of the formation of a Canadian identity rather than a hindrance to it. That the imperial identity of Loyalism was not absolute submissiveness to the Crown or oligarchy, but an affirmation and conservative means to preserve rights and institutions associated with Britishness but adapted to the North American scene, though it was likely genuine toryism for some. However, as mentioned before, there is considerable debate and difference between the works critiqued on the full extent and nature of the Loyalist influence on Canada and English Canadians own sense of identity.

The oldest work examined in this essay is a book by Wallace Brown and Hereward Senior titled Victorious in Defeat: Loyalists in Canada. The stated intention of the authors is to, “examine the role of the Loyalists in Canadian history without falling under the spell of the Loyalist myth or Loyalist-phobia. Their story is a crucial part of Canada’s relevant past in its “search for identity.” The authors argue against the negative Loyalist myth by arguing that loyalists that settled in Canada did not simply identity as British and subservient to a Tory ideal of hierarchy. Instead they argue that Loyalists, “reflected all shades of political opinion”, with Loyalists such as the “Ryersons and Buells among the popular reformers of the period” (1830’s) .

While this work seeks to show that Loyalists were not all mindlessly obedient to toryism and the imperial connection, are they also arguing that Loyalists, Loyalism, or the imperial connection were not important? No and yes. Brown and Senior do demonstrate the impact on politics in Canada that the presence of Loyalists had: such as a need for cooperation with French Canadians leading to an acceptance of diversity in politics, the powerful position Loyalists and their descendants held in government, low levels of republican sentiment, and of course the conventions and procedures borrowed from British parliamentary tradition . Instead of a setting a single tone of conservative toryism among Loyalists, this work makes the case that the Loyalists contributed to a more diverse Canadian political identity. Further, although they claim the “Loyalist myth,” was woven by the more conservative Loyalists, and “was only the property of those Loyalists who cared to claim it” , loyalty to the Crown and parliamentary principles was something that all Loyalists did share at least somewhat. Beyond this vague loyalty, however, the identity of “Britishness” among English Canadians is not really mentioned.

Brown and Senior conclude with a few ideas that seem a bit of leaps and are not particularly supported in the rest of the text. For example, Brown and Senior indicate Loyalist presence in Canada helped influence a more peaceful western expansion due to Loyalists being persecuted in the past, and Loyalists accept state-enterprise and aid preparing Canadian political culture for socialist trends and welfare . While conclusions can be expected to include a certain amount of idle speculation, the fact that Brown and Senior argue away from a strong Canadian Loyalism and British connection, and toward a more diverse and liberal national identity seems to put thi...

Read more


-17 -1850 -49 -5 -51 -53 -65 1 10 109 11 121 131 133 138 139 14 15 16 17 1783 1784 1792 1812 1815 1820 1830 1837 1840 1859 187 188 190 191 1914 192 1942 1946 1954 1965 1971 1979 1980 1984 1986 1987 1988 1990 1993 1994 19th 2 2001 2008 207 208 209 20th 220 221 229 253 254 3 34 36 47 5 50 52 57 6 89 9 90 91 abl aborigin absolut accept account acquisit act action actual adapt addit address adher adopt advoc affirm afterward agre agreement aid aim albeit alien allegi allegori allianc allud almost alongsid alreadi also although altogeth alway ambiti america america/canada american amidst among amount analysi analyz anarchi ancestri anglo anglo-american anglo-saxon anoth answer anti anti-republican anyth anyway appar appear appli argu argument aristocrat articl ask aspect assert assimil assist associ attempt attent australian author autonom autonomi autumn avoid awar away back background baer balanc barbar barn base basi bastion becam becom begin believ bell besid best better beyond bit blackwel blend bloodsh blur book book-length borrow boundless breadth britain britann british british-american british-north broaden broader brother brought brown brunswick brutal buckner buell build calhoon call came canada canadian capric care careless cartwright case categori center central centuri certain chanc chang chapter character chief children chilton christoph chronolog circumst citat cite citizen claim class clear closest code coincid coleman coleson collect coloni colonist combin come common communiti companion compar comparison competit complex compon composit comprehens concept concern conclud conclus concret concur condit conflict connect conscious conserv consid consider consist consolid constitut constrain contemporari contend context continu contribut convent cooper corner could counter counter-revolutionari countri cours creat creation credit crise critic critiqu crown crucial crucibl ct cultur curti daniel david dear debat decad decis declin decolon defeat defend deferenti defici defin definit delic demand democraci demonstr deni depth descend descent describ descript deserv desir desper despit detail determin develop devianc devot diari differ difficulti dig direct disagr disagre disappear discord discours discrimin display disprov dissent distinct distract distress distrust divers divid divis document domest dominion done dougla downplay draw due duti earli earlier earth econom economi edit edward effect effort elabor elit elitist els embrac emerg emphas emphasi empir empow encourag end enemi england english english-canadian english-speak ensur enter enterpris entir entitl entrench environment epic equal equat era errington especi essay essenti establish ethnic european even everi evid evil examin exampl except exclus exemplifi exhibit exil exist expans expect experi explain explor extent extern extrem eye face facet fact factions/strife factor fair faith fall famili far farm favor featur federalist federalist-loyalist feel fell felt fiction fifteen fifti fight final fine first flight focus follow fondest forc forefath forest form format forsook found four fourteen fragil frame fratern fratricid freedom french friend frontier frost fulfil full fundament futur gain garrison gave gender general genuin georg get gideon give given glori go golden good govern grabb grant greater greenwood guid half halifax happen hard hardlin held help hereward hierarchi high higher higher-ord hindranc histor histori historian historiograph historiographi hitherto hold home honor honour host howev human ibid idea ideal ident identifi ideolog idl ignor illiter illustr imbu immigr impact imped imperi imperial-coloni impli import imposs impress improv in-depth inc includ inclus indic indigen individu influenc influenced/influenced influx inform inhabit initi instanc instead institut insular intent interact interest interpret invent involv island issu j.m.s jame jane jar john journal jr justic justifi kingdom kirbi know knowledg lack land larg larger last late later latter law lead leader leap learn least leav left legaci lend length lesson level liber liberti life like limit link lipset lisa liter literatur littl live local long longer look lost low lower lower-ord loyal loyalist loyalist-phobia loyalti m ma mackinnon made main maintain mainten majesti major make malden malic mani march mark masculin materi matter mcclelland mcgill mcgill-queen mean meant measur mention mere met method methuen metropol metropolitan migrat mill mind mindless minist mirror miseri misguid mission model moder modest moment montreal moor motiv move much must myth narrowli nation nationhood nativ natur necessari necessarili need negat neglect negoti neighbor neoconserv new nineteenth nobli noel none norm north note notic nova novel number obedi occur occurr offic often old oldest oligarchi one ontario oper opinion opportun oppos order ordinari organ origin other outlook overkil overlap oxford paper paramount parent parliamentari part parti particip particular partner passag past patriot pattern peac peopl perform period persecut person perspect phillip philosophi phobia phrase place play pleasur plung poem point polici polit politician popul popular populist port posit power practic preclud predomin prefer prepar presenc present preserv presidenti press prevail prevent previous primari principl prior privat problem procedur process produc progenitor prone proper properti propheci propinqu protect protest protocol proven provid provinc provinci public publish put quebec queen question quit quot race racial raddal raj randal rang rather rawlyk read real realiti realli reason rebellion recent recogn recreat recur refer reflect reform refut regardless region regular reign reject relat relationship relev reli religi remain remedi repres represent republ republican requir reserv resourc respect respons rest result retain reveal review revolut revolutionari rhetor richard richardson right rigor road robert role royal rugged rule ryerson s.w sacrific said sarah saw saxon scene schism scholarship school scotia scotian search second secondari section seek seem seen self self-govern self-sacrific senior sens sensibl sentiment separ seri set settl settlement settler shade shape share sheer shelburn shift show shown signific similar simpl simpli sinc singl skelton slight small smaller social socialist societi sociodemograph someth somewhat sourc southern speak speci special specul spell spiritu stanc state state-enterpris static steer stewart still stir stockwel stood stori strengthen strong structur studi subject submiss submit subordin subsequ subservi subvert success suffer suit sulli superior support surpris surround swipe system take taken tale talman task teach tell tender tepperman term territori text theme therebi therefor thesi thing third thirteen thoma thompson thorough though thought thousand threaten three throughout thus tie time timothi titl tone took topic topographi tori toronto toryism toward town trade tradit trafalgar trait transfer transform treat trend tri truli turn two tyranni u.e unclear unconstrain understand understood unhesit unifi uniqu unit univers unquest upon upper upset upton urban use usurp util vagu valu vers versus victori view viii violent vital wallac want war wave way weaken welfar well well-organ western westport wherea whether white wider widespread wilder will william winslow wish within without withstand women wonder work would woven writer written wynn xxiii xxiii-xxvi xxvi yanke year yes yet zealand