Essays /

Canadian Vs American Identity Essay

Essay preview

The importance of defining an identity is of sociological concern because sense of "self', or identity, is reached only by means of people socially interacting (Hiller 1976). Determining whether or not there is a unique Canadian identity has been a struggle since the conception of the nation back in 1867, and with good reason. "[A]n identity is very difficult to define and it is virtually impossible to determine the fine line between lack of an identity and the existence of an identity" (Hiller p.155). In order to conclude that there is a unique Canadian identity, it is necessary to see past the irony in which such a conclusion is reached. The irony is that, there are fewer things unique within Canada, which all Canadians share in common, compared to unique characteristics that can be seen across the board. This fact is one that Canadians closely identify themselves with, and thus becomes part of the unique Canadian identity. The primary causes of this lack of uniqueness within Canada among Canadians are various types of barriers. Government has made significant efforts throughout Canadian history to unify Canada and overcome many of these barriers. As well, it has recently been found that there is a market for things "Canadian" which corporate Canada has taken advantage of in national advertising campaigns through the means of mass media. We will see how this too has contributed to overcoming these barriers as well as created a sense of uniqueness to Canadians. We will also take a look at what the American identity is: How it is/was shaped, and what comparisons can be made between it, and the Canadian identity. When it is all said and done, the Canadian identity is a delicate, yet strong and something to be very proud of.

General Canadian Identity When mentioning Canadian identity, some of the first things that come to mind are the external and internal stereotypes that have been created about Canadians. There are of course the typical stereotypes that arrive from the United States such as the idea that Canadians all live in igloos while dodging stray hockey pucks. Or that it is cold everywhere in Canada, all year around. All of which are untrue.

Furthermore, there is a distinct view on what a Canadian language is. Verbal language of (English) Canadians is more like American spoken language than it is to spoken English in England. However, Americans in particular will notice a slight British accent in Canadian language. For example the way a Canadian says "Out and About", to an American will sound "Oot and Aboot". Also not forgetting to mention the Canadian "word' "eh" and how it is a uniquely Canadian word. However, the context in which Canadians use the word "eh" is not unique by any means. It is used in much the same context as the American "huh"; only "eh" has more uses (So You Want to Speak Canadian, Eh?). In addition, such words as "toque", or "ski-doo" are only common phrase within Canada. These two words not only contribute to Canadian identity in their being uniquely Canadian, but that the objects themselves can even be used, unofficially, as Canadian symbols.

What greater unofficial Canadian symbols are there than anything that has to do with hockey, and justifiably so. Canada has been the most successful nation when it comes to hockey. It is identifiable throughout Canada. Nearly every Canadian town has an arena in which residents could find blindfolded. On September 28, 1972, one of the most familiar phrases in Canadian history was broadcast across the airways; starting with "Here's another shot. Right in front. They score!" which Canadians will likely finish with "Henderson has scored for Canada" (Earle 1995). This of course being in regards to Canada's victory over the USSR in an international hockey series. Another hockey symbol is the mere name of "Wayne Gretzky". Gretzky is more recognized outside Canada than the Canadian Prime Minister. There could someday be a movement to have the theme from "Hockey Night In Canada" changed to the National anthem, where Canadians just stand in silence listening to the recognizable theme song. It would put up a good fight for sure.

Barriers as Hindrances Barriers play a major role in constructing (or destruction of) a Canadian identity. Canada's diverse geography has created physical regions that separate Canadians. The Rocky Mountains separate the West Coast from the prairies. The Canadian Shield separates the prairies from that which is east. Finally, the Appalachian Mountain Range separating much of the Maritimes from Lower Quebec and Southern Ontario. These regions are in turn constructed further socially. People create their identity within and from their surroundings and these physical barriers deter interaction outside their own region.

Along with these physical barriers, there are cultural barriers. The most evident of these is between the French and English cultures within Canada. Events in Canadian history insured the survival of French culture mainly the French language and Catholicism, as opposed to English language and following the Anglican Church. This cultural difference, though always tense, has not been as prevalent as it has in the past 30 years or so. Starting with the violent measures taken by the FLQ in the 70's, the Meech Lake Accord in the 80's and the referendum regarding Quebec Sovereignty in the 90's, the clash between French and English Canada has nearly boiled over and split the country. To this very day, French is the official language of Quebec, opposed to English in the rest of the country (except New Brunswick where both are considered official). The Quebec Government has strict policies within Quebec to protect the French language by making it illegal for businesses to use English names, or post English signs.

Not only are there cultural barriers between French and English in Canada, but between a variety of ethnic backgrounds co-existing throughout Canada and within the separate regions. Poet Robin Skelton writes as pointed out by J.A Wainwright (1998) illustrates this co-existence of different ethnicity: sometimes I sit in a beer parlour with the Hungarians, the Czechs,...

Read more


-1996 000 1 10 150 1867 1899 1915 1920 1933 1939 1950 1960 1972 1976 1978 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 19th 2 20 200 2000 20th 24 25 27 28 29 30 31 37 41 43 49 5 52 54 54th 68 70 74 79 8 80 81 90 abl aboot aborigin abroad absorb abund accent accept accommod accomplish accord account accultur achiev across act actual ad adam addit adult advanc advantag advertis advis advisor affair affect affili afford africa african african-american age agenc agricultur ahead aim air airport airway allow almost along also although alway america american american- among amount ancien anglican anoth answer anthem anthoni anti anti-american anyth appalachian approach architectur aren arena aris arlington around arriv art articl artist asid ask aspect assimil associ assum attempt attitud audienc austrian author auto b back backdrop background bacon balanc bald baromet barrier base basi battlefield beat beauti becam becom bed beer behalf belief believ benefici benefit best better beyond bibliographi bill birth black blank blindfold blue board boil border bottl boundari bourgeoi bow branch brand break brew briefli british broadcast broken brunswick bryan build busi button came campaign canada canadian capit capitalist capitol card care carri case cast categori catherin catholic caus cbc celin cemeteri centuri ceremoni certain chang charact characterist chicago children chines chrietien christian church citi citizen civil claim clash class classic classifi clean climat close closest co co-exist coast coca coca-cola coke cola cold coloni colour columbia combin come comfort command commerci commiss common communic communist compani compar comparison compass compil compon concentr concept concern conclud conclus concurr conduct conflict conformist conglomer congress connect connot conquer consequ consid consist constitut construct consult contact contain content contest context continu contract contrast contribut conveni convey convict convinc corpor could counsel counterpart countri cours creat creation creativ criteria crtc cultur czech d dane daprato david day debat debit dec decis dedic deem defin degre delic demand democrat demograph depart depend describ design destruct deter determin develop dictat didn differ difficult dilemma dionn diplomat direct director discern discoveri discuss dislik disneyland dispar dispers display distinct divers dodg doesn domest domin done doo downfal drive driven [email protected] due duti dynast eagl earl easi east econom economi educ effect effort egalitarian eh elsewher email emot empir encourag end engin england english enhanc enterpris equal era erasur escap essenti ethnic europ european european-styl even event eventu ever everi everywher evid evolut exampl except exchang exclaim exclud exclus execut exemplifi exhibit exist expand experi explain explicit explod extend extent extern extrem fact factor fail fair fall famili familiar far fast father feat feder feel fewer fight figur fill film final financi find fine finish firm first fish five flag flourish flq focal folk follow fond forc foreign forestri forget form found foundat frame free free-enterpris french french/english friend front frontier furthermor futur game gateway gather gene general generat geograph geographi german get gettysburg gift give given global globe glorifi go goal god gone good govern government governor grab graceland grade greater greec green gretzki gross group grow haas/shaffir hamper hand hard health health-car held help henc henderson heritag heterosexu hiller hindranc histor histori hockey hold home homeli hope hour hous howev huh human humankind hungarian husband idea ideal ident identif identifi identificatori ideolog igloo ill illeg illustr imag imageri imagin immens immigr implicit import impos imposs includ inclus incom incorpor increas incred indian individu industri infinit influenc influenti ingredi inhabit initi innov innumer inscript insignia instil institut insur interac interact interest intern internet interpret investig involv irish iron ironi is/was isn issu j.a jack jacqu januari jefferson jeopardi jfk job john joni judgment juli june justifi kaplan keep klan klux km knew know ku lack lake land languag larg last late later lawson lead leader leaf learn least legal less lesser let level liber liberti lieuten lieutenant-governor life lifestyl light like limit lincoln line lineag linguist link list listen littl livabl live ll lobbi logo look lose loud lower loyalist ltd macdonald maclaren maclean made magazin mail main major make makeup male man manag mani map mapl maritim mark market marvel mass may mayb mccann mean meaning measur meat media medium meech memori mention mere messag middl midwest milit millennium million million/year mind minist ministri mirror mitchel molson monarch monarchi monger monkey monument moos moral mother mount mountain mouth movement movi much multicultur multiraci must mysogenist myth n name nation nationalist natur near necess necessari need negat neighbour neither ness net network never never-end new newer news newsweek next nice night non non-canadian non-conformist none norm north note noteworthi notic number object obstruct obviat obvious ocean offici often oil old older on-air one ontario onto oot open oper opera opportun oppos order other ottawa outsid overcom ownership p.14 p.155 p.157 p.162 p.17 p.19 p.20 p.21 p.23 p.25 p.38 p.44 p.45 p.67 parent parlour part particular partnership past patriarch patriot payment peek peer penetr peopl percent perhap period perman perpetu person personhood pertain phallic phenomenon phrase physic place play player poet point pole polici polit pontif popul popular portray pose possess post power practic prairi precis prefer presenc present prevail preval prevent pride primari primarili prime principl probabl problem process produc product program progress promot properti proportion prostitut protect protector proud provid provinc provinci proxim public puck puppet purpos push put qualiti quebec queen quest question quot race racial radio radio-televis rais ran ranch random rang rapid ravag re reach reaction real realiti reason receiv recent recip recogn recognition/non-recognition recogniz redistribut referendum reflect regard regim regiment region regul regular reign relat relationship relay remark rememb renwick report repres represent repress republican requir research resid resourc respect respons rest retain revenu revisit revolut rhetor right robin rocki role rome room roosevelt ross ross1998 run rushmor russian safeti said sale savag save saw say schedul school score scot search second secretari see seen select self self-imag sell sens sent separ separatist septemb seri serv servic sever sexist sexual shadow shania shape share shield shop short shot show shown side sign signific silenc similar sinc sing singular sir sit skelton ski ski-doo skin skyscrap slaveri slight slow slower small smile smith soap social societi sociolog sole someday someon someth sometim somewhat song sound south southern sovereignti space spawn speak speech spent spill split spoken stand star start state station statu stay steadi step stereotyp still store stori strateg stray streak strenuous strict stripe strong structur struggl student student-exchang studi style success suggest sung superpow supper support suppress supremaci sure surpris surround survey surviv susan suscept symbol system take taken talk task taught taxi teach teacher technolog teddi telecommun televis ten tens term thank theme thexton thing think third third-gener thirti thorough though thought thrive throughout throw thus tie time timeless today togeth took topograph toqu toronto toronto-bas totem toward town trace trait transcend transfer translat tri trip trust trustworthi truth turn tv twain twelv twenti twist two type typic u.s ukrainian un un-fre unifi union uniqu unit univers unoffici untru up-beat upon urgenc us use uss ussr util valu vari varianc varieti various vast verbal vernacular via victori view viewer villeneuv violent virtual vis vis-ã visit vs wainwright want washington wave way wayn well went west western wherea whether white whole widdi wilson wilson-smith wind within without wolf woman women word work world would wouldn write wrong year yet york young younger ã