MGT 409 Case 1: Arbitrage in the Government Market
1.
In 1991, major discrepancies in the prices of multiple long maturity US Treasury bonds seemed to appear in the market. An employee of the firm Mercer and Associates, Samantha Thompson, thought of a way to exploit this opportunity in order to take advantage of a positive pricing difference by substituting superior bonds for existing holdings. Thompson created two synthetic bonds that imitated the cash flows of the 8¼ May 00-05 bond; one for if the bond had been called at the year 2000, and one for if it hadn’t been called and was held to its maturity at year 2005. The first synthetic bond combined noncallable treasury bonds that matured in 2005 with zero coupon treasuries (STRIPS) that matured in 2005. The synthetic bond had semiannual interest payments of $4.125 per $100 face value and a final payment of $100 at maturity in order to exactly match the cash flows of the 8¼ May 00-05 callable bond if it had been held to maturity. Thompson found the price of this synthetic bond by using this formula:

The ask price of the two bonds were given as $129.906 and $30.3125, respectively. She calculated the number of units needed of the 2005 treasury bond by dividing the semi-annual callable 00-05 coupon rate by the semi-annual 2005 treasury bond (4.125/6). The only part of the equation that she did not have was the number of units needed of the 2005 STRIP. She had to calculate the correct amount in order to imitate the cash flows of the 00-05 callable bond. Thompson did this by using this equation. The final cash flow of the 00-05 bond was $104.125, the final cash flow of the 2005 ...

-05 -51 -52 /6 0.0704 0.3125 00 1 10 100 100.43 101.125 104.125 106 129.906 15 18.1 1985 1991 1992 1993 1995 1998 2 20 200 2000 2005 2014 211 24 25 28 3 30 30.3125 35 36 37 38 4 4.125 409 5 50.7 61.5 71.2 8 98.78 addit advantag affect al almost alreadi also although amount annual anomali anoth anyth appear approach arbitrag aris ask associ avoid back base better bibliographi bid bid-ask bliss bond borrow bought bradford busi buy calcul call callabl capit case cash chang close closer combin come common compani conduct consid converg correct could coupon creat current d date david dealer debat debt decreas deriv desir differ discrep divid doesn drop due earli earlier earn ehud eldeson employe enabl end enough equat essenti establish estim et evalu even event exact examin exampl exercis exist exploit face factor fehr final find firm first five fix flow formula found four furthermor futur gave generat get give given go goe govern hadn happen harvard held high high-interest hold imit immedi impact impli instanc interest introduct investig investor issu jordan jorden journal june kuiper larg larger less like long longstaff look lower main major market mason match matur may mercer method mgt midpoint might mispric money month multipl multitud n.p need negat never new non non-cal noncal normal notic number oblig odd one opinion opportun optim option order overpr par part pay payment per play plenti pocket posit price problem profit provid question r rais rapid rate ration reason redeem redempt refin relat replac research respect respond result right risk robert ronn samantha school second secur seem sell semi semi-annu semiannu sens sept short shouldn signific similar sinc situat smaller sole spread strip striplet studi substitut suggest superior surpris susan synthes synthet take tend term thompson thought tie time treasuri tremend tri two type u.s ultim underpr undervalu unit upsid us use valu valuat ve volatil wait way web wherea whether within without word worth would year zero zero-coupon