Essays /

Canadian Journal Of Learning And Technology Essay

Essay preview

Canadian Journal of Learning and Technology
Volume 31(3) Fall / automne 2005
An Electronic Portfolio to Support Learning1
Anne Wade
Philip C. Abrami
Jennifer Sclater
-------------------------------------------------
Authors

Anne Wade, is Manager and Information Specialist at the Centre for the Study of Learning and Performance/Education, Concordia University, Montreal, Quebec. Correspondence concerning this article can be sent to Anne Wade, Concordia University, LB 581. 1455 de Maisonneuve Blvd. West, Montreal, Quebec, Canada H3G 1M8. Email: [email protected] 

Philip C. Abrami, PhD is a Professor, Director and Research Chair at the Centre for the Study of Learning and Performance, Concordia University, Montreal, Quebec. 

Jennifer Sclater, is an ICT Cosultant at the Centre for the Study of Learning and Performance, Concordia University, Montreal, Quebec. Abstract
Abstract: In this paper, we provide a description of a CSLP research project that looked at portfolio use within a middle school, the web-based e-portfolio software we have developed within the context of the Quebec educational system, our plans for further development of the tool, and our research plans related to the use of portfolios to support learning. Our aim is to combine research evidence on portfolio use with practical feedback from the field in an attempt to develop easy-to-use, powerful software designed to support active self-regulated student learning in schools. Résumé: L’article contient une description d’un projet de recherche du CEAP qui examine l’utilisation de portfolios au sein d’une école secondaire, le logiciel de portfolios électroniques axé sur le Web que nous avons développé au sein du système d’éducation du Québec, nos plans visant le perfectionnement de l’outil et nos plans en matière de recherche visant l’utilisation de portfolios pour appuyer l’apprentissage. Notre objectif est de conjuguer les résultats de la recherche sur l’utilisation de portfolios avec la rétroaction pratique des utilisateurs afin de tenter de développer des logiciels puissants et faciles à utiliser pour appuyer l’apprentissage auto-réglementé et actif des étudiants dans les écoles. Educational Goals of Portfolios

A portfolio may be defined as a purposeful collection of student work that tells the story of a student’s effort, progress and/or achievement in one or more areas (Arter & Spandel, 1992; MacIsaac & Jackson, 1994). The Quebec Education Programme (QEP) (Ministère de l’Education du Québec, 2001) is based on the principles of socio-constructivism including a belief in the value of portfolios and requires teachers and students to develop a proficiency with them. Consequently, the use of portfolios has been mandated within the elementary Language Arts curriculum and is encouraged in other core subject areas. The QEP lists the following as possible advantages of portfolios, they: involve students in their learning (as a tool for reflection); allow students to increase their ability to self-evaluate; teach students to make choices; encourage students to better understand themselves and focus on their strengths; allow students to reflect on their procedures, strategies, and accomplishments so that they can improve and correct them and ultimately succeed; promote feedback during the learning process, particularly during individual conferences; encourage students to reflect on their strengths, needs, errors, interests, challenges, and objectives; encourage interactive processes among students, teachers, and parents; shows student progress because it tracks performance over time; and they are used to assess competencies developed by students. Portfolios can be linked to the following cross-curricular competencies within the QEP (2001): Intellectual Competencies. Encourages students to “use information, to solve a problem, to exercise critical judgment and to use creativity.” (p.13) Methodological Competencies. Encourages students to “e self reliant, to select appropriate means for attaining objectives, to analyze the way they use available resources, and to evaluate the effectiveness of their work methods.” (p.26) Personal and Social Competencies. Encourages students to “exchange points of views with others, to listen and to be open to differences” (p. 35) and to adapt their behaviour to the social context of learning. Types of Portfolios

Danielson and Abrutyn (1997) identified three main types of portfolios: working, showcase, and assessment. Working (also known as “process” or “learning”) portfolios contain works in progress, track student learning over time, and may be temporary because students move on to either an assessment or showcase portfolio. Showcase portfolios exhibit the student’s best work. They are generally used to demonstrate the level of accomplishment that the student has attained. Students often use showcase portfolios during college applications or for professional employment purposes. Assessment portfolios are structured and standardized with “the content of the curriculum determining what students select for their portfolios” (p.5). Digital Portfolios

In the past, portfolios were collections of work stored in binders, file folders, or boxes. Today, computers are used as an effective tool for developing and storing portfolios given their ability to store and process large quantities of content, and because they can effectively support and guide the portfolio process. These computer-based portfolios are called digital or electronic portfolios (e-portfolios). The advantages of using digital portfolios include: * Digital portfolios provide an effective means for cataloguing and organizing learning materials, better illustrating the process of learner development. * Students can easily integrate multimedia materials, allowing them to use a variety of tools to demonstrate and develop understanding. (This may be especially advantageous for at-risk children whose competencies may be better reflected through these authentic tasks.) * Students can develop their Information and Communication Technology (ICT) skills through the creation of multimedia work and use of the tool. * Student work becomes easy to share with peers, teachers, parents and others, and lets students and others provide feedback through a single electronic container. * Digital portfolios provide remote access to work for students to complete homework or when otherwise learning at a distance from school. * Digital portfolios provide remote access to student work for teachers for review and assessment purposes. * Digital portfolios provide an opportunity for greater and improved communication with parents. The use of digital portfolios can be linked to the following cross-curricular competencies within the QEP (2001): * Methodological Competencies . Encourages students to “be familiar with the purposes, concepts, vocabulary, procedures and techniques of ICT,” (p. 29) their use of ICT to carry out a task, and to evaluate their use of ICT. * Communication-related Competency. Encourages students to “experiment with different forms of communication: oral, written, visual, media-related” (p.38). The Portfolio Process

The QESN-RÉCIT * (2005) identified five stages to the portfolio process for print-based or digital portfolios, (1) collection, (2) selection, (3) reflection, (4) evaluation and (5) celebration (see: http://www.qesnRÉCIT.qc.ca/portfolio/ port_eng.html). These stages are analogous to those laid out by Danielson and Abrutyn (1997) for developing portfolios. In the collection stage, teachers and students work together to save artefacts that represent successes and opportunities for growth. In the selection stage, teachers and students review and evaluate the saved artefacts and jointly decide which of those artefacts best demonstrate the achievement of learning goals. At the reflection stage, students articulate their thinking about each piece in the portfolio. Students evaluate their own growth over time as well as discover any gaps in their development. This stage is undoubtedly the most crucial and it is what enables portfolios to become lifelong learning tools. In the evaluation stage students compare their reflections to their pre-set goals and other achievement standards and indicators and set learning goals for the future. Finally, in the celebration, or as Danielson and Abrutyn (1997) call it, the presentation stage; students share their portfolios with their peers. This is the stage where appropriate public commitments can be made to encourage collaboration and commitment to professional developments and lifelong learning (Barrett, 2001). Pedagogical Value and Potential Benefits of Portfolios

In the next two sections we examine the use of portfolios to support student self-regulation and to encourage authentic assessment. Student Self-regulation
Proponents of socio-cognitive models emphasize that to develop effective self-regulated learning strategies, “students need to be involved in complex meaningful tasks, choosing the products and processes that will be evaluated, modifying tasks and assessment criteria to attain an optimal challenge, obtaining support from peers, and evaluating their own work” (Perry, 1998, p. 716). When students use portfolios, they assume more responsibility for their learning, better understand their strengths and limitations, and learn to set goals (Hillyer & Lye, 1996). Educators believe that portfolios allow students to think critically, and become active, independent and self-regulated learners (Mills-Courts & Amiran, 1991; Perry, 1998). Self-regulated learners are individuals who are metacognitively, ...

Read more

Keywords

-6685 /dgfj/dp/programme_de_ /eportfolio/promo/ /portfolio/ 1 1.the 101 11 12 133 1455 148 1499 15 159 162 1989 1991 1992 1993 1994 1996 1997 1998 1999 1m8 2 2000 2001 2004 2005 2006 23 246 265 28 29 296 3 31 33 35 36 361 37 392 4 40 44 48 5 581 60 61 62 63 715 716 72 729 79 90 92 93 abandon abc abc-clic abil abl above-ment above.the abracadabra abracadbra abrami abrutyn abstract academ accept access accompani accomplish accord accuraci achiev acquisit act actif activ adapt addit administr adopt adult advanc advantag afin agre aim alexandria allow alon also altern american amiran among analog analysi analyz and/or angel ann annual anoth answer anticip anxieti appear appli applic apprais apprentissag approach appropri approv approxim appuy april archiv area argument aris art artefact arter articl articul artifact ask aspect assess assign assist associ assum at-risk attain attempt attend attent au audio auditori authent author auto auto-réglementé automn autonom avail avec avon awar award axé b back background barbara barrett base basi basic becom began begin behaviour belanoff belief believ benefici benefit bereit best better beyond bilingu binder blvd board box boynton/cook brought button c c.j ca call camp canada canadian carri case catalogu caus cautious ceap celebr center centr central certain chair challeng chang charg child children choic choos claim class classroom clear clearinghous clic clip cognit collabor collect colleg combin come command commit committe communic communication-rel communiti compar compet compil complain complet complex compon comput computer-bas compétenc concentr concept concern concert conclus concordia conduct confer conferenc confirm confus congruent conjugu connect consequ consid consist constitut construct constructiv consult consum contain content context contient continu contrari contribut control copi core cornwal correct correspond cosult council cours court covari creat creation creativ criteria critic cross cross-curricular crucial cslp culmin cultur current curricular curriculum custom cycl d d.b dan danielson data databas dawson day dc de deal debrief debug decid defin definit demand demonstr depend des describ descript design designers/programmers desir despit detail determin develop development dickson diego differ differenti difficult difficulti digest digit direct director discomfort discov discrimin discuss display/print dissemin distanc distract district download dozen dramat dropout du dual due dyadic dynam développ développé e e-portfolio e.g e.w earli easi easili eastern easy-to-us ed edit editor educ education.teaching effect effort effort-outcom either elabor electron elementari elicit elimin email embed emerg emphas emphasi empir employ en enabl encourag encyclopedia end endeavour energi engag english enhanc enrol enter entir environ erlbaum error es especi essay essenti est establish et etc evalu even evid evidence-bas evnet examin excel exchang excit exercis exhibit exist expect experi experienc expert expertis explain explan explor expos extern extrem face facil facilit fact fact-find failur fall familiar featur feder feedback felt femal fenwick field fifth file filemak final financi find firm first fit five flexibl focus folder follow follow-up fond foot form formation/primaire/educprg2001h.htm forward foster found foundat four four-month fourth fqrsc framework free french friend frustrat ftp full fulli function fund futur g.b gain gap gear gearhart general genuin geographi given glaser global goal grade grader grant great greater gric group grover.concordia.ca grover.concordia.ca/eportfolio/promo/ growth guarante guid guidanc h.c h3g hand happen heart heinemann help henc high high-level higher hillsdal hillyer hire holist home homepag homework honor hope howev hypothes i.e ict idea identifi idiosyncrat il illustr immedi impact implement implic import improv in in-context inadequ includ increas independ index.html indic individu industri ineffect influenc inform initi input inquiri instal instead institut instruct integr intellectu intend intens intent interact interest interfac interim intern internet interpret interview introduct introductori intégrat investig involv isol issn issu item j j.a jackson jade jennif joint journal judgment june jurisdict k k.b kakkar key kind klein know knowledg known koretz kovalchick l l.b la lab lack laid languag larg large-scal later laurier lawrenc lb le lead learn learner learning.canadian learning1 led les less let letter level life life-long lifelong likewis limit line link list listen literaci literatur littl live local locat logiciel long long-term look los low luck lye m m.r macisaac made main maintain maisonneuv make male manag mandat mani manual marri match materi matièr maximum may mb mccaffrey mean meaning measur mechan media media-rel meet member mention meq mere metacognit method methodolog middl mill mills-court ministri ministèr minut mission mix mixed-method mode model modifi monitor month montreal motiv move much multimedia multipl multiple-choic must mysql n.e name nation natur necessari need neither network new next nine nj non non-portfolio non-quebec non-techn norshield nos note notic notr nous novic number numer numeraci ny object objectif observ obtain occur offer often older on-lin one one-day onlin ontario onto open oper opportun optim oral order organ organiz orient origin other otherwis outcom outil outsid overal overcom ownership ownphys p p.13 p.26 p.38 p.5 p.c p.j packag page paper paper-bas par parent parent-teach parson part particip particular partner past pdig pedagog pedagogi peer peer-confer peer-conferenc peer-review percept perfectionn perform performance/education perhap period perri person personn phase phd philanthrop philip php physic piec pilot pinpoint place plan platform pleas plug plug-in point polici polytechn port_eng.html portfolio portfolio/eng/theory.htm portsmouth posit possibl potenti pour power pp practic pratiqu pre pre-set pre-test precept precursor predict prefer prepar present press previous primari principl print print-bas prior pro problem problem-solv procedur process product profession professor profici program programm progress project projet promot prompt propon prototyp provid provinc provinci psycholog public publish puissant purpos pursuit qc qc.ca qc.ca/portfolio/ qep qesn qesn-récit qualit qualiti quantiti que quebec quebecoi question questionnair qui quiet québec québécoi r r.c rand rang rapid rather rational re re-examin read reader readi readili realist realli reap reason receiv recent recherch recogn record redesign reduct refer refin reflect reflections/conferences regard regul regular regulatori relat relationship releas relev reliabl reliant remain remot repeat report repres request requir research resnick resourc respect respond respons ressourc restrict result retriev revamp reveal review risk riversid robert routin rubric récit réglementé réseau résultat résumé rétroaction s.a sampl san santa save say scaffold scale scardamalia schedul school school-bas scientif scientifically-bas sclater score screen seamless second secondair secondari section sector see seek seem seen sein select self self-assess self-evalu self-monitor self-reflect self-regul self-regulatori semest sent separ serv server servic session set setback sever severign share shift short short-answ short-liv short-term show showcas sign signal signific similar sinc singl sir site situat six six-month skill slight small small-scal social societ societé socio socio-cognit socio-constructiv société softwar sole solicit solv sometim sound space spandel special specialist specif specul staff stage stand stand-alon standard state stecher step storag store stori strategi strength stress strong stronger structur struggl student student-friend student-l studentsconstruct studi subject submiss subsequ substanti succeed success suggest sum summar summat supervis support sur sustain swap sweidel system systèm t.c t.j task taught teach teacher teacher-cent teacher-direct team technic technician techniqu technolog tell templat temporari tend tenter term test text theoret theori therefor therrien thesi think third thirti three throughout thus tie time time-manag today togeth tool topic total tout toward township track tradit train transit tri troubl true/false truli two type ultim un unchang underli understand understood underw undoubt une univers urbana us use user utilis utilisateur v va valid valoris valu valuabl variabl varieti various ver vermett vermont version versus video view visant visual vocabulari volum volunt [email protected] wade want washington way weak web web-bas week weexpect well well-design west western wherebi whether whole whose wide wide-scal widespread wilfrid will willing window wish wit within wolf word work workplac workshop worth would write writer written www.meq.gouv.qc.ca www.meq.gouv.qc.ca/dgfj/dp/programme_de_ www.qesn.meq.gouv.qc.ca www.qesn.meq.gouv.qc.ca/portfolio/ www.qesnr yancey yarbrough year yearlong yet york young younger zitkut à écit école éducat électroniqu élèves étudiant