Essays /

Not Applicable Essay

Essay preview

Globalization and Anti-Globalization:
An Indian Perspective

If one is going to talk about globalization, the term globalization must be defined. That’s the easy part. Globalization is defined as free cross-border flow of goods, services, capital, labour, information, ideas, intellectual property. Everything in fact. Defined thus, globalization is more than mere trade reform. Globalization has a descriptive component, as well as a prescriptive one, with the latter more important than the former. The former is simply a factual statement. Over a period of time, globalization has increased in importance and countries have become less insular. It is possible to argue that one encountered such globalization also in the 19th century. There are however two differences between earlier phases of globalization and the present one. First, the speed of change is faster. Second, because most flows (including capital) are private ones, governments have become less powerful in controlling or determining the shape of globalization.

However, there is a prescriptive element to globalization as well. The cross-country empirical evidence is fairly robust that more open economies tend to perform better than more insulated ones. Borders are after all artificial boundaries, created by governments. They are irrelevant for purposes of efficient resource allocation. The logic of Adam Smith’s specialization and division of labour does not become any less compelling because artificial national boundaries have been erected. Here is a quote from Wealth of Nations. “By means of glasses, hotbeds and hotwalls, very good grapes can be raised in Scotland, and very good wine too can be made of them at about thirty times the expense for which at least equally good can be brought from foreign countries. Would it be a reasonable law to prohibit the importation of all foreign wines, merely to encourage the making of claret and burgundy in Scotland?” The point about efficiency gains need not be belaboured. If it does not make sense for Delhi to produce everything that it consumes, it does not make sense for India to produce everything that India consumes.

Why is this logic generally not accepted? It is not enough to argue that in the late 1950s and early 1960s, the government adopted a policy of inward-looking and import-substituting industrialization. Why is there extensive empathy for this import-substituting mindset? It is possible to identify a few inter-related strands, some speculative, others less so.

First, there was the colonial legacy and the identification of the Swadeshi movement with the Independence struggle. Progeny did not necessarily interpret Swadeshi in the sense that the Father of the Nation had. Second, warped policies self-perpetuated themselves in the sense that export pessimism and the resultant foreign exchange constraint, inherited from World War II, became a permanent constraint. The Foreign Exchange Regulation Act (FERA) of 1947, which gave semi-permanency to rules under the Defence of India Act of 1939, is an instance. The Preamble to this 1947 version merely stated that this was “an Act to regulate certain payments, dealings in foreign exchange and securities and the import and export of currency and bullion.” By the time the FERA of 1947 was replaced and tightened by the FERA of 1973, the Preamble had changed. The Preamble now stated that this legislation was necessary “for the conservation of the foreign exchange resources of the country and the proper utilization thereof in the interests of economic development of the country.” The late 1960s to the mid 1970s was the heyday of this Planning Commission kind of control mindset. The point however is that there was considerable public support for this mindset.

Third, perhaps innately, the Indian mind identifies itself much more easily with hierarchical and control structures. It is thus accepted that the government should control and monitor various things. Fourth, the sense of being economically marginalized in the global world was reinforced by a sense of political isolationism, the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM) not having amounted to much. It was difficult to empathize with US foreign policy and this extrapolated into striving for self-sufficiency in food, the PL-480 episode involving Lyndon Johnson and Indira Gandhi acting as a trigger. Conversely, it was easier to empathize with Soviet foreign policy and the apparent economic success of the Soviet Union was also a trigger. Fifth, as a counter factual, the scenario might have been different had the development paradigm been based on agriculture and light and sma...

Read more

Keywords

-02 -1991 -2000 -480 -91 -94 000 1939 1947 1950s 1960s 1970s 1973 1980s 1990 1991 1993 1998 1999 19th 2 20 200 2001 2002 2005 2015 26 30 300 35 36 4.5 40 5 52 65 7 8000 absenc absolut accept account achiev across act ad adam add addit adequ administr admit adopt affect age agenda ago agre agricultur ahead airlin align all-india alloc also alway american amount andhra anoth anti anti-glob anyon apart appar applic appropri approv apt area argentina argu argument around artifici ascrib asian ask assumpt attain attempt avail awar back backward bad bailout balanc bar base basi becam becom begin belabour beneficiari benefit bengal better bias bihar bimaru border born boundari brazilian break brighter broad broad-bas broaden brought budget bullion bureaucraci burgundi busi call campbel canadian cannot capit capita car care cartel case cash cell centr centuri certain chain chang characterist charg china chines civil claret class climb clive close club coffe collaps collect coloni come commiss communist compani compar comparison compel compens competit complain complet compon composit concern concess conclus condit confid congress consensus consequ conserv consid consider conspicu constitut constraint consum consumpt context contribut control convent convers convert cost could count counter counterfactu countervail countri cours creat credit crisi criteria criterion crore cross cross-bord cross-countri cross-subsid crutch currenc current custom cut cynic d dacoiti danish data de de-reserv deadweight deal debat decis decision-mak defenc defin definit degre delhi deliber deliveri demand democrat demonstr depend descript despair despit determin develop differ differenti difficult diffus direct dis dis-intermedi discourag discuss disinvest dispar dissent distribut district ditto divid divis document doesn domest done doubt downsiz downturn draft drink driven drop due dunkel durabl earli earlier easi easier easili east eastern econom economi edg educ effect effici element elimin elitist els empath empathi emphas emphasi empir employ encompass encount encourag english enhanc enough ensur enter entir entiti episod equal erect especi essenti ethnocentr euphem even eventu everi everyth evid exampl except exchang excis execut exempt exhaust exhibit expect expens experi explicit explos export extens extern extrapol facil fact factual fair far farmer faster father favour fdi feed fera fertil fifth figur financ financi first fiscal five flow flush focus fold follow food forc foregon foreign formal former fourth fragment free french front function furnitur gain gandhi garment gatt gave general generat generi genuin german get given glass gleefulli global go good govern government-guarante grape group grow growth guarante gujarat hammer handl hang hang-up happen hash haul haven head health healthcar heavi help henc heyday hierarch high higher home hong hotb hotwal household howev hugh hurt hype idea identif identifi ii implement implicit import import-substitut incent includ incom increas inde independ india indian indic indigen indira indirect industri ineffici inevit infant inflat influenc inform infrastructur infrequ inherit initi innat inordin input instanc instead insul insular intellectu intensifi inter inter-rel interest intermedi interpret interv introduc invest investor involv inward inward-look irrat irrelev isol isolation issu italian japanes job johnson judiciari kind know known kong korea labour larg large-scal last late latter law lead learn least led legaci legisl legislatur less level liber licenc licens light like limit line link list literaci littl live lobbi local logic long longer look lord lose loss lost lower lyndon made madhya maharashtra main major make mani manufactur margin market market-determin market-ori materi may mean member mention mere messag mid middl might miller million mind mindset minist minor mistak moment money monitor monopol mortal move movement movi much much-hyp munch must myopia myopic nam name nation nda necessari necessarili need negat net new ngo non non-agricultur non-align non-compar non-glob non-liber noth notwithstand nowher nss number object obtain obvious often oligopolist one open oper opportun organ orient orissa other otherwis outsid overal overdu ownership p/e paper paradigm parliament part parti particular passeng pastri pattern pay payment pds pen pend peopl per perceiv perform perhap period perman perpetu perspect persuad pertin pessim phase phone physic pick pin pl place plan point polici policy-mak polit politi politician poor popul popular populist posit possibl post post-independ postpon poverti power pradesh pre pre-condit preambl prescript present price primari privat pro pro-rich pro-urban probabl problem process procur produc product profit progeni prohibit proper properti propos prospect protect protest provid public publish purpos purview push put quantit question quo quot rais rajasthan rang rare rate rather ratio ration raw reach reaction realiz reap reason receiv recent reciproc reduct reflect reform regress regul reinforc relat reliabl remain replac replic repres requir reserv resist resourc restrict result return revenu rice rich right risk road robust rough rs rule run rupe rural sampl sanit satellit save say scale scam scenario scheme school scotland scrap secess second sector secur seed segment self self-perpetu self-suffici sell semi semi-perman sens sequenc servic set seventh shakeout shape share show sick signific simpli sinc singapor sit sixth slowdown small small-scal smith so-cal social societi solitari someon sometim somewher sound south soviet special specul speech speed spent spill squeez ssi stamp state statement status stay still strand stream strive strong structur struggl subject subordin subset subsid subsidi substitut success suffer suffici sui support sure surfac surplus survey swadeshi syndrom system taiwan take taken takeov talk tariff tax teacup tend term textil thank theft therefor thereof thing third thirti though three thus tighten time timefram togeth top total toward trade trade-off transfer transmiss travail trigger true tv two understand undesir unfair unilater union unit unlik unorgan unrealist up urban us use user usual util uttar valid valu various vast vat version vest vintag visibl vocal vote voter want war warp water wealth well well-known went west wheat whether whole whose widen wine within without won word work world worst would write wto year yet zero