Essays /

Northwest Passage Issue Essay

Essay preview

The Northwest Passage Issue
A frosty hornet’s nest
Kirthana Amirthavasani(

I. Introduction
One of the bittersweet occurrences of present times that seem to affect, in different angles and aspects, the general life of many is the navigability of the Northwest Passage[1]. A sea route that took rather many years to discover with the ardent efforts of numerous explorers of yesteryear, many of whom turned around with hopes lost, others succumbing to the irrationality of the nature’s forces and still others growing complacent too early after making their mark somewhere midway only to turn back homeward, is today the subject of great contention world over. The first attempts to navigate through this golden sea route, which weaves through the archipelagic waters of Canada’s many islands of the north, were made by Spanish explorers who termed this waterway ‘The Strait of Anian’, although the Norwegian Vikings had sailed in and around the area having attempted to set up trade relations with the Inuit groups who were occupying this region[2]. Not much came out of these westward explorations but they were precedents to the many subsequent crusading excursions to these isles. The earliest record of documented evidence is that of John Cabot[3] in 1497 who was commissioned by Henry VII to discover a sea route that would lead forthrightly to the Orient. The expedition carried out by Sir John Franklin deserves special mention here as his ships Erabus and Terror were the largest and were highly equipped with an internal heating system to combat cold[4]. Albeit these advantages, both the vessels failed to withstand harsh forces of nature and all its 129 crew members perished from a combination of cold, hunger, scurvy and lead poisoning. By the late 1500s and the early 1600s, explorers like Martin Frobisher, Jacques Cartier and Henry Hudson had each separately tried their luck in discovering this much coveted route that was claimed to reduce trade distances between Europe and the Orient by over 4000 kilometres[5]. This however, didn’t prove to be successful although landmark territories, which are called after them today, were earmarked. The first successful conquest was in 1906, by the Norwegian explorer Roald Amundsen[6] who took three long years, after being trapped in ice for three whole winters. He announced the success of his exploration through a telegram from the coast of Eagle in Alaska. The possibility of navigating through this strait, although seeming absurd then, for it took an unreasonable three years, was a proposition that remained at the back of many minds. Today, with global warming on the rise, the polar ice caps in and around the Arctic are fast depleting. Despite this environmentally hazardous side effect, it opens up the possibility of navigation through the route. The economical pros seem to outweigh the environmental cons. In what is to follow, we shall take a deeper look at the issues at hand from the legal perspective.

1.1. What is the issue?
What seemed an innocent pristine waterway has today become the subject of much debate. The key issues that have so far been brought to the fore are as follows.

a) The question of sovereignty
A closer look at the map points out that this waterway stretches out for about 900 miles from the north of Baffin Island to the Beaufort Sea[7], which is above Alaska. This brings in the question, ‘Whom does this waterway really belong to?’ Is it the sole sovereign possession of Canada? Can it qualify to be an International strait as America claims? Can an amicable solution be sought between the various arctic players who claim that which according to them is a fair share of the cake? The claim over the natural resources of the region’s seabed, beneath the superficial sea is another bone of contention.

b) The environmental debate
The rapid rate at which the polar ice caps are melting is all but a good sign. They have thinned by half between 2001 and 2007[8]. The toll that it would take on the environment has been given little thought, albeit upping the ante for better prospects in trade and development. This would be the irreversible death sentence to many exotic species like the Arctic fox, the Polar bear and the Pacific walrus[9]. The deep ocean currents are getting warmer, there are massive ice shelves are breaking free and greater albedo feedback loops[10]. Over and above this, the thawing permafrost[11] will unleash tons of methane that scientists refer to as ‘climate bomb’ – something that could increase temperatures at a rapid rate. Allowing shipping vessels and carriers to traverse these paths on a regular basis will create many negative consequences let alone the risk of graver danger. The undisturbed calm of the flora and fauna of the region will become a thing of the past and will leave many species endangered due to human encroachment. The levels of water pollution, which are currently negligible, shall soon catapult. The secondary repercussions of these actions will affect the coastal population leaving them with no option but to migrate.

c) The economical aspect
Every event, whether contentious or not, has either a positive or negative impact on the world economy. The reduction of trade routes by over twenty-five percent[12] is no small thing. This shall lower transportation costs benefiting ship owners, setting off a fall in cost of production benefiting cargo owners, and thereby creating a reduction in the cost price of the product in question benefiting consumers. Other additional costs incurred on the way – Canal fees, fuel costs, to name a few, shall see stark declines. This would entail significant reductions in the cost of one single journey by close to fifteen percent[13] from around $17.5 million to about $15 million thereby saving the shipping industry a ...

Read more


-11 -1592 -18 -322 -46 /book_shelf/26_spilldb.pdf. /facts/operational.html. /history/articles/northwest_passage1957.pdf. /manuscripts/pdffiles/dong.etal.jgr01.pdf. /node/326824. /pdf/ccsciencecompendium2009/ccsciencecompendium2009_ch2_en.pdf. /policy/sub6_2.php. /vo6/no4/north-nord-01-eng.asp. 0 000 1 1.1 10 11 1100 116 12 121 1261 129 13 130 14 145 1497 15 1500s 1587 16 1600s 17 17.5 1723 1724 18 19 1906 1916 1936 1950 1951 1958 1962 1966 1967 1969 1970 1973 1982 1985 1986 1988 1989 1991 1997 2 20 2001 2002 2003 2007 2008 21 22 23 234 24 25 250 26 262 27 276 28 2800 29 3 30 300 308 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 4 4.5 40 4000 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 5 50 555 56 560 58 6 63 666 7 74 76 77 797 799 8 80 87 9 900 92 a/c.n.4/143 abil absenc absolut absorb absurd acceler accept accommod accord acia acquiesc across act action actual ad addit address admin adopt advantag advers affair affect affirm age agre agreement aid aim air alarmist alaska albedo albeit alga alia allow almost alon along alreadi also although ambit america american amic amidst amirthavasani among amount amundsen analyz ancillari andrea angl anglo anglo-norwegian anian announc anoth answer ant approach approb archipelag arctic ardent area argu arguendo argument aris around articl asid ask aspect aspir assert assess assum atmospher attach attempt attract attribut author avail await awar away awppa b b.a back background baffin balanc bald ballast bare base baselin basi basic bay bear beaufort becker becom behind believ belong belt beneath benefactor benefit best betray better bigger bilater biodivers biota bittersweet black bleak blight blyton bodi bolster bomb bone boon boost border borger borgerson bottom bounti breach break brew bring britain brought brunt build bulk bureaucrat c cabot cake calcul call calm came campaign canada canadian canal cannot cap cape carbon cargo carri carrier cartier case casual catapult catch caus certain certainti cgs ch chanc chang channel chapter charact charron cheap cheaper circumpolar circumst citizen claim clark classic clean clear climat close closer coast coastal coastlin cold combat combin come command commerci commiss common compar compel complac complet complex comprehens con concentr concern conclus condit conduc conjur connect conquest consecut consent consequ consid constant constitu consum consumm contact content contenti contigu continent continu contrari contribut control convent cooper core corel corollari cost could couldn council countri cours court cover covet craft creat crew crisi criteria cross crude cruis crusad ct current custom customari cynthia d damag danger dark death debat dec decad decemb decis declin decomposit deep deeper defenc defin definit delic delimit delta demarc demast demonstr depend deplet deserv design despit det deterior deterr develop diagon didn differ difficult dilemma diminish dioxid diplomat direct disast discharg discov discriminatori disintegr dissip distanc disturb doc doctor document doesn doggett dome donat done doth dougla dr draw dread dream due eagl earli earliest earmark earth easili eco eco-system ecolog econom economi economist ecosystem ed effect effort eight either element eleven emit enabl enact encompass encroach end endang endors energi enforc enid enough ensu ensur entail entir environ environment envtl equip erabus establish etch europ even event eventu everi evid exact exampl except exclus excurs exempt exercis exhaust exil exist exot expect expedit expend expenditur expens explain exploit explor expos extens extern extrem exxon eye fabl face fact factor fail fair fall famous far farfetch fast fauna feder fee feedback fellow fifteen final find fire first fisheri five floor flora follow food footprint forc fordham fore foreign foremost forget form former forth forthcom forthright forward four fox fragil frangibl franklin franklyn free frequent frobish frosti frozen fuel fume further futur g gallon gase gen general generat generos geneva geo geograph gestur get given global go golden good goodwil gordon govern grade grant graver graviti great greater green greener greenhous grey griffith grisbadarna ground group grow guard habitat hagu half hand handl happen harbor hard harder harm harsh hasten hazard head healthier heat hemispher henri high high-valu higher histor histori hitherto hmrad hold holm homeward hon hope horn hornet hous howev hudson human humbl hundr hunger hunter hurri hyderabad i.l.m ibid ice ice-cov ice-fre icebreak icj ident identifi ignor ii iii illeg illicit immedi immemori immin impact imper impli implic implicit import impress imprint improv incid includ inclus incom incorpor increas incur indel indic indiffer indiscrimin induc industri ineffect inhabit inher inim initi innoc insert inspit instanc instead institut insurmount int integr inter interdepend interest intern introduct intrus inuit inuit-nors invari irrat irrepar irrespect irrevers isl island isn issu iv j jacqu jag januari jarashow jeopard joe john journal journey junctur jurid jurisdict justic justif justifi k.m keep key kill killer kilometr king kirthana l l.c land landmark larg largest last late later law lawyer lead least leav led legal less let level lie lieuten life like limit line link listen littl live ll.b local long longer look loop lost lot lower luck mackenzi made magic main maintain mainten major make mammal man manag manhattan mani manifest map marin maritim mark martin mass massiv may mccullough mcgrath mean measur meet melani melissa melt meltdown member mention merchantmen merci methan method metr michael middl middlepowermanship midway migrat mike mile million mind minimum money mother move much multifari multilater must myopic nalsar name narrowli nat nation nativ natur nautic navig near need negat neglig negoti nest never newli news nitrogen no.2 non non-discriminatori normal nors north northern northwest norway norwegian note numer nunavut observ obstruct occupi occur occurr ocean offshor often oil old one one-tim open oppos opposit option order orient origin other otter outcom outweigh overlook owner p pace pacif palpabl panama part parti particular pass passag passageway past path peopl percent perfect peripher perish permafrost perman permiss perri persist person/organization/product perspect persuas pertain petroleum pg pg.13 pg.15 pharand place plausibl player pli point poison polar polici pollut popul popular portray pose posit possess possibl potenti power precari precaut preced predict prerog presenc present preserv press prevail preval prevent previous price primarili principl pristin probabl product progress propos proposit pros prospect protect prove proven provid provis purpos pursu put qualifi question quit quot rais ramif rang rapid rate rather reach read realiz realli reason recogn recognit record recov recoveri redress reduc reduct refer regard regener regim region regul regular relat relev remain remaind rep repercuss report requir research residu resist resourc respect respons rest restor rev rever revisit reward right rise risk roald rob rock rogu role room round roundabout rout rubbl rush s.c safer sail sanction satisfact satisfactori save scale scenario schizophren schledermann school scientif scientist scope scott scurvi sea seab seabird seal seal/caribou secondari secretari section secur sediment see seem seen self sensibl sentenc separ sept serv set sever shade shall share shelagh shelf shelv shift ship shorten shorter shown side sign signific simpli sinc singl sir situat small smith snow soil sole solut someth somewher soon sought sound sourc sovereign sovereignti space spanish speci special speedi spent spill spill/chemical spilt spirit spread ss stake stand standard starbuck stark state statement status statutori still straight strait stretch string struck student studi subject submarin subsequ substanti success succumb suffer suffic suffici suggest suit sulfur superfici superior supra surfac surround surviv sustain sweden synonym system take taken tale tamper tank tanker tast technolog telegram temperatur tenac term territori terror thaw therebi thick thin thing thought thousand threat threaten three thus time titl today toll tom tomorrow ton took total trade tramp transcend transfer transit transport trap travel travers treati tri true trust truth turn twenti twenty-f two tynan u u.n u.s uk un unaccustom uncanni unceas unclo uncorrupt understand understood undisturb unexpect unexpend unfamiliar unfurl unimagin uninterrupt unit univers unleash unless unlik unpreced unreason unrestrain untouch untoward unviabl unwis up upon upto us usag use usual utmost v valdez valid valu various vehement verac verhaag verit vessel viabil viabl view vii vike violat viz vol vol.38 vol.50 vulner walrus warm warmer warn wast water waterway wave way weav week well westward whale whether white whole wide width wildlif winter within without withstand word world would wouldn y year yes yesteryear youth zone