Essays /

Macroeconomic Effects Of Government Debt Essay

Essay preview

The purpose of this paper is two-fold. This paper surveys the literature on the macroeconomic effects of government debt. It begins by discussing the impact of federal government debt on aggregate economic activity such as lower output and income, increased demand for output in the short run, inflation and reduced economic growth. The paper then presents the recommended policies that can be implemented by governments to reduce their debts such as the contractionary fiscal policy.

Statement of the problem
The relationship between budget deficits or public debt and real economic activity has sparked a tremendous debate. Federal government deficits negatively affects the aggregate economic activity in several ways for example government deficits causes lower output and income levels since a growing portion of savings would go towards purchases of government debt, rather than investments in productive capital goods such as factories and computers, leading to lower output and incomes than would otherwise occur. A high debt level may result in inflation if currency devaluation is viewed as a solution to debt reduction. Debt levels may also affect economic growth rates. Economists Kenneth Rogoff and Carmen Reinhart reported in 2010 that among the 20 advanced countries studied, average annual GDP growth was 3–4% when debt was relatively moderate or low (i.e. under 60% of GDP), but it dips to just 1.6% when debt was high (i.e., above 90% of GDP. Another effect of government debt is to alter the political process that determines fiscal policy. Some economists have argued that the possibility of government borrowing reduces the discipline of the budget process. A country with a large debt is likely to face high interest rates, and the monetary authority may be pressured to try to reduce those rates through expansionary policy. This strategy may reduce interest rates in the short run, but in the long run will leave real interest rates roughly unchanged and inflation and nominal interest rates higher. Another effect of government debt is the deadweight loss of the taxes needed to service that debt. The debt-service payments themselves are not a cost to a society as a whole, but, leaving aside any payments to foreigners, merely a transfer among members of the society.

An important economic issue facing policymakers during the last two decades of the twentieth century has been the effects of government debt. The reason is a simple one, the debt of the U.S. federal government rose from 26 percent of GDP in 1980 to 50 percent of GDP in 1997. Many European countries exhibited a similar pattern during this period. In the past, such large increases in government debt occurred only during wars or depressions. Recently, however, policymakers have had no ready excuse. This episode raises a classic question: How does government debt affect the economy? That is the question that we take up in this paper.

Increased Demand for Output in the short run
High government debt may lead to an increase in the demand of output in the short run. Suppose that the government creates a budget deficit by holding spending constant and reducing tax revenue. This policy raises households' current disposable income and, perhaps, their lifetime wealth as well. Conventional analysis presumes that the increases in income and wealth boost household spending on consumption goods and, thus, the aggregate demand for goods and services.

According to conventional analysis, the economy is Keynesian in the short run, so the increase in aggregate demand raises national income. That is, because of sticky wages, sticky prices, or temporary misperceptions, shifts in aggregate demand affect the utilization of the economy's factors of production. ( Elmendorf and Mankiw, 1998)

Nevertheless, successive Chairmen of the Federal Reserve Board of America have warned of the possible link between the budget deficit and inflation. A high debt level may result in inflation if currency devaluation is viewed as a solution to debt reduction. If wages are rising due to inflation, fixed amounts of debt can be paid off more easily using cheaper dollars. This helps the debtor but hurts the debt holder, who receives less value in return for ...

Read more


-135 -147 -158 -20 -220 -334 -46 1 1.6 10 100 106 123 129 13 1335 141 178 1896 1920s 1959 1977 1980 1980s 1981 1983 1984 1985 1988 1989 1990s 1991 1995 1997 1998 2 20 2008 2009 201 2010 2013 21 26 27 273 3 4 4/1/95 405 43 450 5 50 522 56 59 60 80 90 92 abel abil abroad abstract accomplish accord account accru accumul across across-the-board activ actual addit administr advanc affect age agenc aggreg aircraft alan also alter america american among amount analysi andrew annual anoth appreci appropri approv approxim april argu argument aris around asid aspect assembl assert assess asset associ assort author avail averag awar b bacchetta back balanc balanced-budget bank banker base becam becom begin behavior ben benefit bennett bernank bernheim better bigger billion blanchard board bolivia bond bond-financ boost borrow bring brook buchanan budget buy call canada capit carmen carnegi carnegie-rochest carrier case caus centuri chair chairmen challeng chang characterist cheaper check chicago choic choos claim classic clear clip coincident collect common compens comput concern conclud conclus confer confid congress connect constant constitut constrain constraint construct consumpt contain continu contractionari control convent cost could countri cours creat credibl creditor crise crisi criteria currenc current current-account cut danger date deadweight debat debt debt-output debt-servic debtor decad decemb decis declin decreas deep default defens deficit demand denomin depart depreci depress describ despit deterior determin determinaci devalu dick dicks-mireaux difficulti digit diminish dip disabl disagre disciplin discuss dispel dispos distort dollar dollar-denomin domest domestically-produc doubl double-digit dougla dramat due dynam earli earn easier easili echo econom economi economist ed edward effect effici either elder elmendorf emerg emphas employ emul encourag endang england ensu episod equilibria eric especi essay etc euro european everyth evid exampl exceed excus exhibit exist expand expansionari expect expenditur expens experi explan export extrem face fact factor factori fall februari fed feder feldstein ferguson fewer final financ fiscal five fix flexibl flight fold forc foreign four friedman function fund furnitur futur gdp general generat germani given go good govern great greater greenspan gregori gross grow growth h hard harm heighten held help henc high higher highway histor historian hold holder household howev hurt hyperinfl i.e iii illusori impact impair implement impli import impos inadequ includ incom increas inde independ index indic individu induc inflat inflationari inflow influenc institut interest intergovernment intern interview introduct invest investor involuntari involv issu italian j jame januari john journal judg juli justifi kenneth keynesian king known krugman labor land larg larger last late latin lawrenc lead leader leadership least leav led leeper less level levi lifetim light like line link literatur loan long long-term lose loss loui low lower lump lump-sum m macroeconom made major make maker mani mankiw margin marri martin match may mccallum mean meet member mere michael might mireaux mispercept moder monet monetari money month moreov mortgag much musgrav must n name nation near need negat neither net nevertheless niall nomin note noth novemb oblig observ occur offic often olivi one one-third one-tim ongo opportun oppos order other otherwis outlay output p paid palat paper part particular passiv past pattern paul payment peopl perceiv percent perform perhap period persist person perspect phenomenon philipp place plan plus polici policymak polit politician poor popular portion possibl poterba power predict prefer present press pressur presum pretax price price-level primarili print privat problem proceed process produc product prospect prosper provid public purchas purpos push put qualifi question quit rais rapid rate rather ratio readi real realli reason receiv recent recipi recommend red reduc reduct refer reinhart relat relationship reli remain report repres requir reserv resid respond rest result resum return revenu review ricardian richard rise risk rochest rogoff role root rose rough rule run said salari sargent save schedul second sector secur seigniorag separ seri servic sever share sharpli shift short shoven side signal signific similar simpl simultan sinc size skeptic small smaller social societi solut someth sometim soon sort spare spark specif spend stabil stagger state statement statist status sticki stock strategi stronger studi subprim subsequ substanti success sum summer suppli support suppos surcharg surplus survey sustain system take tax tax-approv taxpay teacher temporari tempt tend term theori therebi think third three threshold thus time told tool total touch toward trade traffic transfer transit transport treasuri tremend tri troubl turn twentieth twin two two-fold type typic u.s ultim unanim unchang undertak undertaken unemploy unit univers use util valu varieti view volcker voter vulner wage wagner wake wallac war warn way wealth welfar well whether whole wicksel within without woodford work world worri would wrote year yet zeckhaus zero zone