Essays /

Locke Hobbes And Good Life Proper Role And Extent Government Essay

Essay preview

The political philosophies of Thomas Hobbes and John Locke revolve around the proper role and extent of government. Their two philosophies have extensive similarities but in the end are wholly different when it comes to the quality of life they provide for their subjects. The differences lie in whether they provide mere life or the good life for their subjects. Aristotle laid out the basic ideas of mere life versus the good life when he stated: "When several villages are united in a single complete community, large enough to be nearly or quite self-sufficing, the state comes into existence, originating in the bare needs of life, and continuing in existence for the sake of a good life (Politics, 1252b28)." Using Aristotle's basic idea of the progression of society, it can be seen that the initial need and intent of civil society is to provide mere life while its ultimate goal should be the good life. While both Hobbes and Locke provide the mere life for their subjects, only Locke allows for the attainment of the good life.

A government that offers the mere life to its subjects only offers the protection from outside invasion and from other subjects. This is the initial intent of any civil society, simple protection. After the society is established the natural tendency is to provide for the good life, a life where pleasure and happiness are attainable. The good life can only be guaranteed when there are restrictions and limitations on the ability of government to encroach upon the lives of its subjects. Following this idea, one might claim that civil liberties are necessary to maintain certain minimal guarantees against severe iniquity, or that there ought to be more to civil liberty than mere silence of the law, and so properly allow for the good life. Absolute power is not compatible with this end, however, by its very nature. Absolute power has no checks against it, therefore it may act however it desires and still be acting justly towards the subjects. These ideas will be the basis for a greater analysis of the societies cr...

Read more


-351 120 122 1252b28 326 327 350 89 abil abl absent absolut accord account act action activ actual advoc affirm afford al alien allow alreadi amass american amongst analysi anoth anyth appeal arbitrari arbitrarili aristotl arm around attain aw babi bare basi basic believ benefit best better beyond bodi born bound bred brutish cannot caus central certain chang chapter check chief child choos cite civil claim clear come common common-wealth commonwealth communiti compat complet concept confer consent constant content continu continual contrari contrast corrupt could count coven creat creation crucial current danger death decad decid decis defend deni depriv desir despot differ disapprov discontented distribut due dynam either elimin enact encroach end endnot enough enter entitl erect essenc establish even exchang execution exist explicit expos express expressli extens extent fact fall fear feel fellow find first flatteri follow forc free freedom freeli give given goal good govern great greater group grow guarante guard happi heavili hobb hobbesian hold hope howev idea imagin imped import improv inabl includ inconsist inconveni inde inequ influenc iniqu initi instead institut integr intent interest interfer invad invas john join judg judgement juri just justic key kind laid land larg larger last law lead least left legislatur leviathan liberti lie life limit live lock lockean made maintain make man mani may mean mechan men mere might minim miseri moment monarch monarchi movement much must nasti natur near necessari need never new noth nourish obedi odd offer one oppos oppress order origin ought outsid p parent part peopl permiss perpetu pg philosophi pleasur polit poor possibl potenti power preserv prevent progress prohibit proper properti protect provid pursu pursuit put qualiti quit random react reaction reaffirm reason recreat reduc reduct remain remov requir resist restrict revolv right role rule ruler sake scenario second see seen self self-suff sens separ sever short show shown silenc similar simpl simpli singl situat societi solitari somehow sovereign state statement step still strength stretch strong strongest subject substanti suffic system systemat tendenc terror therebi therefor thing thoma thus time toward trade tri truli two ultim unit unlik unrestrain unsatisfi unto upon use versus vest vigor villag violent war way wealth whatsoev whether whim wholli whose will wish without work world would write yet