Essays /

Financial Problems In Local Government Essay

Essay preview

1 LOCAL GOVERNMENT’S FINANCIAL CHALLENGES A fresh look at local government’s deliver obligations and resource requirements is needed. HILDEGARDE FAST makes the case for a differentiated approach. It is common knowledge that many municipalities in South Africa are financially in dire straits. In the public discourse, the focus is often on operational issues such as poor revenue collection, unsustainable debt burdens, and lack of financial management capacity. In seeking to understand the financial challenges facing municipalities, it is important first to take a step back and ask broader questions, namely: What is local government required to do? Where should the resources come from? And is there a need to change the current intergovernmental fiscal system to ensure that local government can do its job? Constitutional mandate Municipalities are given five over-arching tasks in Chapter 7 of the Constitution: to govern in a democratic manner, to ensure the provision of basic services, to promote social and economic development, to promote a safe and healthy environment, and to encourage community participation in local government. The specific functions assigned to municipalities are subsequently listed in part B of schedules 4 and 5 of the Constitution. Delivering on these mandates invariably has financial implications. Whether it is extension of infrastructure for basic services or promotion of economic development, municipalities require resources to perform their constitutional functions. Revenue sources Municipalities have two main sources of revenue, namely own revenue and intergovernmental transfers. Own revenue consists primarily of revenue from property rates and surpluses generated on electricity and water accounts. It is important for municipalities to balance these revenue sources appropriately. A recent study undertaken by the Financial and Fiscal Commission (FFC) has shown that some municipalities do not maximise some revenue sources while simultaneously over-utilising others. This can result in economic distortions. For example, some municipalities collect relatively little from property rates but have high electricity tariffs, which may discourage businesses that rely heavily on electricity from investing in that municipal area. Municipalities need to understand the crucial link between decisions on revenue sources and their attempts to promote local economic development. In considering intergovernmental transfers, the imperative to redistribute resources and alleviate poverty needs to be taken into account, given the historically unequal development of South Africa. It is appropriate for redistribution to be funded primarily from the centre, since municipalities have different levels of poverty and thus varying fiscal capacity to address poverty. There are three general categories of intergovernmental transfers to municipalities, and each is evaluated bel...

Read more


1 13.9 15 1994/5 2 2001/2 23.5 3 4 5 7 80 90 abil abl accept access accord account accur act activ address africa allevi alloc almost also although amalgam and/or anoth answer appli approach appropri arch area articl ask assign attempt attent authoris avail b back backlog balanc bank base basi basic besid bill born borrow broader brought build burden busi calcul cannot capac capacity-build capit care case categori cent centr certain challeng chang chapter choic choos circumst citi clarifi clear close coach collect come commiss common communiti compar complement complet compon concentr conceptu concern concessionari condit confus consid consider consist consolid constitut constraint context continu cost could council councillor creation crucial current data dbsa dearth debt decis deliv deliveri democrat demonstr depart depend detail develop differ differenti difficulti dire direct discourag discours distort distribut district doubt dplg due dynam econom economi effici either elect electr encourag engag ensur entitl environ envisag equit evalu even evid ex ex-homeland exampl exist expenditur experi extend extens extent face fast favour ffc financ financi first fiscal five flexibl focus follow formula framework fresh fulfil function fund furthermor futur gain general generat given go goal govern grant greater greatest ground group grow growth half hand health healthi heart heavili high hildegard hinterland histor homeland household howev human identifi idp impact imper impli implic import improv incent incom inconsist increas inde indefinit indirect infrastructur insight institut integr intend intergovernment invari invest issu job key knowledg lack larg larger leader least legal level levi lie like link list littl loan local locat long long-term look low low-incom main major make manag mandat mangaung mani manner market maximis may mean meant measur mechan met metropolitan minor mobil money most move much municip must name nation natur necessari necessarili need negat neither non non-metropolitan nonmetropolitan number numer oblig obtain often old on-go one oper option other otherwis over-arch over-utilis overal owe paid paper part particip particular past pay peopl per percentag perform perman person place plan play poor portion posit poverti poverty-target premium prerog press prevail primarili prioriti problem problemat process programm prohibit project promot properti proport proportion provid provinci provis public publish question rais rate realiti receiv recent recognis recognit redistribut reduct reflect reform regard region relat relationship reli reliabl remain requir resid resourc respect respond respons result retain revenu revenue-rais right risk road role room rough rural safe safeti sanit scenario schedul second secondari secur see seek serious servic sewerag share short shortag shown signific simpli simultan sinc situat skill social solut soon sophist sourc south southern speak specif specifi spent sphere squeez static step still stipul strait strateg stream strike strong struggl studi subsequ subsidi substanti success suffici suggest summari suppli surplus sustain system take taken target tariff task tax term therebi therefor third three throughout thus time transfer translat transport trend two type uncondit under-resourc under-utilis underpin understand undertaken unequ uniform unlik unsustain urban use utilis vari various view vision water water-born way weak wealthier whether white wish within would written year yet