Essays /

Not Either An Experimental Doll Essay

Essay preview

Ryan Shellady
Professor Mtisi
October 31st, 2012
Placing Fault: A Look at Determining Who is to Blame for Lily Moya’s Downfall in Not Either an Experimental Doll The Separate Worlds of Three South African Women
In today’s Western culture, it is hard to imagine a world without education. Adults and children alike view education as a common practice that is essential to everyday life. For Lily Moya, this is not the case. In Not Either an Experimental Doll, edited by Shula Marks, letters of correspondence reveal a relationship between Dr. Mabel Palmer, a well-known European supporter of black education, and Lily Moya, a girl growing up in apartheid South Africa. Lily writes to Palmer requesting acceptance into a school. Due to Lily’s amusing writing style, Palmer feels a connection to her. In turn, Palmer decides to find a way to fund Lily’s education. Throughout the letters, Lily alludes to this idea that she desires a more intimate friendship with Palmer; however, Palmer continues to assertively state that the relationship Lily seeks is impossible. In the end of the correspondence, Dr. Palmer releases her sponsorship from Lily’s education which means Lily can no longer attend school. For these two reasons, some critics will argue that Palmer is to blame for Lily’s mental breakdown at the end of the book. These people are mistaken; Mabel Palmer’s actions are not to blame for what happens to Lily. Fault lies in the differing cultures between Lily and Palmer, and in Lily’s stubbornness, egocentrism, and her inability to follow simple instructions.

It is easy to infer that there are inevitable differences in culture between a European woman in her seventies and a fifteen-year-old African girl living in apartheid-ruled South Africa. In the introduction of the book, editor and expert in the field of South African studies Shula Marks articulates that the cultural differences between Lily and Dr. Palmer make for a difficult understanding of correspondence etiquette.

Not surprisingly, the world of the busy academic was remote from the concerns of a lonely and aspirant fifteen-year-old in Umtata. For Lily, still living in a world in which misfortune was explained in terms of individual wickedness and witchcraft, Mabel’s failure to reply could only be the result of the evil counsel of her advisers (Marks 18).

Lily has been raised in a place where academia is not prominent. To understand why Dr. Palmer didn’t rep...

Read more


-122 -145 113 121 128 133 136 138 143 161 16th 18 183 1949 1951 1987 2012 26th 28th 31st 59 6th 87 91 94 abil absolut absurd academ academia accept accomplish action activ actual address adolesc adult advis affair africa african age aggress alik allud alon alreadi also amus anglican anguish annoy anoth answer anticip anxieti anyth apartheid apartheid-rul appar appear appoint argu arriv articul ask aspir assert assist attempt attend back background beg behavior best bit black blame bloomington bomback book boundari break breakdown built bullhead busi call cannot caretak case cathol caus center certain chang charact children choic circumst cite claim clear close colleg come common communic complet comprehend concern conclus confront connect consid continu correct correspond could counsel cours creat critic cultur daili date deal decid deeper deepli defi demis demonstr depend depress describ descript desir detail determin devot didn differ difficult difficulti direct disappoint display disrespect distress doll downfal downward dr drastic due durban earliest easi ed edit editor educ egocentr either end enough entail enter environ essenti etho etiquett european even ever everyday evil exampl expect experi experienc experiment expert explain expos face fact fail failur fair far fault februari feel field fifteen fifteen-year-old find finess first flaw focus follow forget forgiv forgiven friend friendship fund gain get girl glad goe great greater grew grow guilt happen hard heartstr help helpless hope hostel howev hurt idea identifi ignor imagin impati imposs impress inabl inclin indiana indianapoli individu inevit infer inform insist instanc instruct intens interact interest intim introduct isn januari jump justifi keep kind know knowledg known lack laid larg later lead leav lectur less lessen lesson letter level lie life like lili list littl live ll lone long longer look loss lost m mabel made main make makhanya mani mark matricul matter may mean men mental mention merciless might misfortun misguid mistaken money moreov moya mrs mtisi much must nativ need neglect neither never non non-person nonsens note notic number obstin obvious occas occup octob old one orphan other outlook page paideia palmer paper paragraph particular patienc peopl percept person pictur place play plead pleas pocket point poor possibl practic pressur previous print problem proclaim profession professor promin promis protegé psychiatr punctual purpos quick quit quot quotat rais rather realiz realli reason receiv recent reciproc relationship releas religi religios remain remark rememb remind remot repair repli request reserv respect respond respons result return reveal revok righteous role romant routin rule ryan say scheme school second see seek seen self self-cent self-right send sens sensit separ seventi sever shall shelladi show shula sibusisiw silenc simpl simpli smart societi sole sometim sorrow south spent spiral sponsorship state stay still stop stubborn student studi style support sure surpris sway swift sympathi sympathis take task term termin therefor thing think though three throughout time today told tone trait treat tri truli tug turn twice two ultim umtata understand understood upon use varianc view violat wait want way weak well well-known went western whether wicked wish witchcraft withdraw without woman women word work world worri wors would write written wrong xhosa year yet zulu