Essays /

Canadian Regionalism Essay

Essay preview

Canadian Regionalism in our Political Life
Canada is known worldwide as a nation that incorporates a number of multiregional identities into its national unification. Its population is made up of peoples from a number of different ethnicities, religions, lifestyles, and traditions, all coexisting under one federal government, and one Canadian nationality. Regionalism is not only a symbol of pride to Canada, however, it is also an issue with regards to political proficiency in the Federal government. The vast differences between the regions within Canada make it problematic for the government to represent all requests of its people at a national level. The number of distinct regions in Canada can be detrimental to this process in that it hinders the development of a national vision for the country. It seems hard to imagine that a country as large as Canada can elect a majority government that effectively represents all multi-regional agendas, considering that each party’s agenda seems to favour the interests of a certain region above others. This is evident in the platforms of the parties and the beliefs of their leaders with regards to economic, cultural and social patterns present in Canada. The economic stability of Canada as a nation is greatly influenced, and reliant, on the regions of the country having strong economic bases. From 1867 to the mid 1950s, Canada’s government had no explicit policy of regional development, instead, it directed its economic policy solely on national development. According to Savoie (2003) the idea was that a strong national economy, based on east-west trade and tariffs would benefit all regions (page. 149). WW1 ensued, and this model was vanquished whilst the Great Depression left poorer provinces in devastation. Savoie (2003) also comments that the U.S. has been much more successful in promoting regional balance in its national economy. He remarks that this is because “each state has 2 senators and the senate plays an important role in policy and decision making and impacts national policy making” (page. 163). In Canada, on the other hand, the senate has never been able to establish itself as a credible institution speaking to the interests of the regions (Savoie, 2003, page. 163). Canada is not only home to a number of regions with different economic foundations impacted by politics, but cultures and identities as well. J.M.S Careless (1969) examines the people’s identities in Canada and distinguishes how Canada is not a strong national region, but instead, a grouping of many regions separated due to numerous factors including race, language, class, historical events and even urbanization. He states that the “social patterning of Canada tends to favour regional commitment” (pg. 4) With regards to bringing these regions together under one nation, Wiseman (2007) states that “from a cultural modernization perspective, the evolution of Canada’s national transportation, financial, and communications networks would foster national consciousness and dampen regional identities” (page. 111) He goes on to comment that “to present Canadian political culture as an amalgam of its regional political cultures is to akin to trying to tie a number of water-melons together with a piece of string. Canada’s vast regions are not easily bound together” (page. 114). T...

Read more

Keywords

1 111 113 114 149 163 172 1837 1867 1932 1948 1950s 1969 1987 1988 2 2001 2003 2005 2007 2010 2011 2012 23 24 3 4 5 7 8 9 99 abl aborigin accommod accord account achiev acknowledg across act action administr adopt affair affect affirm afford agenda akin alien alleg allianc allow also alter altern alway amalgam america american among amount andrew anxious anyth appeal appear appli applic area around articl assist assur attempt back balanc base becom behind belief believ benefit best bet better big blue bodi bound boundless bring british build bureaucraci busi buttress calgari call came canada canadian cancel cannot capabl care careless ccf ccf-ndp cent centuri certain chang chantal chapter charact character chiefli chines choic chosen christian château circumst cite citi class climat cliqu co co-op coalit coexist collect column combin come comment commit common commonwealth communic communiti compact compar comprehens compris concept confeder conscious conserv conservat consid consist constitut continu cooper core corpor could council countri creat creation credibl credit crisi critic crosscut cultur current cut dampen day decis declar defend deficit definit delcar demand democraci democrat demonstr depress deriv desir detriment devast develop di didn differ difficult direct disappoint dispers distinct distinguish divers done doubt drew due earli earlier earn earth easili east east-west econom economi effect effort egalitarian elabor elect elector elimin embrac emphasi encompass encourag encyclopedia ensu ensur entiti enzo epitom equal erect erickson establish etc ethnic european even event everi evid evolut exacerb exact examin exclaim explain explicit express extern fact factor fail fair faith famili farm favour feder feel felt figur financi finish first fiscal fish fit fluctuat focus foot forc form formula foster found foundat four french fuell fundament futur game geographi get globe go goe good gospel govern great greater grievanc group growth h habit half hand harbor harbour hard harper head health heard hebert help hinder histor histori hold home honour hope hostil hous howev idea ident ideolog ignatieff imagin impact import improv includ incorpor indian individu inevit influenc inspir instanc instead institut integr intend intens interest interregion involv irish issu j.m.s jack job journal jurisdict keep known labour lack land languag larg larger largest late layton lead leader leadership least left less level liber life lifestyl like live long lose lost lower lynda made main major makarenko make malchom man manag mani march maritim matteo matter may meet melon member mend merg merger messag michael mid middl might minist model modern monetarist movement much multi multi-region multiregion nation ndp near necessari need network never new news nineteenth non non-territori nonetheless north nova number numer nycol often one ongo oper opportun opposit orang origin other ottawa page para part parti particular past pattern pcp peopl per perhap peripheri perspect pg piec place plan platform plausibl play polici polit poorer popul popular populist posit post power present preserv previous pride primaci prime principl prioriti problemat process profici progress promis promot prosper proud prove proven provid provinc provinci public pursu quarter quebec race rais rather reader realiti realli rebel recent reconcili red reduc reform regard regim region reinforc reliant religion remark remot repres represent republican request residenti respect respons rest result rethink revers revolut right role root rose run sad said sanderson savoi scale school scienc scotia section secur seek seem senat sent separ servic set sherbrook shift shown sight similar sinc sixti sixty-four small smaller social socialist societi sole solidar someth somewher sourc speak specif spend sprang stabil stabl stand state stephen still strategi strengthen string strive strong stronger struggl subsequ success successor suffer sum support symbol system taken talk target tariff task tax taxat tell temporari tend tension territori theme therefor though three tie time today togeth took toward town trace trade tradit transform translat transport tri truli turmel turn twelv u.s ultim unabl unafford understand unfair unif unit uniti unlik unnecessari unpack unreason upon upper urban us valu vanquish vast vehicl victim villag vision vital voic vote voter wall wallac want wasn wast water water-melon way wealth websit well west western whether whilst wholli whose win wing wiseman within without work world worldwid would ww1 year yet young