Socio-spatial stigmatization and the contested space of addiction treatment: Remapping strategies of opposition to their disorder of drugs

Abstract

In recent years, the Not-In-My-Back-Yard (NIMBY) phenomenon has become increasingly prevalent with regard to harm reduction sites, addiction treatment facilities and their clients. Drawing from a case study of community conflict generated by the relocation of a methadone clinic into a rapidly gentrifying neighbourhood in downtown Toronto, Canada, this article offers a unique analysis of oppositional strategies regarding the perceived (socio-spatial) ‘disorder of drugs’. Based on interviews with local residents and business owners this article suggests the existence of three interrelated oppositional strategies, shifting from a recourse to urban planning policy, to a critique of methadone maintenance treatment (MMT) practice, to explicit forms of socio-spatial stigmatization that posited the body of the (methadone) ‘addict’ as abject agent of infection and the clinic as a site of contagion. Exploring the dialectical, socio-spatial interplay between the body of the addict and the social body of the city, this article demonstrates the unique aspects of opposition to the physically, ideologically and discursively contested space of addiction treatment. Representations of the methadone clinic, its clients and the larger space of the neighbourhood, this paper suggests, served to situate addiction as a ‘pathology (out) of place’ and recast the city itself as a site of safe/supervised consumption. The opening of Methadone clinic was not very appealing for the local residents of Cork town because this is not what they wanted in their backyard when they first moved into their neighbourhood. Introduction: East central downtown was considered as a wasteland, sooner or later this area was a place for social services, homelessness shelters, and drug treatment facilities. But later on this area transformed itself to a “Creative city”, it soon turned out to be a urbanized village. Later they decided to bring back a methadone clinic into the community but the community members disapproved. MMT was administered orally in liquid forms. The first strategy imposed by the Corktown was portraying them as victim in which the government just used them to dump an...

-417 1 17 1st 20 2008 27 3 33 382 39 395 40 425 45 50 58 60 66 7 82 9 abject abstract accept addict administ administr advanc affect afford agenc agent allison almost also ambigu among amount analysi analyz anyth appeal area aren argu aros articl ask aspect associ assum attach attitud autonom awar back background backyard bar base becom beforehand behaviour benefit better big blame bodi boom booster border boundari box breed bring brought build busi call canada care carri case categori central chang characterist chi chi-squar citi client clinic code collect communic communiti community-bas compar complex compos conclus condemn conflict confront consid consum consumpt contact contagion content contest contribut control cork corktown crba creat creativ critiqu data decay decentr decid declin decreas demograph demonstr densiti depart depend descript deserv desir develop dialect didn differ differenti diffus disapprov discours discurs discuss disord divers dmh document doesn downtown draw drug dump east economi educ effect effort elimin empow end environ equival essenti establish evalu even exclus exist expel explicit explor express facil facilit factori fail familiar fear featur feedback feel find first form formal found freeli further generat gentrifi geographi get good gotten govern great group guid half harass harm hat health henc hiv/aids hold home homeless hous human ident ideolog ill illustr impact implant implement implic import impos impress incom increas independ individu industri infect infecti inform initi interact interplay interrel interrog intervent interview introduct issu juic junki knew know kyong landscap larger later lee legal letter liber life like liquid list literatur litter live local locat loiter long look loui low mainten major make mark mechan meet member mental methadon method methodolog might mingl mmt model moral morally-inform mount move narc natur near need negat neglect neighbor neighborhood neighbour neighbourhood never new newli nimbi nimbyism non non-product not-in-my-back-yard notif notifi notion number offer often one open open-end oppos opposit option oral outcast outlin outreach owner paper particip patholog patient peopl perceiv percept perspect phenomenon phone physic place plan point polici pollut popul portrait portray pose posit post post-nimbi poverti practic predictor presenc presum preval previous primal privat process product profit project promot properti propos protest provid psychiatr public pure purpos put qualit qualiti quantit question quit race rapid realli reason recast receiv recent record recours reduct regard regardless relat relationship reloc remap represent research resid residenti respond respons result review right safe/supervised safeti said sampl satisfact say second seem semi semi-form sens serv servic set share shelter shift show sibley signal site situat small smith social social-spati societ societi socio socio-spati soon sooner space spatial speak specif spoil sponsor squar start stigma stigmat still strategi strong studi suggest sung supervis support survey system tape tape-record tend term theori therefor thing third thought threaten three time togeth toronto toward town trace transform treatment turn type unabl unattain understand unfortun uniqu urban use user usual valu verbal victim view villag vital want wasteland welcom well weren white wit within without won worri worthi would yard year zippay