Essays /

Canadian Senate Essay

Essay preview


Assignment 3 The Canadian Senate By: Courtney Marie Lester.  What role does the Senate play in terms of Canadian democracy, and in light of that role, should the Senate be retained in its current form, reformed in some way, or abolished entirely?

The Canadian Senate has often been referred to as the sober second thought. The house of commons was originally set up to have two chambers, the upper and the lower, to carefully decide Canadian laws.  The Senate, in the upper house, reviews proposed legislation and ultimately decides whether a bill becomes a law. They are responsible for protecting the interests of Canadians, in all regions, and of all minorities.1 Recently however, there has been a big concern for more accountability. Many Canadians believe the senate no longer seems necessary, or acceptable, while others still see its need of approval. Which leaves Canada with some very diverse decisions; to amend it, abolish it, or leave it as is. This essay will explain why the Senate should be amended in order to show more accountability and transparency, as well as having an elected body instead of appointed, while ending on the important benefits the Senate still holds in Canada´s democracy. 

Let's start by looking at how the Senate functions. After the House of Commons passes a bill, it then goes to the Senate where they must vote on whether or not it becomes a law. Originally, it was intended to allow the elite, wealthy Canadian representatives to veto legislation. Today, the senate consists of 105 members, who have all been appointed by various Canadian prime ministers and their terms last until their 75th birthday. It´s quite clear then that when selecting people for the senate, the prime ministers usually appoints them from their own political parties. Senators are divided by various provinces biased on how long they have been a part of Canada, meaning Quebec and Ontario each get 24 senators, and the rest of the provinces have anywhere from 1 to 10. It becomes very controversial when the Senate doesn't approve a bill from the House, so they usually tend to send it back with a list of recommendations on how to improve it; consequently acting as a second pair of eyes, which is why it´s received the nickname “sober second thought.”2

Recently however, this sober second thought has been the centre of corruption and cover-up allegations and has provoked a heavy debate about the role of the Senate in our government and whether or not it should be amended or abolished. It outlines a lot of undemocratic examples of the...

Read more

Keywords

-377 /15 /abolish-the-senate /commentaries/whats-an-elected-senate-for /news/politics/conservative-senator-s-amendment-guts-union-disclosure-bill-1.1367879 /news/politics/harper-dismisses-senate-expenses-scandal-as-grounds-for-prorogation/article13872921/ /news/politics/proposed-senate-reforms-wouldn-t-have-stopped-expenses-scandal-1.2427137 /news/politics/red-chamber-should-open-the-books-on-travel-expenses-senator-says/article9333457/ /omar-alghabra/senate-reform_b_4268401.html /opinion/canada%e2%80%99s-appointed-senate-controversies-reveal-deeper-trend-authoritarian-rule?page=0,2 /polls/43954/seven-in-ten-canadians-want-to-directly-elect-their-senators/ 000 1 10 105 11.5 1991 2 2004 2008 2009 2011 2013 21st 24 26th 3 3rd 4 5 56 6 7 75th 8 9 90 abl abolish aborigin abortion.9and abus academ accept access accommod account accountsi achiev act action actual agre alghabra alleg allow along although amend analyz angus anni anyon anyth anywher appoint appropri approv argu argument around assign assur attempt attend auditor aug.20th authoritarian averag away back basic becom believ benefit better bias bibliographi big bill birthday board bodi book brazeau c call canada canadian care caught cbc centr centuri chamber chang chief choos chosen citizen claim clear common concern condit conduct consequ conserv consist constraint content continu controversi convinc corpor corrupt could count countri courtney cover cover-up cowan craig craigscott.ndp.ca craigscott.ndp.ca/abolish-the-senate credit crimin current cwf.ca cwf.ca/commentaries/whats-an-elected-senate-for day days/year deadlock dealt debat deceiv decemb decept decid decis declar deeper defin definit deflect deliber deliv democraci democrat destin detail difficult direct disabl disclos disclosur dismiss divers divid document documentari doesn dollar done donors.false doreen doubt draw duffi dysfunct earn educ elect elector elig elit emerg emphasi end engulf entir especi essay even everyth exampl except excess exempt expens explain expos extrem eye fact fals far fast financi fix form former forward foundat fraudul freedom friend function fund fund-rais gave general generous get gibbin give glen global globe go goe good govern grade group gut happi harm harper hasn haunt hay heart heavi held help hold homepag hope hour hous howev huffington hurri import improv includ indecis inform instead institut intend interest invalid involv issu j jackson jaideep jame jeopard journalist june jurisdict kim labor lack last law leader leav left legisl legitimaci legitimat length lesli lester let liber lie light link list long longer look lose lot lower mackinno mackinnon mackrael made mail main major make mani manipul mari matter matter.2 may mean member mere michael mike million minist minor minorities.1 misus modern modifi money movi much mukerji must ndp near necessari need nelson never nevertheless news nicknam nigel nov nov.16th number observ obvious often omar one one-sided onlin ontario open order origin other otherwise.4 outlin overal overstep paid paidmost pair pamela paper parliament parliamentari part parti pass patrick pay paycheck pearson pension peopl per perfect pick place plain plan play plus polit politician poor popul post power prime privacy.10 privileg problem produc proof proper propos prorog protect provid provinc provinci provok public purpos push qualifi quarter quebec quiet quit rais raiser reach read realli reason receipt receiv recent recommend record red refer reflect reform region reimburs reimburseth repeat repres represents.7 resid respons rest result retain reveal review revis right risk river roach robert roger role roll rule said salari say scandal scott second secret secretari see seem select senat senate.6 send serv set seven show side sided simpl simplest simpli sinc six small sober solv someth sort specif speech spent staff stand start statement status stephen still stop style suffer summari support suppos surround suspend suspens take taken tax taxpay technic technolog ten tend term thomson though thought three time today top top-heavi toronto toward track transpar transport travel trend tri trip.5 turn two ultim un unaccount unavoid undeliber undemocrat unelect uneth unilater union unmistak unrestrict upper usual vagu vancouv various veto violat visibl vote wallin want way wealthi well west whether whittington william without women work would wouldn wright write wrong www.angusreidglobal.com www.angusreidglobal.com/polls/43954/seven-in-ten-canadians-want-to-directly-elect-their-senators/ www.cbc.ca www.cbc.ca/news/politics/conservative-senator-s-amendment-guts-union-disclosure-bill-1.1367879 www.cbc.ca/news/politics/proposed-senate-reforms-wouldn-t-have-stopped-expenses-scandal-1.2427137 www.huffingtonpost.ca www.huffingtonpost.ca/omar-alghabra/senate-reform_b_4268401.html www.theglobeandmail.com www.theglobeandmail.com/news/politics/harper-dismisses-senate-expenses-scandal-as-grounds-for-prorogation/article13872921/ www.theglobeandmail.com/news/politics/red-chamber-should-open-the-books-on-travel-expenses-senator-says/article9333457/ www.vancouverobserver.com www.vancouverobserver.com/opinion/canada%e2%80%99s-appointed-senate-controversies-reveal-deeper-trend-authoritarian-rule?page=0,2 year yet