Essays /

Canadian Women Essay Essay

Essay preview


BETWEEN THE UNES: THE REPRESENTATION OF CANADIAN WOMEN IN ENGUSH-LANGUAGE NOVELS WRIITEN BV WOMEN IN THE 1930S

Ann Gossage Department of History McGiII University, Montreal March,1996

A Thesis submitted to the Facult) of Graduate Studies and Research ln partial fulfilment of the requiremern of the degree of Master of Arts

(c) copyright Ann Gossage, 1996

.+.

National L,brary of Ganada ACqUISlt;onS and Blbllographlc seMCes Branch 395 Wellington Street Ottawa. Ontario
K1AQtI,I4

Bibliothèque naltonale duGanada Direction des acqUisitions et des services bibliographiques Ottawa IOnlano)
K1A0N4

395. rue Wellington

The author has granted an irrevocable non-exclusive licence allowing the National Library of Canada to reproduce, loan, distribute or sell copies of hisjher thesis by any means and in any form or format, making this thesis available to interested persons.

L'auteur a accordé une licence irrévocable et non exclusive permettant à la Bibliothèque nationale du Canada de reproduire, prêter, distribuer ou vendre des copies de sa thèse de quelque manière et sous quelque forme que ce soit pour mettre des exemplaires de cette thèse à la disposition des personnes intéressées.

The author retains ownership of the copyright in hisjher thesis. Neither the thesis nor substantial extracts from it may be printed or otherwise reproduced without hisjher permission.

L'auteur conserve la propriété du droit d'auteur qui protège sa thèse. Ni la thèse ni des extraits substantiels de celle-ci ne doivent être imprimés ou autrement reproduits sans son autorisation.

ISBN 0-612-19896-0

Canada

Shortened Title: Between the lines: Women in Canadian novels of the 1930s

ABSTRACT This thesis examines the role of Canadian women as presented in English language novels of the 1930s written by women authors. Within the context of the Great Depression it focuses on issues that are central to women's daily lives such as work, love, marriage and motherhood. lt also isolates recurring themes in the nove!s and attempts to understand the authors' messages within their social context. Social reform. politics and ge!1der relationships are among the subjects explored.

RESUME Cette thèse examine le rôle des femmes canadiennes telles que représentées par les auteurs féminins des romans de langue anglaise des années 1930. Elle se concentre, dans le contexte de la grande dépression, sur les préoccupations qui sont qu centre la vie quotidienne des femmes: le travail, l'amour, le mariage et la maternité. On a isolé les thèmes qui reviennent fréquerrlll,oot dans les romans et essayé de comprendre les messages des auteurs en tenant compte du contexte social. La réforme sociale, la politique et les relations homme-femmes font partie des sujets explorés.

::

ACKNOWlEDGEMENTS 1would like to thank the following people: Professor Andrée Lévesque for her guidance and forbearance; the inter-library loans staff whose services 1used to the point of abuse; Peter Gossage for his editorial suggestions on structure and style. and for "Between the Unes"; Mary Bleho for the abstraet translation: Joan Kearvell for her help with printing; Audrey Gossage. Mary Bleho and Helene Bleho for babysitting Michael 50 that 1 could work on this thesis: and Mike Bleho for his constant encouragement and support.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION APPROACH and METHODS CHAPTER 1: CANADIAN PUSLISHING IN THE 19305 REALISM RECEPnON CHAPTER Il: EMPLOYMENT AND THE DOMESnC IDEAL THE DEPRESSION SETIlNG WOMEN AND WORK

1 4 15 15 19 24 24 33

47 CHAPTER III: LOVE AND MARRIAGE LONG ENGAGEMENTS 47 'ADVANTAGES' OF MARRIAGE 49 "ILLEGITIMACY" . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 52 SEXUALITY ST SELF-SACRIFICE 65 CHAPTER IV: MOTHERING SIRTH CONTROL CHILDSIRTH CHILDREARING WOMEN'S CULTURE? 73 73 77 83 88

CHAPTER V: WOMEN. SOCIETY AND POLITICS ...........•........ 94 SOCIAL REFORM 94 SEING ''WELL-BORN'' 97 WEALTH AND CLASS 99 EUGENIC AND ENVIRONMENTAL REFORM 102 ETHNIC INTOLERANCE. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • . . . . . . . . .. 107 COUNTRY VERSUS CITY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 111 DEPRESSION POLITICS ......................•........ 118 RADICAL ALTERNATIVES 119 GENDER POLITICS 124 CON CLUSI ON ..............................•...•........ 135 APPENDIX: STORY SUMMARIES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • . . . • • • .. 137 BIBLIOGRAPHY .................................••.••••.• 146

INTRODUCTION Authors and historians tend to charaeterize the decade of the Great Depression as a decade manquée. The idea that the 1930s seem to mark a hait to the progress of the 1920s is expressed, as historian Michiel Hom has pointed out, in Depression titles such as ''ten lost years" and ''the winter years", Hom sees the "Bennett Buggy" as the best symbol of the rollinq back of certain advances in Canadian society; unable to afford fuel, people hitched their horses to their automobiles and named the hybrid after Prime Minister Bennett.' For Canadian women this rollback was significant. Althouqh by the 1930s they had won the right to vote in federal elections, to serve in both houses of the Canadian parliament, and had entered the paid workforce in increasing numbers since World War l, their freedom to operate in the "public sphere" did not go unchallenged. With the economic downtum of the 1930s, the sense that the best place for women was in the home was reaffirmed. One author and social commentator, Gwethalyn Graham, in an article entitled. "Women, Are They Human?", argues that the 1930s witnessed a backlash against wornen's individual rights. She links this backlash to the economic pressures of the Depression, and to psychoanalytic theories which understand a woman's bioloqy, her mothering function, as her single motivator in life! According to Graham, "Women are conditioned to regard marriage as an end which is exclusive of everything else since their earliest childhood.'" furthers this point. King, writing for New Frontier in 1937,

1

Michiel Hom, The Great Depression of Ihe '930s in Canada. Canadian HistoricaJ Association Booklet No. 39 (Ottawa ,984). 3.

2 A woman's mind. according 10 Frederick Tracy. an ethics Professor ciled by k3eth Ughl and Ruth

Roach Pierson. •...is reproductive rather than productive: Beth Ught and Ruth Roach Pierson. No Easy Road Women in Canada 1:)20$ 10 ,960$ (Toronto: New Hoglown Press. ,990), 57, William D. Tait, writing for the Dalhousie Review in ,930. also argued that a woman's role W8S essentially !hat of wife and mother. He wriles. 'The mothers of great men have done more for the world than ail the so-called female uplifters that ever lived: William D. Tait. ·Some Feminisms·. Dalhousie Review , 0 (1930): 54-55. 3

Gwethalyn Graham, "Women. Are They Human?· The Canadian Forum 16 (Oecember 1936): 22.


quo.

2
Women are mugs: Because they are brought up to believe they must marry and keep house for a living. They are taught to expect less of themselves than men, and to fear and distrust ''working'' for a living as a permanent prospect. The economic system makes this inevitable of course. But what a ridiculous situation! It means that myriads of intelligent women, with extremely varied capabilities and interests, find that if they wish to live a full emotional Iife, to which mating and parenthood are necessary they are automatically doomed to one kind of occupation. whether they Iike it or not. 4 The authors of Canadian Women make the paradox of women's position in Canadian society explicit, suggesting that despite broadened social opportunities for women after World War 1. there was an attempt to recapture the pre-war status For women, this meant a reaffirmation of traditional roles as wives and mothers at a time when increased educational and job opportunities appeared to offer more choice than ever before....the "new woman" was incorporated into a value system that reasserted and redefined the female traits of femininity, domesticity. and dependence. 5 Gender politics in the 1930s were informed by the Victorian ideelogy which placed women in the horr.e and men in the work place". Yet, as Ruth Roach Pierson has noted, the separate spheres doctrine was based on gender

• Marjorie King, "Women are Mugs",

Nl!W

Frontier 1. no. 10 (February 1937): 23.

• Alison Prentice et al., Canadian Women: A History (Toronto: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich. 1988), 240. • The corollary to the theory that women are wives and mothers while men are crusaders and breadwinners, is that there is something unnatural about men or women who wish to step outside of these ready made roles. This restrictive standard affected even successful women who seemed to live outside of il Agnes MacPhail. the first Canadian woman MP. for exarnple, had to forego a family. She aise had to endure the pejorative depiction of hersel! in Ottawa as "an austere, sharp" tongued 185) who was somehow incomplete despite her accomplishments. It is said that Mac:'hail "..felt strongly the right of a woman to be a person [emphasis in the original], ta do things in the world at large instead of merely serving as helpmate to a man." Mary Quayte Innis, ed.. The Clear Spirit Twenty Canadian Women and Their Times (Toronto: University of Toronto Press. 1966). 195.

3
stereotypes, such as males are aggressive and females are passive. 7 Feminist authors have questioned whether these spheres accurately represented male and female relationships or work patterns. Many conclude that they did not. While men were perceived as breadwinners, for example, women, particularty rural women, engaged in ail sorts of activities that contributed to the household coffers in largely unrecorded ways. Their ingenuity and home production was often

essential to survival during the hard financial times of the thirties.· Wornen's contributions to the family economy often went publicly unrecognized, however. "...for decades neither the farm wife nor the fisherman's wife was countoo as a participant in Ganada's labor force."· Historian and literary critic Mary Poovey, in her survey of middle-class women in Victorian England, also makes a case for the f1uidity of the spheres. She denies the biological foundat;on for Victorian ideology, and suggests instead that these notions were socially created and never completElly accepted. She says, "...the middle class ideology we most often associate with the Vic...

Read more

Keywords

-0 -12 -1929 -1945 -19896 -55 -612 -69 .. 0 00 01 011 02 044 04s 084 1 10 102 104 107 109 11 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 13 130 133 135 137 14 146 15 155 156 16 165 170 1820 185 1885 19 1919 192 1920 1920s 1925 1930 19305 1930s 1931 1932 1933 1934 1935 1936 1937 1939 1940 1949 195 196 19605 1966 198 1985 1988 1989 1990 1992 1996 19th 1am 1der 1didn 1e3 1get 1have 1lost 1married 1n 1taken 1used 1would 2 20 21 215 22 229 23 24 240 252 253 254 27 279 28 3 300 318 33 336 339 34 345 347 348 365 38 39 395 4 40 41 468 47 49 5 50 52 53 54 55 57 58 6 65 67 68 7 70 711 73 74 75 77 7ll 8 82 83 85 87 88 8li 90 930 930s 94 95 960 97 98 984 99 990 a1coholism a1phabetically aberhart absenc absent absolut abstract abstraet abus academ accept accomplish accord accordion accordé account accur accus achiev acknowledg acquisit acquislt acr across act activ actual ad adam address adopt advanc advantag adventur advic advoc advocaci ae affect affluent afford age ages-som aggress agn agrarian agricultur ail ain air ais al alberta ali alison allan allisten allow almost alon along alreadi also altem alter altern although althouqh altribut alway alyan amber ambient ambigu america american ami among amour anachron analysi analyz anc ancestor andré anger anglais angri anim ann anné anonym anoth answer anxieti anyadvantag anyadvantages-and anyon anyth apart apolog appal appar appeal appear appendix appreci approach approprial area argu around arous arrest art articl artilleri ascertain ascrib asha asham asia ask asm assess assimil associ assum assur atmospher attach attempt attend attent attitud attract atwood aud audienc audrey aunt auster auteur authent author authori auto automat automobil autoris autrement avail awa away ba.ird babysit bacchi back backlash bad baird baker band bank base basic basqu bath battl be beasley becom bedroom befriend began begin begun behav behaviour behind belief believ belong belor beneath benedict bennett best beth betroth bibliographi bibliographiqu bibliothèqu big biograph biolog bioloqi birth blackfoot blake blame blatant blbllographlc bleho bliird bliss blood blow blue boag book booklet born bottom boy brace branch brari breadwinn break breed brief british broaden brothel brought brunswick buck bug buggi build built bumst bunch bush busi bust butthafsperson buy bv bygon c c1eaning c1inging cake cali call calm came camp campaign camper canada canadian canadiana canadien canadienn cancel cani cannot capabl capit capitajist care career careless carol carri cartel case castig catalogu caus ce celebr cell celle-ci centr central centuri certain cett cf chaileng challeng chanc chang chapman chapter charact charaet charaeter charaeterswhetherthey charbonneau charg chase chastiti cheek chicago child childhood childrear children childsirth chinamen chines chink choic choke choos chose chosen christian church ci cile cio cite citi civil claim clara clark clash class claw clean clean-cut cleanli cleans clear cli cloth clusi co co-educ co-op coach coars coast code coerciv coffer cogent coid cold collect colour columbia combin come comes-and commenl comment commentari commerc commonwealth communism communist communiti compar comparison competit compil complet completelli composf comprendr compt con concem concentr conclud concur condemn condit confeder confer confid confirm conglomer conjug conserv conservat consolid constant constim construct consult contain contemporari content contenti contest context continu contirm contribut control convent convers convey coon cooper copi copp copyright corollari correct corrobor couch could count countoo countri countrysid cour courag cours cousin cove cover creat creativ credibl credit crestland cresuand crimin crisi criteria critic critiqu crop crosscul crosscut crusad culey cull culmin cult cultur curlain cut d d.n dago daili dalhousi damn dan danc danger darrow date daughter day de deal death deathb decad decay decent decid deep deepli defeat defenc defend defens degener degre deliber delin demand demograph deni depart departrn depend depict depiet depress depression-era depression.era deprllsslon deprllsslon-era depth des descend describ desir despit develop deviat dick didn die differ difficult difficulti difficultto digniti direct dirt disagre disarm discours discuss dish disposit distinct distract distribu distribut distrust divorc doctor doctrin document doivent dollar domesnc domest domin done doom door doukabour downtum dr drawn dream dress drink drive droit drub drunk du due duganada duley dump dumping-ground duplessi dynam dépression eam ean.dierl earli earliest earth eas easi easili east echo econom economi ed edit editori educ either el eleanor elect element ell ella els embarrass emot emphas emphasi emphasiswera employ emporia en encourag encroach end endur energet engag engi8nd engin england english engush engush-languag enough enrag enter entertain entir entitl entrap environment envis eo epithet equal era eraschuck eros erskin especi essay essayé essenti establish et ethel ethic ethni ethnic eugen europ evan even event ever everi every-man-for-himself everyon everyth everywher evid evolv examin exampl exarnpl except exclud exclus excus exemplair exemplifi exist expect experi experienc explain explicit explor exploré express extract extrait extrem exud eye f f10rid f1ame f1aw f1uidity face fact facult fail fair fairer fall famili fanner far farm farmer fashion father fau fault faultless faultless-almost favour fear februari fed feder feel feelin felix felt femal femin feminin feminist femm fiction fill fin final financi find fine finlay first fisherman fit fix flame fo focus foley follow font foolish forbear forc forego foreign forestal form format forum fought found foundat four frame francophon frederick free freedom french friend friendship frontier frown fréquerrlll fu fuel fulfil full fulli fun function fundament further furthermor futur féminin g7 gabriel gad gail ganada garbag garden gate ge gear gender generaili general generos generous gerson get gigolo girl give given glimps gnome go god godefroy godfrey goe gone good gossag got govem gr grab graduat grafl graft graham gralt grammar grand grant great greater greek gretl grim groom ground group grow growl gs guess guidanc gutter gutter-epithet guy gwethalyn h hail hait half hall halter hand handicap handsom hannah happen happi harass harcourt hard harder harm harri harvest hasn hat hate hatti haven head healthcar healthier heard heart heavi helen help helpmat hepbum heritag hersai hersel heterogen high highlight hisjher histor histori historian historicaj historv hitch hodgepodg hoglown hom home home-iov home-wer homestead homm homme-femm honest honor honora honour hope horr.e hors hospit hostil hot hotel hous household housekeep housework howev human husband hybrid i4 ianc ibid iblcl idea ideal ideelog ident identifi ideolog idiom if ife ihe iiber iif iifestyl iight iii iik iink iip iiteratur iittl iiv il ilfeg illegitimaci imag imagin imbu immacul immigr immor impact implic implicit import imposs impress imprimé imprison inappropri incam inclin includ inclus incomplet inconspicu incorpor increas inde independ indict indigen individu inevit influenc influenti inform ingenu inhabit inher initi inni innoc insight insignific insignificance-their inslitut instanc instead institut insult insurance.85 integr intellig intend intent inter inter-librari interact interest interpret intervent intoler intrigu introduc introduct intéressé involv ionlano iook iov iren ironi irrevoc irrévoc isbn island isn isol isolé issu iv j j.l j.s jack jall jalna jane jargon jealousi jeen jessi jld joan job john joliett jovanovich jtto judg june justic jws k1a0n4 k1aqti k3eth kapica kathleen kearvel keep kerri key kike kind king kitchen kitchen-and knew know known l la labor labour lack lad ladi laith lambert lamp lan land landroit langu languag lar larg larm last late later laugh laundri law lay le leader leadership leam lean least leav lebreaux led left legislatur leigh lelt lent les less lesson let li liber liberai librari licenc lie life lifestyl light like lilon lime line link lip lisl list liter literai literari literatur littl livabl live ljfe ln loan lobbi local locat log logger lone long long-stand longer longest look lor lord lose lost lot lousi love low lower lscape lt ltalian lucien luck lucki luncheon lundamentaj lure lurther ly lévesqu m mac macaulay macmurchi macphail made magazin main mainstream major make make-up maker male man manag mani manifesto manièr manqué march marcil margaret mari mariag mariana marjori mark mark-their marri marriag masler master match mate materi maternité matilda matt matter mauric maxin may mazo mcgiii mclaren mculnln meadow mean meaning meant meet member men mention mere merit messag met metaphor method methodist methoo mettr michael michiel mid middl middle-ag middle-class might mike mind mine minist minor minut misfortun misrepres miss mistaken mitchel mix mobil model modem money monograph monopolist montcalm montreal moral moran moreov mosquito mother motherhood motif motiv motor mount mountain move movement movi mp mr mrs much mug muscular music musician must mv myriad mysleri mysteri mysterv n nake naltonal name narrow nation national natur ne near necessari need neglect neighbor neighbour neither nephew nerv nervous network never nevertheless new newfoundland next ni nice night nl no-if non non-exclus none normal normat norseman north northem nose notabl note noth nothin notic notion nova nove novel novelist nri number numer o o4 object oblig obscur observ obtain obvious oc occup occupi occur oe oecemb offer often oftenc oh old older on on-to-ottawa-trek one onethat onset ontario oo oo.ain oo53 oot open oper opportun oppos opposit optim order organ origin orphan os oshawa other others-their otherwis ottawa ou outfit outlay outsid outward overcom overlook owner ownership p pacif page paid paint pamphlcl panic par paradox parenthood parliament parson part parti partial particip particular particularti partner pass passag passiv past pastor pastorll patriot pattern pauciti peac pearl pejor pentworth peopl perceiv percept peril period perman permett permiss perrnan person personn perteet peter phil philip physic physicallov piac pick pictur pierr pierson pieti pioneer pitkin pitrnan place plain plan plant play pleas pleasur plot poetri point pois polem polili polit politic politicaj politicized-in politiqu poovey populist portion portray pose posit possibl potvin pour poutic poverti power practic prairi pre pre-war precis prefer pregnant prejud prejudic premier premis prenlic prentic prepar prescrib prescript presenc present press pressur pretent pretti prevent previous price pride prime print prioriti prison privileg problem product profession professor profit progress project promis promiscu promot proper properti propriété prose prosecut prospect prosper protèg proud prove provid provinc préoccup prêter psychoanalyt publ public publish puli punish puriti purport purpos puslish put q qu qualiti quarter quayt que quebec quelqu question qui quit qult quo quotat quotidienn r rabid race racism racist radic radio raft rag rainbow rais rame rampant rare rast rate rather re re-introduc re-work reaction read readi reaffirm realism realiti realiz realladi reason reassert recal recaptur receiv recent recepnon recept recogn recur red redefin reed reevalu refer refin reflect reform reformist refrain refus regard regener regina regist regret relat relationship relev reli reliant relief religi remain rememb remind remodel renni reorder replac repli repres represent reproduc reproduct reproduir reproduit représenté repudi request requir requiremern requirey research resent resist resolv respect respond respons responsibility-but rest restauranteur restless restrict resum retain retract retum revienn review reviewof reviv revlew revolutionari reward ridicul rift rift-raft right riordan rise rival rivièr rnake rnake-up rnateri roach road robe robert roch rocki roger role roles-such rolland rollback rollinq rom roman romanc roof room root rose rough round rout rue rug run rural rusti ruth réform rôle sa sacrific sage sai said salari sale salt san sanderson sarah saskatchewan saturday saw say sc scale scandal scath scenario scheier scheme school scorn scotia scrub scum se sea seanor search second section secur seduc see seem seen self self-centr self-confid self-reli self-sacrific self-suffici sell selt semc sens sent separ serious sern serv servanr servic set setilng settler sex sexual shack share sharp sheard shed shelll shift shivare shock shoedeck short shorten show sic sick sieg sight sign signifi signific similar simpl simpler simpli sin sinc singl sirth sister situat sium skin skunk slightest sllape slosh slur sm small smith smither so-cal soae soag soap social socialist societi soit sold somehow someth sometim somewhat son sonner sont sooti sophist sore sorn sort sought soul sourc sous space speak special specul speech speeific spend sphere spirit spoke spokesman sport spragu spread spring st staff stand standard starkey start starvat state statement statern status steal step stereotyp steve still stood stop stori straight strang street strength stress strict strike striker strong strong-boag strong-soag stronger structur studi stuff style stylist suav subject submit subrniss substanc substanti substantiel succeed success suffici suggesl suggest suggsst suit suitor sujet sullivan sulphur summar summari summer sun superfici superior suppli support suppos suppress sur surfac surg surplus surpris survey surviv sustain swamp swing symbol sympathet sympathi system ta tabl tactic tait take taken tale talent talk taught tawni tawny-head te teach ted teeth tell temper ten tenant tend tendenc term terribl testament text tha thal thank them-th theme then-if theori therefor thesi thet thetr thing think thirti thoma though thought throughout thèmes thèse tim time tirst tish titl tled togeth told toler tongu toni took topi toronto tough toward town traci trade tradit trait translat trauma travail treatment trek tri troi trois-rivièr trom troubl true truer truli truth tuberculosi tume twenti twentieth twig type typifi ubbi ughl ught ukrainian unabl unbom unchalleng uncl under under-written undercut undermin understand underw underwood undoubt une unemploy uneven unfair unfortun union uniqu univers unknown unmarri unnatur unrecogn unrecord unrest unsettl unsmear unspecifi up-th uplift upon urban us use user uteratur utopian v vacant vacuous valu valverd vari vast vat vehicl vendr veneer vener ventur veronica versus viabil victirn victorian vie view vigor vike villag vima vine violent virgin virtu virtuous vision visionari visit visitor vocabulari voic vote vou vow w w8s wachtel wait wake want wanton wantor war warmth wash wasn wast wasta waster water way weaker wealth weapon weil welfar well well-born wellington wender went werd west western wet whatev wheel whenev wherea whether whirlwind white whiteoak whole whose whue why-iook wife wilh will willet william williamson willing willison win wind window winter wish wit within without wive wnich wo wolf woman womanhood womel women won wonder woodsworth word worfd work worker workforc world world-a wornen worri worship would wouldn wriiten wrile write writer writina written wrong wrote y year yellow yet york you-what young youth à être