Essays /

Canadian Involvement In Afghanistan Is Humanitarian Essay

Essay preview

Intervention means to enter or appear as an irrelevant or extraneous feature or circumstance. The diction expressing irrelevance and extraneous appearance undoubtedly applies to the concept of humanitarian intervention. Despite the proposed intentions of humanitarian intervention, it is often clear that it is not effective in creating sustainable long-term solutions to long-term issues. Canada’s involvement in Afghanistan outlines six priorities that all focus on imposing a democratic system. These priorities call for critique on the fact that a government “by the people” is being developed by an extraneous force. Human intervention does not produce an independent democratic body but a dependent state as a new source for exploitation. Canada’s involvement temporarily addresses civil rights issues but at the expense of substantial progress for Afghanistan itself. Presence of military forces in Afghanistan neither tames security and safety threats posed by extremist groups. In fact civilian deaths and other negative outcomes occurring during military occupation will be attributed to Canadian forces and this puts the future safety of the country at risk. Therefore Canada should not be involved in Afghanistan if motivated by development of long-term solutions and protecting their self-interests. These ideas will be examined to substantiate how the extraction of Canadian forces in Afghanistan will offer potential for long term solutions to human rights issues and protect the interests of both Afghani and Canadian people, demonstrating normative thinking and the assumptions associated with economic structuralist thinking.

The North Atlantic Treaty Organization’s (hereby referred to as NATO) engagement in Afghanistan is focused on developing the country as a democratic body which includes priorities geared towards establishing effective law and justice systems. However attempts to implement this sort of system have violated the very laws that are trying to be established to preserve human rights. A prominent example of this violation would be NATO’s current interest in arming Mujahedeen commanders, guerrilla fighters formed and utilized during the Soviet occupation, in efforts to recruit police forces. Carlotta Gall describes the mujahedeen as having “fearsome reputations...have deep links in communities that can be revived to gather intelligence and...

Read more

Keywords

11th 2014 abl accomplish acknowledg act action actual address advantag affect afghan afghani afghanistan agenda aggress aid allevi alli alreadi also although among amount anoth answer appear appli apprehens arbitrari argu aris arm articl articul associ assum assumpt atlant attack attempt attribut author authorit avenu avoid band band-aid basic benchmark benefit best bland bodi bomb call canada canadian cannot capabl carlotta catalyz caus certain chang choos circumst citizen civil civilian clear close combat command commit common communiti comparison complex compromis concept concern concoct condit conserv consid contenti context continu contribut control convinc core correl corrupt cost could council countri creat credibl criteria critiqu current cycl dampen date de death decid deep deepli defenc degre democraci democrat demonstr densiti depend describ descript despit determin detriment develop diction die difficult diminish diplomat direct discuss disenfranchis disingenu divers done dougla drawn due dyer dynam easili econom economi effect effort eight employ empow enabl encourag enforc engag enrag ensur enter environ establish ethic evid examin exampl expect expens exploit express extend extract extran extremist face facilit fact factor fall fals fearsom featur fifti fight fighter first fit five focus forc foreign foremost form four freedom function fundament futil futur gain gall gather gear give given goal good govern great greater group growth guerrilla gwynn harper head help herebi high high-mind highest hope howev human humanitarian hundr idea imag imageri immedi impact impend imperi implement import impos includ independ indic individu infring initi injustic insignific instabl insurg intact intellig intent interest intern interven intervent interventionist involv irrelev issu journalist justic justifi karzai keep kill lack landscap last law leav left legal less liber lie life light like link littl live long long-term longev loos lose lost louder machiavelli main maintain mainten major make mani manipul margaret may mean member militari militia mind minist minor mission mobil moral motiv mujahedeen multilater must nation nato near need negat neither net new nicer norm norman normat north noth oblig obtain obvious occup occur off offer often one oper oppress order organ other ought outcom outlin overse oxymoron paper part partial particip paul peac peacekeep peopl peripheri perpetu perspect phenomenon place play polic polit pose possibl potenti power presenc present preserv prevent previous primarili prime prioriti privat produc progress promin propos prosper protect put question quick radic rais rather realist realiti realiz rebuild recent recruit refer regain relat relationship relev reminisc repel reput resolv resourc respect respons result resurg reviv revolt revolutionari rife right risk rob rooij root safer safeti said say secur see seem self self-def self-interest self-suffici separ septemb share shed show simpl simpli sinc six societi soldier solidar solut sort sourc sovereign sovereignti soviet speak specifi spector stabl stakehold stand standard state stephen strong structuralist stunt subject substanti suffici suggest superpow support surround sustain system talk tame tax temporarili term terrorist theori therefor think though thought threat thus toward trade trade-off treati tri truli turmoil twenti twenty-eight two u.s ugli un undoubt unit uniti unregul unsustain use util violat violent vital wallerstein war war-fight warfar wealthier weight went western whether will within without word world wors would