Essays /

To What Extent Can National Governments Essay

Essay preview

To what extent can national governments influence the outcomes of economic globalization? Discuss with examples?

In a world where trade barriers are blurring, people cross borders relatively easier in comparison with previous times, countries cooperate with one another and even unite and multinational enterprises (MNEs) gather momentum the national governments still exist. National states refer to geographical space preoccupied by a group of people, who share the same cultural values and political governance, language and religion, history and ethics (Dicken, 2003). Recently, their relevance has been questioned because the world experiences fundamental economic transformation (YouTube, 2008). In other words due to globalization a significant number of changes has occurred in terms of competition, integrated trade, capital movements, MNEs and the role of national governments. This essay is going to argue that as a result of globalization, the role of national states nowadays have changed and they assume a number of different positions and perform various functions. The first paragraph is going to show that states contain different cultural dimensions. Then, the second one asserts the view that national governments might be or might not be seen as key regulators in terms of trade, industry and foreign direct investment (FDI) policies. The next section is concerned with the relationship state- MNEs. The penultimate part delineates that states might or might not be seen as competitors while the last one represents them as collaborators. I. States as containers of different cultures

This paragraph is going to examine one of the main sources of differences- culture. Although, globalization has spread in a fast pace, countries still have their specific cultures and institutions. Basically, the international business systems seem to be based on different countries’ values which are diverse in terms of local culture and practices. Hofstede and Hofstede et al.,(1883; 2010), argues that there are four main cultural dimensions:

Figure 1.1 (Hofstede, 1983; 2010)
So, each country has different traditions and culture which represent its uniqueness of national system and politics. States dealing with international business should be aware of such difference in order to prosper and facilitate their merchandising. To illustrate, this appears to be highlighted by Jake’s character in the movie Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps, when Chinese business representatives seem to be fascinated not only by the bargain proposed but also by the fact that Jake speaks their own language and pleased them with a present “American bijou” (Stone, 2010). II. States as regulators of trade, foreign investment and industry Hudson (2001, pp 48-9) asserts that “state activity is necessarily involved in constituting economy and society and the ways in which they are structured and territorially organized.” First of all, states form their mix of policies on the basis of a few key dimensions including their level of development in the globalized economy, the standards of their main institutions, their capital of resources and the proportions of their domestic market (Dicken, 2003).States could influence the economy in two major ways – by using fiscal or monetary policies. The former refers to the use of taxes and government spending, the later to the level of money (high powered money) supplied by the Central Bank (Blanchard et al., 2010). Finally, the policies adopted by states might be applied towards neoliberal market capitalism, which refers to narrow state intervention and more liberal market orientation, or developmental market capitalism, in which the state plays a key role in the economy and might imply restrictions to markets in order to support domestic trade (Whitley, 1999). In the former case, countries are more liberal and their macroeconomic position is likely to be more competitive. A good example seems to be the United States (Dicken, 2003).In the later, government still plays crucial role in the formation of country’s macroeconomics, trying to encourage further economic development, for instance, Japan, Korea and Taiwan (Woo-Cumings, 1999). So, according to the type of capi...

Read more


-9 /abc/maps/index_en.htm 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.5 1.6 12 1883 1970 1980s 1983 1990 1994 1996 1999 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2008 2010 2011 27 3 40 48 77 abil abl abreast access accord achiev acquir action activ actual ad addit adopt advanc advantag affect agreement aim al allianc allur along also altern although america american analyz anoth appear appli appropri area argu around arrang aspect assert asset assist assum assumpt assur attempt attract avail awar b bank bargain barrier base basi basic becom benefit better big bijou blanchard bloc block blur bodi border brasilia brazil british built burden busi candid cannot capabl capit case categori ceas central certain chang charact characterist charlton chen china chines circumst claim classif clear close coincid collabor color combin commiss common compani comparison compet competit competitor comput concern conclud condit connect consequ consider constant constitut constrain constraint contain content contrari contrast control convers convinc cooper corpor cost costa could council countri creat cross crucial cultur cume currenc custom danger deal decad decid decis decreas defin definit delin demand depend deregul develop development diamond dicken differ dimens direct disadvantag discuss distinct divers divert divid domest door dramat draw due dun easi easier ecb econom economi element embodi emerg empir encourag endeavor engag enhanc enter enterpris entri environ environment ep erron essay essenti establish et ethic eu europ european even evid examin exampl except exist expens experi experienc export extent facilit fact factor factori failur fascin fast fdi fdis featur figur figure1.4 final financi firm first fiscal flow forc foreign form format former four framework free full fulli function fundament furthermor gain gather general geograph germani global globe go goal good govern grey gross group growth hand hectic high higher highlight histori hofsted host howev hrist hudson idea ii ii.1 ii.2 ii.3 iii illustr implement impli import impos improv incap incent includ increas independ industri influenc innov insid instanc instead institut integr intel interact intern interpret intervent invest involv inward isol iv jake japan japanes job jurisdict keep key khan known korea krugman labour languag larg last later latin law lawrenc lead least level liber like live local look loosen lose loss low lundan macroeconom main maintain major manag manner mansfield manufactur map market mean member membership merchandis michael might mill milner minimum mix mne mnes modifi momentum monetari money moreov movement movi multin name narrow nation necessarili need negat neglect negoti neoliber network never nevertheless next ni non non-tariff notic nowaday ntbs number object obtain obvious occupi occur offer often one open open-door oper opportun orang order organ orient other otherwis outcom outflow outsid overal own pace pakistan paragraph parliament part particip particular partner payment penultim peopl perform perspect persuad place play pleas polici polit pool porter posit possibl power pp practic preferenti preoccupi present previous price primarili privat process prodig produc product profit proper proport propos prosper protect protection protectionist provid proxim ptas put quantit question quot rapid rate react realli reason recent recours reduc refer region regul relat relationship relev religion remov replac report repres requir resourc restrict result retain rica rise risen rivalri rodriguez role safeti scholar second section seem seen servic sever share show side signific simpli sinc situat skill sleep slight slow societi sourc sovereignti space speak specif spend spread stabil stake standard state status still stimul stone strain strategi street strength strengthen strong structur struggl subject subsidi succeed success supervis suppli support sustain system tabl taiwan take taken tariff tax taxat technic technolog tend tendenc term territori therefor third thompson though three time tobacco toward trade tradit transfer transform transnat tri turn two type unabl undergon undermin understand undertak union uniqu unit univers upon us usa use v valu value-ad vari variabl various vertic view virtu vis vis-à-vi wall wang war way weak welfar well whitley whole within without woo woo-cum word world worth would wto yellow youtub à