The phrase workers’ participation is used loosely to encompass various forms of workers’ participation in decision making, usually at the enterprise level. They complement other forms that may exist at the industrial or sectoral level and the national level, such as bodies for tripartite cooperation. The types of workers’ participation arrangement differ widely with regard to their functions and powers, ranging from informal individual employee suggestion schemes to co-determination of certain matters by workers’ representatives together with management. The mechanisms used for encouraging employee participation vary so widely that it is impossible to review them fully here. The main forms that have attracted recent interest, particularly in the field of work organization, are reviewed below; to these could be added the historical example of self-management by workers in former Yugoslavia. As particularly relevant today, joint safety and health committees are examined as a special form of workers’ participation within the larger labour relations context.

The idea of workers’ participation arose in Europe, where collective bargaining has usually been at the branch or industry level; this often left a gap of employee representation at the enterprise or plant level, which became filled by bodies such as works councils, works committees, enterprise committees and so forth. Many developing countries have also adopted legislative initiatives with a view to having works councils or similar structures set up (e.g., Pakistan, Thailand, Zimbabwe) as a means of promoting labour-management cooperation. The relationship of these bodies to trade unions and collective bargaining has been the subject of considerable legislation and negotiation. This is reflected in a provision of the ILO Workers’ Representatives Convention, 1971 (No. 135), which states that where both trade union representatives and elected representatives exist in the same undertaking, measures shall be taken to ensure that the existence of those representatives is not used to undermine the position of the trade union (Article 5).

Direct Participation

Workers may participate in decision making either directly themselves or indirectly through their representatives – trade unions or elected employee representatives. Since the 1980s, there has been a spread of direct participation by workers, if the term participation is understood as the exercise of any influence on their work or how it is to be carried out. Thus workers may “participate” in work-related decisions not only when there is an institution, such as a quality circle, at the workplace. Accordingly, a simple exercise of work enrichment may be a form of promoting direct participation of workers.

Direct participation may be on an individual basis – for example, through suggestion schemes or “enriched” work. It may also be on a group basis – for example, in quality circles or similar small-group activities. Teamwork in itself constitutes a form of group-based direct participation. Direct participation may be integrated into decisions about daily work, or it may take place outside daily work, such as in a voluntary quality circle that cuts across the group structure habitually used. Direct participation may also be “consultative” or “deliberative”; research by the European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions has explored this particular aspect in some detail (Regalia and Gill 1996). With consultative participation, employees are encouraged and enabled, either as individuals or members of a group, to make their views known, but it is up to management to accept or reject their proposals. Deliberative participation, on the other hand, places some of traditional management responsibility in the employees’ hands, as in the case of teamworking or semi-autonomous work groups wherein some authority has been delegated to the workers.

Works Councils and Similar Structures; Co-determination

The term works councils describes arrangements for the represen-tation of employees, usually at the plant level although they also exist at higher levels (company, group of companies, industry, European Union). The relationship to trade unions is often delineated by legislation or clarified by collective agreement, but tensions between these institutions sometimes remain all the same. Extensive use of works councils, sometimes called workers’ committees, cooperation committees or otherwise, is well established in a number of European countries, such as Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany and the Netherlands and, under the impetus of Directive No. 94/45/EC of 1994 on European works councils, can be anticipated to spread in that region for large enterprises. Several Central and Eastern European countries, such as Hungary and Poland, have enacted legislation to encourage the emergence of works councils. They are found as well in some countries in Africa, Asia and Latin America; part of the post-apartheid labour law reform in South Africa, for instance, included establishing a form of works councils alongside trade union structures.

The possible powers of works councils are best illustrated by the example of Germany, although in some ways it is a unique case. Weiss (1992) describes the works council in that country as the form of institutionalized representation of interests for employees within an establishment. A works council enjoys certain rights to information, ...

1 135 1970s 1971 1980s 1989 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 5 94/45/ec abil abl above-ment absenc accept access accid accompani accord achiev across act action activ ad addit adequ admit adopt advanc advis affect afford africa age agenda agreement allow alon alongsid also alter although alway ambiti america among amount anoth anticip apartheid applicalbl appoint apprais approach appropri arbitr area aros around arrang articl asia aspect assess assign assist attend attract attribut austria author autonom autonomi awar back bargain base basi becam began behind belgium belief believ best better beyond bind bipartit board bodi bound branch built busi call canada cannot capit carri case categor central certain chanc chang character chosen circl civil clarifi clear climat closur co co-decis co-determin co-manag co-work coincid collect come command comment commit committe communic communiti compani compar competit complaint complement compos conceiv concern conclud concret condit conduct confin conflictu confus connect consid consider constitut consult context continu contribut control convent cooper coordin corpor cost could council countri cours cover coverag creat creation creed criteria critic cut daili deal death debat decis decision-mak declin defenc defin definit degre deleg delib delin democrat denmark densiti depend depriv deriv describ design desir detail determin develop differ difficult direct disabl disappear discrimin diseas disenchant dismiss distinct durabl duti e.g earli earlier easili eastern econom effect effici effort either elect elsewher emerg emphasi employ employe empow enabl enact encompass encourag end enforc engag enhanc enjoy enlarg enough enrich ensur enterpris enthusiasm entitl environ equal especi essenti establish establishment-level etc europ european evalu event examin exampl exclud exercis exert exist expect expens experi expert expir explor express extend extens extent extra facil facilit fact factor failur fall far far-reach fast featur field file fill financi finland firm first first-lin fix flexibl floor follow forc foremost form formal format former forth foster found foundat four framework franc frequent fruit fulfil fulli function fund gap general german germani get gill give given go govern grade greater greec group group-bas guarante guidelin habitu hand harder hazard health heed held help high high-qual higher histor hoc hold holiday holl honour hope horizont hostil howev human hungari idea ident identifi illustr ilo immin impact imparti impetus implement impli implic import imposs improv in-servic incid includ inclus incorpor increas incur inde indic indirect individu induc industri ineffect influenc inform initi injuri innov insist inspect inspector instanc institut institution insuffici integr intercompani interdepartment interest introduc introduct invalid invest investig involv ireland issu itali japan japanes job joint kaufman kingdom kleiner known labour labour-manag lack larg larger later latin law layoff lead leader leas least led left legal legisl legitimaci less level liabil liabl lie life like limit line link littl live loos lose low made main maintain make manag management-l mandat mandatori mani manner manual marker matter may mean measur mechan member membership mention middl might minor model monitor moribund move much multi must nation necessari necessarili negoti netherland nevertheless new non non-manag non-manu non-particip none normal north norway notabl note notion number numer oblig obligatori observ occup off-lin offic often on-lin one oper opinion order organ organiz origin other otherwis outsid owner ownership ozaki paci pakistan paper parallel part particip particular pay payment peac peopl perform performance-rel phenomenon phrase place plan plant play poland polit posit possibl post post-apartheid potenti power power-shar practic predomin prejudici prepar prerequisit prerog presenc present pressur prevent principl prior prioriti privat problem process produc product programm project promot propos protect provid provinc provis purchas purpos put qualiti quebec question qwl race rais rang rank rank-and-fil rapid rare rate rather rational reach realiz reason receiv recent recognit recommend reconcili record red red-tag reduc redund refer reflect reform refus regalia regard regim region regul regulatori reilli reimburs reject relat relationship releas relev religion remain remuner report repres represen represen-t represent requir research reserv resourc respons restrict result retali retent return review right rise risk role rule run safeti satisfact satisfactori scandinavia scandinavian scheme schregl scope scrape second secreci sector see seem seen select self self-determin self-fulfil self-manag semi semi-autonom sens separ serv servic set sever sex shall share sharehold shield shop shop-floor short shortcom shown shrink shut shut-down side signific similar simpl sinc situat skill small small-group smaller social someth sometim sought south spain special specif specul sphere spot spread staff stakehold standard start state status still stimul stoppag strateg strategi strengthen strong structur studi subject substanti substitut success suggest supervisor supervisori support survey sweden swedish system tag take taken tangibl task tation team teamwork technic technolog tend tendenc tension term thailand theori throughout thus time today togeth tool top total toward tqm trade tradit train traine transfer transplant trend tripartit turn two type undermin understood undertak unfound union uniqu unit unlik upgrad upon use usual valuabl vari variabl variat various ventur vertic view visibl vogel voic voluntari voluntarili walkaround way weiss welfar well western wherein whether wide widen widespread within without work work-rel worker worker-manag workplac world would year young yugoslavia zimbabw